Trains.com

CANADIAN PASSENGER RAILROADS - Let's talk! BYOB ........

29375 views
375 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    January 2001
  • From: US
  • 304 posts
Posted by andrewjonathon on Friday, March 4, 2005 10:36 PM
I assume 1968 is a typo right because didn't railway service on Newfoundland last until 1988?

My first decade of life nearly coincided with the last decade of the Canadian as a CP passenger train. I have one vivid memory of the Canadian from my childhood. I grew up in the countryside about 1/4 mile from the CN branchline that went south from the CP Rail mainline near Kamloops to Kelowna in BC. At a town called Armstrong it connected with a CPR branchline. The two branchlines and the mainline effectively made a large triangle. Anyway, I could always hear the freight trains coming and I would race down the driveway to the rail tracks to wave or at night I'd fla***he porch light on and off - even at 4:00AM. My family thought I was nuts. Naturally, in at that time the branchline only had freight trains. One day, I heard a train coming but when I had raced out to the tracks imagine my surprise to see a gleaming stainless steel passenger train go rolling by loaded with people, dome cars and all. It was the only time to my knowledge that it ever happened. I suppose the train must have been detoured via the two branch lines due to a derailment on the CPR mainline. I don't know why since the mainline must have had other derailments and the train was never detoured at other time. Either way, seeing the Canadian on a small branchline like that made an impression I never forgot.
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Saturday, March 5, 2005 9:03 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple:

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!


=============================================================
andrewjonathon
QUOTE: My first decade of life nearly coincided with the last decade of the Canadian as a CP passenger train. I have one vivid memory of the Canadian from my childhood. I grew up in the countryside about 1/4 mile from the CN branchline that went south from the CP Rail mainline near Kamloops to Kelowna in BC. At a town called Armstrong it connected with a CPR branchline. The two branchlines and the mainline effectively made a large triangle. Anyway, I could always hear the freight trains coming and I would race down the driveway to the rail tracks to wave or at night I'd fla***he porch light on and off - even at 4:00AM. My family thought I was nuts. Naturally, in at that time the branchline only had freight trains. One day, I heard a train coming but when I had raced out to the tracks imagine my surprise to see a gleaming stainless steel passenger train go rolling by loaded with people, dome cars and all. It was the only time to my knowledge that it ever happened. I suppose the train must have been detoured via the two branch lines due to a derailment on the CPR mainline. I don't know why since the mainline must have had other derailments and the train was never detoured at other time. Either way, seeing the Canadian on a small branchline like that made an impression I never forgot.


What a great train story - and so vivid too. That's the kind of "stuff" that the movie, "Polar Express" is made of. Childhood surprises with memories that are everlasting. Thanx for sharing your thoughts with us!!
===================================================
passengerfan
QUOTE: My Newfoundland vacation was in 1968 the last year the narrow gauge ran. CN operated three Maritime trains from Montreal at that time The OCEAN between Montreal and Halifax the CHALEUR between Montreal and Gaspe and the SCOTIAN between Montreal and Truro where it split into two trains one going to N. Sydney and Sydney and the other continuing on to Halifax. Besides these the CPR operated the ATLANTIC LIMITED between Montreal and St. John, N.B. via Maine.


And here we are today with VIA Rail carrying on with the "Ocean" running between Montreal and Halifax with six round trips per week (Tuesday's "off"). My wife and I traveled VIA Rail's version of the "Atlantic" in 1990, which was pretty close to the end of the line for that route through Maine. To this day, while traveling aboard VIA Rail, we come across train crew who we remember from the days of the "Atlantic."

Recent announcements from Ottawa indicate that the "Chaleur" may be discontinued for budgetary reasons. That route, Montreal to Gaspe, is one I have had on my "list" for solo trips - but somehow haven't gotten to it - yet. I guess I better get moving!

For those who don't know - the "Chaleur" departs Montreal as part of the "Ocean" then splits at Matapedia for the journey up to Gaspe. On the return, it rejoins the "Ocean," in what always seems to be a very long and laborious process, again at Matapedia. From what I have witnessed - the "Chaleur" has a consist of baggage car, one or two coaches, a Skyline dome, and one or two bedroom cars - all seasonal dependent.

passengerfan: Thanx for the continuing input!
============================================

How about some input from those who have traveled the "Skeena" from Jasper to Prince Ruppert in particular. Also, would like to get some feedback from anyone who has recently boarded VIA Rail's RDC's on Vancouver Island - called the 'Malahat' running between Victoria and Courteny.

My last trip aboard RDC's was in March of 1999 on a roound trip between N. Vancouver and Lilloeet, BC. BC Rail operated daily service on what it called the Cariboo Prospector - a great run all the way to Prince George. What scenery! Just fantasic all the way.

I was disheartened to learn of the selling off of that route with their RDC's. I've tried to keep track of those cars ... but it gets a bit difficult as they wind up "here or there." My HO model railroad features two very accurate LifeLike BC Rail RDC's, with accurate numbering. I run those along my mountain route - replete with lakes (Anderson and Seton ... for those "who know"!), With every run, my thoughts go back to a very enjoyable trip ..........



Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    January 2003
  • From: Mexico
  • 2,629 posts
Posted by egmurphy on Saturday, March 5, 2005 12:03 PM
In 1956 we traveled from New Haven up to Sydney, NS by train. Took the ferry across to Port Aux Basques, Nfld. Then on by train as far as Clarenville. Unfortunately I was young and not yet into trains, and my memories of the trip are about nil. What a waste.

I do have a framed B&W print of the " Newfie Bullet". Does that count?

My only ' adult' experience riding trains in Canada came when I was working up in Ft McMurray, Alberta, and had a couple of chances to ride the old "Muskeg Mixed" on the NAR from Ft Mac down to Edmonton. But that's hardly in the same league as the passenger travel you guys are talking about.


Regards

Ed
The Rail Images Page of Ed Murphy "If you reject the food, ignore the customs, fear the religion and avoid the people, you might better stay home." - James Michener
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Saturday, March 5, 2005 3:02 PM
egmurphy
QUOTE: In 1956 we traveled from New Haven up to Sydney, NS by train. Took the ferry across to Port Aux Basques, Nfld. Then on by train as far as Clarenville. Unfortunately I was young and not yet into trains, and my memories of the trip are about nil. What a waste.

I do have a framed B&W print of the " Newfie Bullet". Does that count?

My only ' adult' experience riding trains in Canada came when I was working up in Ft McMurray, Alberta, and had a couple of chances to ride the old "Muskeg Mixed" on the NAR from Ft Mac down to Edmonton. But that's hardly in the same league as the passenger travel you guys are talking about.


Ed - In 1957, I was riding the New Haven between New London, CT and NYC on a regular basis over the weekends. I NEVER knew one could ride from anywhere in Connecticut to Sydney, NS! But, then again - why not??!! Trains were still going virtually everywhere in the U.S. and Canada in those times.

All of my childhood train riding experience were aboard U.S. railroads, so those tales are for another day ...... but I know what you mean about "waste."

The Newfy or Newfie Bullet counts for lots - and to have a framed print "double counts."

Tell us MORE about the Muskeg Mixed - sounds like you have all kinds of stories that surely "qualify" for the intent of this discussion!

Thanx for the contribution and let's keep it going ........
Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    February 2005
  • From: Vancouver Island, BC
  • 23,330 posts
Posted by selector on Saturday, March 5, 2005 11:06 PM
Folks, at siberianmo's kind invitation in another forum, I would like to join your group.

I am a retired Armed forces officer who took the VIA tain from Ashcroft, BC to Vancouver in late February of 1974. My destination was the reruiting centre!

As I recall, the 300 km trip took some seven and a half hours through the Fraser Canyon. A little basic arithmetic will derive an average speed of about 45 kph, or about 26 mph. I was not impressed, but only because I had driven the same route many times on the highway opposite the railway. That is, the scenery was 'old hat'.

My most recent trip was a year ago between Ottawa and Toronto....this time in First Class. It was a muuuuuuch better experience, believe me.

I will offer that I like trains in general, with no preference for freight or pax. I really like the hissing, clanking, thrumming, and ground shaking of steam locomotives, and since the only ones that still run are on the 'tour' trains, I am very much a supporter of them. For example, once I find out how to do it, I will donate some funds to the refurbishment of the Royal Hudson. I would die a happy soul if I could stand at the side of the road and experience it thunder past at a regulator setting of 50% and cut-off of 35% with 220 lbs of head on it. As Tim the Toolman would growl, "Ooh, oohhh, ooohhh!"
  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 20,096 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Sunday, March 6, 2005 3:49 AM
My trips to Newfoundland and PEI were about 1966-1969, and during that period the Ocean split going to both Halifax and North Sidney. I only got to ride the Charlottetown mixed once going from the island, since on my next business trip the passenger service had been replaced by a bus, about 1966 or '67. The bus also used the ferry, which still handled freight cars/
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Sunday, March 6, 2005 11:47 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple:

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!

==================================================
Must be a good day for Gremlins - for this is the 3rd time I've attempted to post a message. Get all the way to the end only to have it disappear when submitted! Hmmmmmm - must be those Canadian freight fans!
==================================================
DaveKlepper
QUOTE: My trips to Newfoundland and PEI were about 1966-1969, and during that period the Ocean split going to both Halifax and North Sidney. I only got to ride the Charlottetown mixed once going from the island, since on my next business trip the passenger service had been replaced by a bus, about 1966 or '67. The bus also used the ferry, which still handled freight cars/


Dave (and passengerfan) Between the two of you, I'd say you have the market cornered on Canadian passenger rail travel spanning several decades. Keep those memories coming!

What kind of equipment did you travel aboard while on the Charlottetown mxed?
===================================================
Selector
QUOTE: Folks, at siberianmo's kind invitation in another forum, I would like to join your group.

I am a retired Armed forces officer who took the VIA tain from Ashcroft, BC to Vancouver in late February of 1974. My destination was the reruiting centre!

As I recall, the 300 km trip took some seven and a half hours through the Fraser Canyon. A little basic arithmetic will derive an average speed of about 45 kph, or about 26 mph. I was not impressed, but only because I had driven the same route many times on the highway opposite the railway. That is, the scenery was 'old hat'.

My most recent trip was a year ago between Ottawa and Toronto....this time in First Class. It was a muuuuuuch better experience, believe me.

I will offer that I like trains in general, with no preference for freight or pax. I really like the hissing, clanking, thrumming, and ground shaking of steam locomotives, and since the only ones that still run are on the 'tour' trains, I am very much a supporter of them. For example, once I find out how to do it, I will donate some funds to the refurbishment of the Royal Hudson. I would die a happy soul if I could stand at the side of the road and experience it thunder past at a regulator setting of 50% and cut-off of 35% with 220 lbs of head on it. As Tim the Toolman would growl, "Ooh, oohhh, ooohhh!"


Selector - Your reference to Fraser Canyon brings back some memories. On Friday, January 3rd, 2003, while aboard the "Canadian" bound for Vancouver a landslide struck the train at about 2:30 AM. The incident took place just a bit north of Boston Bar and didn't cause any serious injuries to people or equipment. Apparently the portion of the slide that hit the train, struck the dining car, with very little visible damage. Of course, the track was closed for about six hours.

That delay turned out to be something like making lemonade out of lemon - for we all got to view scenery that would have been otherwise totally in darkness had the schedule not been interrupted. The memories will live!

Traveling VIA! has always been a positive experience for me. The only thing I manage to screw up with is planning the meals in advance. I'm not one to dine heavily in the mornings or at lunch, so something less filling is fine with me. Unfortunately, I either forget or try to make arrangements too late for the VIA folks to accommodate me. Must be my ever increasing "senior moments"!

Steam engines are fascinating indeed. They pass through these parts every now and then as the focal point for rail excursions, largely Union Pacific run. Although I am a diesel fan, dyed in the wool so-to-speak, those steamers really can (and do) attract a crowd. Ever wonder about the public's affection for watching trains - but when it comes to suporting them, oh well .......??

By the way, I too am a retired military officer - perhaps we should get together by e-mail and exchange some experiences.

Thanx for "dropping in" and don't be a stranger!
=========================================

VIA Rail's "Malahat" and "Skeena" - any takers??

Regards!
Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    July 2004
  • From: Ontario - Canada
  • 463 posts
Posted by morseman on Sunday, March 6, 2005 3:08 PM
To Siberianmo: You mentioned a while back that Via Rail might be
getting back on CP tracks. I doubt it. Several years ago they
tried to get back but the Canadian govt refused them permissioon.
Gov't told Via they gave it up years ago and the Rocky Mountaineer is
now operating very profitably on this route & if Via got back then it would
cut into the Rocky Mountaineer's profit and forother reasons.

Everyone talks about the Canadian . When I worked with Cp many,
many years ago I had a pass from Montreal-Vancouver & took
numerous trips with my wife and kids, The pass was no good
on the Canadian though & had to take the Dominion. The same
route but took about 12 hours slower if I remember correctly.
Equipment was the same except there were a few older cars which
were painted silver trying to match the stainless steel cars.
I'm trying to think back now & I think some of the older cars were
baggage cars and a few coaches.
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Sunday, March 6, 2005 3:34 PM

Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    May 2003
  • From: Abbotsford BC Canada
  • 300 posts
Posted by athelney on Sunday, March 6, 2005 10:13 PM
On the subject of Budd cars (RDC - type) - for information to siberianmo - we have 3 Budd RDC's at the West Coast Heritage Park in Squamish BC -- #14 , #21 and #33 all ex BC Rail - although none are at present operating - we have equipment available to make at least one operational - hopefully by the end of 2005 .

For selector -- info re CPR Hudson #2860 - she is waiting for repairs to start - soon - parts are ordered and a plan is underway -- you can donate to the Hudson fund from the WCRA website www wcra.org -- or send direct to the WCRA at the address on the site -- we have about $180.000 promised so far but more is obviously needed.
Also underway at the site is a restroration of the ex CPR car 'Alberta " - to be used on the excursion train when finished
2860 Restoration Crew
  • Member since
    February 2005
  • From: Vancouver Island, BC
  • 23,330 posts
Posted by selector on Sunday, March 6, 2005 10:42 PM
Thanks for the replies and info, siberianmo and athelney. Good to know that others are keeping their fingers on the pulse of Canadian rail ops, past and present.

Siberinamo, would be glad to compare notes/swap stories. Pls contact me at my profiled e-mail address.
  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 20,096 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Monday, March 7, 2005 4:21 AM
The Charlottetown mixed had a GP-7 or GP-9 on the head end. With train boiler. The coach was next, and it was one of the standard smooth side lighweights, when I rode it painted into the white and black with red lettering scheme that was being applied to nearly all CN (and CV and GT) passenger equipment. It did not have the lower capacity and more comfortable seats of the "day-nighters" but did have normal reclining seats. That was the only passenger equipment on the train (other than the boiler in the locomotive). Then came about 15 assorted freight cars, almost but not quite the limite that could be handled on the ferry at one time. I think there was also a caboose at the rear, but I am not certain. The entire train went on the ferry, with the locomotive doing the switching and boarding last on the center track, somewwhat behind the center point and with freight cars ahead, the first to be pushed off on the Mainland. A good lunch was served upstairs in the ferry dining room, and I do not remember if this was included in the price of the ticket. but I think it was, because I had roomette from Moncton to St. Hycinth (an eastern suburb of Montreal where the organ firms of Casavant Freres and Le Tournau or located).

One other memory is riding the Firday and Sunday afternoon only Grand Trunk Portland ME - Montreal train. After the B&M-CP Alouette Budd RDC and the overnight Red Wing were discontinued, this was the only way to get from Boston to Montreal by train, unless one went via Springfield and the Montrealer, or Albany and the Laurentian. A B&M Budd car from Boston to Portland, taxi with other connecting pasengers to the GT Station, really just a platform, discovery of the rebult heavyweight parlor "Alouette" on the rear with meal included in the upgrade, and a mostly rear platform ride except when enjoying the meal of good sandwiches and hot coffee. I was very lucky to get the upgrade, since there was no other meal service, and he only had one no-show so I was lucky indeed! Power again was a GM road-switcher, and the other cars were the regular CN lightweights, about five or six.

After the Charlottown mixed became freight only, instead of a caboose, and old wood closed-platform combine was used, because the train still carried pass riders who used it for points that the replacement bus didn't reach.
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Monday, March 7, 2005 11:06 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple.

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!



===================================================
Good morning!


morseman
QUOTE: To Siberianmo: You mentioned a while back that Via Rail might be getting back on CP tracks. I doubt it. Several years ago they
tried to get back but the Canadian govt refused them permissioon.
Gov't told Via they gave it up years ago and the Rocky Mountaineer is
now operating very profitably on this route & if Via got back then it would
cut into the Rocky Mountaineer's profit and forother reasons.

Everyone talks about the Canadian . When I worked with Cp many,
many years ago I had a pass from Montreal-Vancouver & took
numerous trips with my wife and kids, The pass was no good
on the Canadian though & had to take the Dominion. The same
route but took about 12 hours slower if I remember correctly.
Equipment was the same except there were a few older cars which
were painted silver trying to match the stainless steel cars.
I'm trying to think back now & I think some of the older cars were
baggage cars and a few coaches.


morseman: Are you REALLY a Morse Man - as in morse code/cw operator? The reason I ask is that in a life long ago (mine), I was a radio operator (speed key qualified/certified) and spent many years at sea communicating this way.
Just curious.....

Now to the important "stuff" - trains, as in Canadian!

The information I provided could be rated somewhere between gossip and credible - depending on more variables than I can document. I do concur that the day probably is not going to arrive when the "Canadian" travels once more on the CP trackage. Moreso the political and funding than any other reasons ....

Insofar as the Rocky Mountaineer is concerned, here are my thoughts in a nutshell: When boarding, no doubt someone will tell you to leave your wallets at the door!

I won't dispute the wonderful experience those day trips may be - but unless and until VIA Rail stops crossing Canada - my wife and I will continue traveling in the Park Car(s)!

And why shouldn't everyone talk about perhaps one of the finest, most heralded passenger trains in North America? The "Canadian" is well worth the talk.

Oh yes, I never saw those painted cars you referred to - but I've seen pictures and read about them. Rather cheesy up close - but okay from a distance. Nothing matches the real Budd stainless steel beauties - nothing!

Thanx for the input!
==================================================
athelney
QUOTE: On the subject of Budd cars (RDC - type) - for information to siberianmo - we have 3 Budd RDC's at the West Coast Heritage Park in Squamish BC -- #14 , #21 and #33 all ex BC Rail - although none are at present operating - we have equipment available to make at least one operational - hopefully by the end of 2005.


athelney - I'd love to see 'em, although I seriously doubt our travels will be taking us to Heritage Park in the near future. I have the book, "RDC The Budd Rail Diesel Car," by Donald Duke and Edmund Keilty. Just can't get enough of those cars - whether in pictures or for real. Ill have to see if I can track down those RDC numbers in the book - they really have quite a roster - but of course only up until publication date - 1990.

Appreciate the info!
==================================================
selector
QUOTE: Posted: 06 Mar 2005, 22:42:15
Thanks for the replies and info, siberianmo and athelney. Good to know that others are keeping their fingers on the pulse of Canadian rail ops, past and present.

Siberinamo, would be glad to compare notes/swap stories. Pls contact me at my profiled e-mail address.


selector - Will do!
====================================================


DaveKlepper
QUOTE: The Charlottetown mixed had a GP-7 or GP-9 on the head end. With train boiler. The coach was next, and it was one of the standard smooth side lighweights, when I rode it painted into the white and black with red lettering scheme that was being applied to nearly all CN (and CV and GT) passenger equipment. It did not have the lower capacity and more comfortable seats of the "day-nighters" but did have normal reclining seats. That was the only passenger equipment on the train (other than the boiler in the locomotive). Then came about 15 assorted freight cars, almost but not quite the limite
that could be handled on the ferry at one time. I think there was also a caboose at the rear, but I am not certain. The entire train went on the ferry, with the locomotive doing the switching and boarding last on the center track, somewwhat behind the center point and with freight cars ahead, the first to be pushed off on the Mainland. A good lunch was served upstairs in the ferry dining room, and I do not remember if this was included in the price of the ticket. but I think it was, because I had roomette from Moncton to St. Hycinth
(an eastern suburb of Montreal where the organ firms of Casavant Freres and Le Tournau or located).

One other memory is riding the Firday and Sunday afternoon only Grand Trunk Portland ME - Montreal train. After the B&M-CP Alouette Budd RDC and the overnight Red Wing were discontinued, this was the only way to get from Boston to Montreal by train, unless one went via Springfield and the Montrealer, or Albany and the Laurentian. A B&M Budd car from Boston to Portland, taxi with other connecting pasengers to the GT Station, really just a platform, discovery of the rebult heavyweight parlor "Alouette" on the rear with meal included in the upgrade, and a mostly rear platform ride except when enjoying the meal of good sandwiches and hot coffee. I was very lucky to get the upgrade, since there was no other meal service, and he only had one no-show so I was lucky
indeed! Power again was a GM road-switcher, and the other cars were the regular CN lightweights, about five or six.

After the Charlottown mixed became freight only, instead of a caboose, and old wood closed-platform combine was used, because the train still carried pass riders who used it for points that the replacement bus didn't reach.


Dave - About all I can add to what you've provided is, "Thanx for YOUR memories!"

I always think of "mixed" trains abominations - but no doubt, if that was the only way to go, that is what one traveled aboard. Obviously, making money was at the heart of it all - so wherever and whenever costs could be trimmed, those "mixed" jobs made sense. But to look at them - well - abominations!

Thanx again for your contributions!
==================================================

I'm going to check into the "Coffee Shop" for a bit - see you later!
Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Monday, March 7, 2005 11:42 AM
selector: I checked your profile and no e-mail address came up ......
Suggest you try mine and we'll get the show back on track (so to speak!).

[banghead]
Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    July 2004
  • From: Ontario - Canada
  • 463 posts
Posted by morseman on Monday, March 7, 2005 1:27 PM
To SIBERIANMO
I mentioned about the Dominion being lot slower than the Canadian
This was account it made quite a few more local stops along the way.

Just aa note about my morse career. I was always interested in RR's
since a kid & someone started up a morse & teletype school
in my neighbourhood. I studied Railroad or American morse,
a bit different from your International morse. I applied to CPR
and got a job as an operator in the CP telegraphs. Most of the
messages sent or recvd were telegrams etc., but still quite
a bit of railroad msges. I applied for a job on the RR line but
as I was dating at the time, & the job coming up would be out on
the prairies I passed it up. When the morse era ended
I went into working jobs Telex, Radio (CBC) monitoring &
regulating, Broadband, etc. etc. CP telecoms joined up with
CN to become CNCP Telecoms, thence to Unitel, Thence
ri AT&T Canada & it's now Alstream & has no connections
with CN or CP. I took early retirement at 55 and with my
wife spend every year taking a cruise & combining it with
a train trip.
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Monday, March 7, 2005 3:07 PM
Morseman - Sounds like you and I are destined to share a condo in a tar pit somewhere - you know, for those who posses skills no longer needed - much less understood.

We're kind of like those people who lost out when buggy whips lost their market! Ah, pity the poor anvil salesman too.

I could continue - but won't.

Now to "legitimize" the use of this discussion topic:

I have an HO consist of CN's smoothside coaches, but I couldn't find any affordable green/black ones for the Dominion paint scheme. So, I settled on the black/white. They are in my display case and look good anyway! The "feature" of course is the CP maroon/grey with beaver logo "Canadian" powered by twin EMD E-8 "A" units. Yes!

See ya.

Cheers!
Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    August 2001
  • From: US
  • 240 posts
Posted by gbrewer on Monday, March 7, 2005 3:18 PM
Ah memories.

My first ride on a train in Canada was the Canadian. It was just before our son started school so it would have been about 1988. We had driven a VW camper to Banff National Park. I talked my wife into going on to Calgary and taking the train to Vancouver and back. (The train still traveled over the CP at the time).

I had the upper birth while wife and son shared the lower. It is the only time in my life I have ever traveled in a Pullman open section. The trouble with the upper is that you can’t see out. To compensate, I stayed in the dome of the Park car until long after dark. Behind me the brakeman was regaling several young Japanese girls on a package tour with tales of the rails.

The Park car really brought back memories of times when I rode the original California Zephyr and later the Rio Grande Zephyr.

In the diner, I remember the three of us being seated with an elderly lady touring Canada from The Isle of Man. Some day, I must go there.

I rode the Royal Hudson steam train twice including the last year that the Royal Hudson locomotive operated. What a shame it no longer runs.

The BCRail Caraboo Prospector was an interesting ride. I can’t say that I liked the RDC all that much, but the scenery was quite good.

The last trip we took was a ride from Toronto to Niagara Falls. The train itself wasn’t much nor was the scenery, but I still enjoyed it. When we arrived, it was like the 1960 in the US. We felt like we may have come the historic way, but a way hardly ever used anymore.
  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Central Valley California
  • 2,841 posts
Posted by passengerfan on Tuesday, March 8, 2005 3:32 AM
I am hoping to complete my Canadian Rail riding this year with a trip on the WP&Y. Then I will be able to say that I have ridden trains in all of the Canadian Provinces and one territory. My trip this year will also be the most expensive as it entails a cruise ship and the ARR from Seward to Anchorage and Anchorage to Fairbanks.
I have ridden just about every other train in Canada except for the Rocky Mountaineer and that is planned for as early as next year.
  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, March 8, 2005 6:20 AM
Hey you guys, there is a lot more to VIA RAIL than the Canadian using original Budd equipment. Here in Québec, starting out of Montréal there are four trains; the Abiti goes to Senneterre Qué., the Saguenay goes to Jonquière Qué., the Océan goes to Halifax NS. and the Chaleur goes to Gaspé Qué.. The locomotives are F40PH often doubles or even tripled on very long trains. The Océan and the Chaleur leave Montréal as one train with two or three locomotives. In Matapedia Qué. the train is split up in two distinct trains, the Océan going south east through Campbelton NB ant the Chaleur going through Bonaventure Qué. where I spend my summers atlantic salmon guiding.
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Tuesday, March 8, 2005 8:01 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple:

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!


===================================================
Good morning all! Looks like we have a continuing "thing" going, which is what I had hoped for .........

GBrewer
QUOTE: Ah memories.

My first ride on a train in Canada was the Canadian. It was just before our son started school so it would have been about 1988. We had driven a VW camper to Banff National Park. I talked my wife into going on to Calgary and taking the train to Vancouver and back. (The train still traveled over the CP at the time).

I had the upper birth while wife and son shared the lower. It is the only time in my life I have ever traveled in a Pullman open section. The trouble with the upper is that you can’t see out. To compensate, I stayed in the dome of the Park car until long after dark. Behind me the brakeman was regaling several young Japanese girls on a package tour with tales of the rails.

The Park car really brought back memories of times when I rode the original California Zephyr and later the Rio Grande Zephyr.

In the diner, I remember the three of us being seated with an elderly lady touring Canada from The Isle of Man. Some day, I must go there.

I rode the Royal Hudson steam train twice including the last year that the Royal Hudson locomotive operated. What a shame it no longer runs.

The BCRail Caraboo Prospector was an interesting ride. I can’t say that I liked the RDC all that much, but the scenery was quite good.

The last trip we took was a ride from Toronto to Niagara Falls. The train itself wasn’t much nor was the scenery, but I still enjoyed it. When we arrived, it was like the 1960 in the US. We felt like we may have come the historic way, but a way hardly ever used anymore.


GBrewer - Memories are what "it" is all about - of course, riding those trains must come first in order to HAVE those memories!

While I have never booked a berth in a Pullman type sleeper, all of my adult overnights have been in bedrooms. However, I have spent many, many hours in the Park Car observation dome - mainly traveling between Montreal (great city!) and Halifax (another great place!). The conversations that one cannot help eavesdrop on run the spectrum of talk. As the night closes in - somehow there's a special feeling one gets while watching the loco headlights widen and narrow while passing under overpasses - all the while listening to the "hum" of the human voices around you. Kinda nice and most special indeed.

By the way - you obviously have some great memories of dome car travel - just the thought of Zephyr travel ....... wow. But - they weren't Canadian! Sorry[:)]

As with you, being seated in the diner not simply to enjoy the food, but to meet other travelers is a plus for sure. I've met many, many people with whom I still keep contact with. All of those relationships began in the dining car of either the "Ocean" or "Canadian." Train travelers are a breed apart - or something like that!

What a shame that BC Rail folded the tent. I have some friends in Vancouver and Pembroke who are devasted at the discontinuance of the Cariboo Prospector. Insofar as the Royal Hudson goes - never had the opportunity to travel behind her. Maybe one day she'll be back on the line .....

RDC's? I love 'em. Really do. When I lived and worked in the Boston, MA area, I traveled daily aboard those wonderful Budd cars - into and out of North Station. Ahhhhhhhh. But back to Canadian RR's - the BC Rail RDC's were quite different on the inside (as you know) and I think the appointments were well done. The food service, in my experiences, was excellent. Just love the memories!

Thanx for the thougths! Keep 'em coming.
===================================================
passengerfan
QUOTE: I am hoping to complete my Canadian Rail riding this year with a trip on the WP&Y. Then I will be able to say that I have ridden trains in all of the Canadian Provinces and one territory. My trip this year will also be the most expensive as it entails a cruise ship and the ARR from Seward to Anchorage and Anchorage to Fairbanks.
I have ridden just about every other train in Canada except for the Rocky Mountaineer and that is planned for as early as next year.


passengerfan - I'm looking at a ball cap with the White Pass & Yukon Route emblazoned on it. Also have a decorative bottle of water - souvenir - with the logo. All delivered to me by a friend who traveled that route last year with his wife. They were on an Alaskan cruise and just raved about the experience on the train. So - hopefully for you it will be as rewarding as all of the other experiences you have chronicled for us thus far!

Insofar as the Rocky Mountaineer goes - well, my thoughts on it are documented a few times within these pages! Nevertheless - it will be an experience - and isn't that what most of us are seeking!

Thanx again!
====================================================
EdgarJowsey
QUOTE: Hey you guys, there is a lot more to VIA RAIL than the Canadian using original Budd equipment. Here in Québec, starting out of Montréal there are four trains; the Abiti goes to Senneterre Qué., the Saguenay goes to Jonquière Qué., the Océan goes to Halifax NS. and the Chaleur goes to Gaspé Qué.. The locomotives are F40PH often doubles or even tripled on very long trains. The Océan and the Chaleur leave Montréal as one train with two or three locomotives. In Matapedia Qué. the train is split up in two distinct trains, the Océan going south east through Campbelton NB ant the Chaleur going through Bonaventure Qué. where I spend my summers atlantic salmon guiding.


Edgar - Welcome aboard! Great having new thoughts and speaking for those who have been "hanging out" on these pages - thanx for yours!

By the way - I invite you to browse through what has been contributed - start at page one. You will find lots and lots of information about eastern Canada and the trains (past and current) associated with that part of the country. In fact, one of my contributions discusses the "Chaleur" and the somewhat interminable split at Matapedia. Take a look - I think you'll enjoy the "talk"!

I have not experienced the "Abiti" or "Saguenay," but hope one day those trains will become part of my passenger rail experiences. Most of my Quebec experiences have been restricted to Montreal proper. My wife and I have been there at least once a year since 1990. Just love that Central Station - really do. I get real pleasure from just taking in the sights and sounds, while having a cup of coffee - a glass of beer - etc. Puts me in the right frame of mind for a train trip - each and every time!

Again, welcome to our group and keep your thoughts coming! (And don't forget to check out the pages before this one ........)

Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    May 2003
  • From: Abbotsford BC Canada
  • 300 posts
Posted by athelney on Tuesday, March 8, 2005 11:12 AM
One trip I made back in 1974 was - Toronto - Niagra Falls on a couple of Budd cars -- does it still run ? if so what kind of equipment ? -- we travelled down in the cab with the engineer (one of the Vanalstine twins who were both engineers ) -quite a trip ( unauthorised), but then both my friend & I were British Rail employees - railway folk seem to stick together despite being from different countries.
2860 Restoration Crew
  • Member since
    September 2002
  • From: CANADA
  • 126 posts
Posted by Grinandbearit on Tuesday, March 8, 2005 7:23 PM
athelney, the only Budd cars running now are the ones on the Sudbury-White River run and the Malahat on Vancouver Island.
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Wednesday, March 9, 2005 9:50 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple:

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!



===================================================
Good morning all!

I see we have two contributions - thanx to grinandbearit and athelney!
====================================================
Riding VIA Rail's Ocean with the Renaissance equipment

Thought perhaps I should document some of my experiences and opinions regarding the subject - Renaissance equipment.

I won't delve into the history of these cars - it is available elsewhere and has been hashed and rehashed sufficiently. VIA Rail KNOWS just how many of us feel regarding the "Euro" cars and has embarked upon a course to "make them right." 'Nuf said.

In October of 2004, I took a solo round trip between Montreal and Sackville aboard the "Ocean." This is a great opportunity for someone who likes riding trains to spend two nights on board and complete the round trip in a relatively short period of time. Sackville, NB is a great place for the turn around in that one can disembark the eastbound train at about 12:30 PM and board the westbound at about 4:30 PM the same day. Four hours in Sackville can be a pleasant experience. (For me, I have friends there - so the time really passes quickly.)

Montreal's Central Station is a great place to "people watch." This station is situated in the heart of downtown and is a connection point for the Metro (subway), commuter trains and VIA Rail. The waiting area is huge and extremely active with people hustling from here to there. Add that to the train announcements (chimes and the bilingual arrival/departure messages .... ) and it becomes a magical place (at least for me and people who share these insights).

The huge train board hangs in the center of the waiting area and there are 'sidwealk' cafe type places to eat and drink along one side of the room. There are times that I have forgotten that I'm inside! There is also an extensive underground shopping area, with eateries, etc. It is simply an intriguing place to visit. Makes waiting for the train a positive event. Well done, Montreal and VIA Rail! (Really CN should get the credit, from what I've been told.)

Boardings take place at a lower level and are well orchestrated. Once situated in the bedroom car, my practice is to take some photo's of the gleaming train waiting for departure. There is sufficient time for that as those with bedrooms board first - generally a 45 minute headway.

The Renaissance cars are very attractive to look at and they are quite modern inside and out. Well done and well appointed. However, I'm "spoiled" and dearly missed the Budd stainless steel beauties - especially "my" Park Car and Skyline car and ...........

My bedroom, even for a single passenger, was designed for two. Very accommodating. The fare charged was 15% higher than what a single bedroom would normally cost. So, that wasn't bad. The room had a toilet inside a separate compartment along with the sink and vanity. Nicely done.

With the seating in place, I found that I'd be traveling backwards! Didn't care for that at all. Further investigation revealed that every other bedroom had seating facing forward - the luck of the draw! Next time, if there is a next time, I'll know to ask for a bedroom with an ODD number - for they have seats facing the direction of travel.

I checked out the inside of the train with a walk through. The dining car is really well done - with seating for four on one side and for two on the other. Nice touch. A very pleasant environment. The cars on either side of the dining car contain the "kitchen" and a lounge area. The "community" aspect of those lounges leaves a lot to be desired. Aside from the space being relatively cramped, there aren't that many places to sit and if you are seated - it seems that you are "expected" to drink something. Hmmmmmm, I just didn't think it was meant for me and my newspaper. Maybe I'm wrong - but that's the impression I got. Cold - is a good description.

The train departed Montreal with 3 loco's and 19 cars. Oh, how I missed sitting up in the Park Car observation dome - just love looking out at the long string of cars. Best I could get with Renaissance was a view from the side windows when rounding the curves ...... pity.

The evening meal was a disaster. It took 75 minutes for it to reach my table and it was - well, unfit for consumption. I left it and feasted on crackers and beer and dessert. Very disappointing.

The meal preparation is somewhere "above" micro-wave and convection oven cooking - wherever that may be. There's a term for it, but I've forgotten what it is. Call it "glorified airline food." Fortunately, breakfast was served to me in my bedroom, so I didn't have to visit the diner again for more of the same .....

At Matapedia, the Gaspe train - "Chaleur" split and went its way north. That process took much longer than normal. I was told by one of the staff that the coupling between Renaissance and Budd cars is not compatible. So, whatever they have to do in order to keep those cars connected, takes quite a lot of time to disconnect. Hmmmmm - one would have thought THAT should have been attended to prior to putting them into service in Canada.

The continental breakfast was more than ample and kind of nice sitting there, dining, and watching the scenery zoom by - albeit, backwards.

When my car attendant noticed that I was spending lots of time walking in the narrow passageways of the bedroom cars, with my camera, he suggested that I find a seat forward in the coaches. He told me that many bedroom passengers have been unhappy with the lack of a place to gather and have been encouraged to sit up front. As long as those seats are empty - it isn't a problem. I took him up on the offer and wasn't sorry at all.

The coaches are splendid - really. Extremely large windows - very comfortable single seating on one side, double on the other. Snacks and beverages from a cart. Well appointed interior - just a nice experience. I stayed there for about 2 hours or so and simply took it all in, wishing all the while that I was in "my" dome!

We had the usual 30 minutes in Moncton to stretch, etc. I use that time to snap off lots of photo's. I know my albums are full of Budd cars - now I've added the Renaissance consist too. Actually, I am impressed with the colors of the cars and their overall appearance. Just don't like riding in 'em as much.

Arrival in Sackville was on time and it was a great visit with my friend and his family.

The return trip was aboard the "traditional" Budd consist - so you can well imagine where I spent my time.

VIA has maintained one train set for the run between Montreal and Halifax for the Budd cars. At present the Montreal departures on Thursday and Sunday are Budd equipped and the Halifax departures on Wednesday and Saturday are the same. So, if one wishes to experience the best of the "Ocean," take those Budd cars! Check with VIA Rail before you make that reservation .....

Hope some of you benefit from what I've passed along.
================================================
Let's keep this topic going!





Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 20,096 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Wednesday, March 9, 2005 2:23 PM
Great report! Thanks
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Wednesday, March 9, 2005 7:18 PM
Sure would like to "hear" from those of you with traveling experiences aboard VIA Rail's "Skeena" (Jasper to Prince Ruppert via Prince George) and the "Malahat" on Vancouver Island (Victoria to Courtenay).

AND how about some "reports" of travel elsewhere in Canada - like up to Churchill! Or to destinations in Quebec or the "corridor" trains or ..........

C'mon, there have to be lots of stories to tell.

If we want to keep this discussion group "alive," letting it slip off the front page will surely be its demise.

Talk to you all in the AM.
Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Thursday, March 10, 2005 11:12 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple:

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!



====================================================
The last time I looked we had 601 people "checking us out" and 54 contributors (but to be honest - many of those are repeat performers).

So, since March 9th when this topic first was posted - we've done well. I wi***hat this could have gone further ...... but if it's not to be, it was fun!

I've checked the block "Notify me when a reply is posted," which I intend to reply to.

So until then - THANX for the very interesting experiences and your participation.



Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    May 2014
  • 3,727 posts
Posted by trolleyboy on Friday, March 11, 2005 12:42 AM
Good evening.The corridor is doing very well still,I live along it and weekdays have 10 Via trains weekends 8.At least once a year the wife and I take the Via to TO for xmas shopping.We've always liked the Algoma Central tour trains into the Agawa canyon,beautifull scenery.I recomend it particularly if you take the run in the fall.Another fun trip is the Polar Bear express on the Ontario northland***eran to Moosenee lovely terrain.You can still catch the Northlander at Toronto Union and it will run you up to Northbay and then you catch the Polar Bear for the rest of the trip north.I can remember catching the CN tempo trains in the early seventies as well though I was too young to remember most of the details.The old RS10's and18's made quick work of theses short runs.Thanks for the memories Siberianmo catch you later. Rob
  • Member since
    February 2005
  • From: Vancouver Island, BC
  • 23,330 posts
Posted by selector on Friday, March 11, 2005 1:29 AM
Not entirely on topic, my wife and I went into the interior of BC last week to see her sister and husband. On the way back, my wife took the first 'shift' at the wheel. It gave me an opportunity to look at CN and CP rail bridges in the Fraser Canyon. They're all modern steel with cement abuttments, but, oh, the weathering effects!! Most were built circa 1955, but are nicely rust-stained, as are their supporting concrete piers. Naturally, no two are alike. Imagine the engineering department that had to measure gaps, survey and draft up approaches, design abuttments, supports, spans, and so on. I also saw rock-slide sheds that I had hitherto neglected on my countless trips through the Canyon. And, there are telegraph poles that have been pressed into a more contemporary use; supporting large sheets of chain -link to contain rock debris that rains down adjacent rock faces on a daily basis.

Running trains in BC ain't fer sissies!
  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Chesterfield, Missouri, USA
  • 7,214 posts
Posted by siberianmo on Friday, March 11, 2005 7:34 AM
QUOTE: The groundrules are pretty simple:

Share your thoughts about Canadian passenger railroading - past and present. Let's not bash one another because of differences in opinion and of course, nationalities. Above all - keep politics out of our discussions.

Ladies and Gentlemen, let's talk Canadian passenger trains!


====================================================
Good morning!

I see two fans of Canadian RR's have resonded - thanx, you made my day (and hopefully all of the other readers)!

trolleyboy
QUOTE: Good evening.The corridor is doing very well still,I live along it and weekdays have 10 Via trains weekends 8.At least once a year the wife and I take the Via to TO for xmas shopping.We've always liked the Algoma Central tour trains into the Agawa canyon,beautifull scenery.I recomend it particularly if you take the run in the fall.Another fun trip is the Polar Bear express on the Ontario northland***eran to Moosenee lovely terrain.You can still catch the Northlander at Toronto Union and it will run you up to Northbay and then you catch the Polar Bear for the rest of the trip north.I can remember catching the CN tempo trains in the early seventies as well though I was too young to remember most of the details.The old RS10's and18's made quick work of theses short runs.Thanks for the memories Siberianmo catch you later. Rob


Rob - I've always enjoyed my experiences traveling the "corridor" between Toronto and Montreal and always 'spring' for the VIA1 ticketing. My wife and I have also traveled between Montreal and Ottawa on two occasions, but in coach - which was just fine. Actually, for me - ANY train that has passenger cars in its consist is OK wth me![:)]

Algoma Central is a roadname I have come to like. Not that long ago I found an HO freight car with the herald on it and of course HAD to add it to my crowded sidings. By the way, sure would appreciate a bit of insight regarding those tour trains - while they are not my favorite in terms of "not real passenger trains," we'd love to experience what they have to offer. I know I could find out on their web site - but getting the info this way is much more FUN![:D]

A few years ago I checked out the Ontario Northland - tried to plan a trip from Toronto northward that would provide me with a relatively quick turnaround. As I recall, the schedules (at the time) really weren't that "friendly." I'll have to look again, for as with the AC, ON is another road I want to ride.

Thanx again, "see" you back at the "Coffee Shop"![tup]
=============================================
selector
QUOTE: Not entirely on topic, my wife and I went into the interior of BC last week to see her sister and husband. On the way back, my wife took the first 'shift' at the wheel. It gave me an opportunity to look at CN and CP rail bridges in the Fraser Canyon. They're all modern steel with cement abuttments, but, oh, the weathering effects!! Most were built circa 1955, but are nicely rust-stained, as are their supporting concrete piers. Naturally, no two are alike. Imagine the engineering department that had to measure gaps, survey and draft up approaches, design abuttments, supports, spans, and so on. I also saw rock-slide sheds that I had hitherto neglected on my countless trips through the Canyon. And, there are telegraph poles that have been pressed into a more contemporary use; supporting large sheets of chain -link to contain rock debris that rains down adjacent rock faces on a daily basis.

Running trains in BC ain't fer sissies!


selector - I hope you had a chance to view my post a (page or two back) regarding our experiences aboard the "Canadian" when a rock slide struck the train just a bit north of Boston Bar. You are correct - only the hale and hardy need apply when running trains in BC (and anywhere else in the Canadian Rockies!).

You and I must view the scenery in a similar fashion, for I too recall those bridges and wondered ....... AND, yes - the telephone poles/chain link fencing, assisting with the rock slide deterence.

Those rock slide sheds were visible to use too - and only because our train was delayed for six hours due to the slide. Had the trip been made during its normal scheduling - we would have missed them completely, along with the splendid scenery of Fraser Canyon.

Thanx for the info and good "seeing" you again here![tup]
================================================

FOR ANY NEW COMERS - I suggest you take a look at the postings on this discussion from the beginning - find something that tweaks your interests and tell us about it!
================================================

See ya shortly after the next post occurs ...........[:)]



Happy Railroading! Siberianmo
  • Member since
    July 2004
  • From: Ontario - Canada
  • 463 posts
Posted by morseman on Friday, March 11, 2005 4:11 PM
I mentioned a while back about the DOMINION between
Montreal & Vancouver using baggage cars & some coaches which were
painted silver to match the stainless steel cars.
As this was in the days before VIA and was all CP livery
The coaches were formerly painted red.
I'm mentioning this as siberianmo may have confusedit with
the former CN cars.

On the roofs of the Canadian & Dominion were steel
bars to break any icicles in the tunnels through
the Rockies so as not to damage the scenic domes.
Do the present VIA locomotives still have these steel bars?

Join our Community!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

Search the Community

Newsletter Sign-Up

By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Trains magazine.Please view our privacy policy