Trains.com

Is the forum dead?

6458 views
139 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    March 2002
  • 9,265 posts
Posted by edblysard on Friday, August 4, 2006 8:10 AM

They have the 12 banger....

http://www.thedieselshop.us/PTRR.HTML

is a list of the locomotives, and what frames they were built on.

So far, they have been pretty good locomotives.

On their 10th year, and entering a rebuild/overhaul program here...in a lot of cases, the diesel is pulled out, refurbished and re-installed....while the prime mover is out, they are cleaning and inspecting all other system, replacing worn wires, ducts and such, repainting all the interiors in the long hood and the cab.

For what we do with them, they have held up quite nicely...because the majority of our work is flat switching and industry, they get pretty banged up, but they seem up to the task.

The only major failures have been a head on collision with a loaded grain train, which bent the frame beyond repair, and the 9601 got speared by a piece of drill stem(pipe) that rolled off the top of a gondola in the next track, and stabbed the locomotive as it was passing by.

Managed to go through the cab floor under the engineers seat, the A/C unit, then the back wall, alternator and out the other side by ten feet.

 

The head on was sent back to Bosie(MK) for a new frame, they swapped all the rest, cab, long hood, diesel and alternator over, and it was back in service within a year.

The 9601 was repaired here, at our shop, after a lot of photos were taken!

 

Ed

23 17 46 11

  • Member since
    December 2001
  • From: NW Wisconsin
  • 3,857 posts
Posted by beaulieu on Friday, August 4, 2006 7:55 AM
 edblysard wrote:


<snipped>

 

I know why CSXengineer is so quite…he is waiting for someone to ask him an intelligent question he can answer.

Me too!

There isn’t much he or I could add to the “I saw a red locomotive” style thread.

Ask about flat yard switching, I’m your guy…ask about running really hairy big freight trains, he has you covered.

Want to know how and why a hump yard does certain things, see Carl S,

Tell me you saw a red locomotive…..ok, and?

 

Although I can’t really speak for CSXengineer, I can tell you I am pretty tired of all the “UP sucks, BNSF sucks, CSX sucks, I wish they would bring back the Cotton Belt”, “I hate the new paint scheme ” threads…to us, this is a ongoing part of our daily lives…

Whether UP or BNSF sucks is all a matter of perspective.

 

If they sign your paycheck, then they don’t suck that bad…

 

For a lot of us, this is how we make our living, and reading how upset some one is over the shape of a logo is somewhat amusing, but not worth getting your panties all wadded up,…it is a tool to us, one of the tools we use to do our job, and we pretty much don’t care what color it is painted, so long as it works.

 

On the other hand, “What are the yellow thingies on the trucks of BN locomotives” is one of those questions that will have railroaders and fans scrambling to go see if they can find a yellow thingies, and get the answer.

 

I think what I am trying to get at is that a lot of the threads now follow the chat room format, instead of a question/answer/discussion format.

 

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and the right to express it, and you will find I am one of the first to defend those rights, heck, I even argued on the side of FM having every right to come here and make a fool of himself, but after a while, seeing UP sucks in every other thread, or reading about how someone hates the new paint on BNSF locomotives gets kinda tired.

 

Ed

 



I have a couple of questions Ed, the first concerns the Cat powered switchers you operate a PTRA.
Are they powered by the 12cyl. 3512 engine. or the 16 cyl. 3516 engine. How has been PTRA's experience with the locomotives. The reason I ask is the Austrian Railway the OBB has been experiencing serious problems have been with the Cat 3512 engine itself. Its possible that things like frame stiffness could be the culprit, but I was wondering what your experiences were like?
  • Member since
    December 2001
  • From: Northern New York
  • 25,014 posts
Posted by tree68 on Friday, August 4, 2006 7:43 AM

You do reach a point at which most of your questions have been answered, most of your stored up stories have been told, and you just don't have a lot to say.  I was noticing that even before the format change.  Some people "get up and leave," others just lay back and become less active.

The "Thread For" explosion kept me quiet for a while - I may enjoy reading the occasional piece about any given railroad, but when all of page one was "Thread For" material, well, I'll just click over to a local forum for a bit.  That one goes through the occasional doldrum, too, and many threads seem to devolve into personal attack forums after all of the pertinent points have been covered, but it can prove entertaining at times. 

Now that we're back into a more normal mix, I drop the occasional comment in a thread, if I have something to add, and read with amusement some of the more arcane stuff.  I really don't mind the "today I saw" thread - everybody needs a place to brag up the high point of their day, even if it's an everyday occurance for others.

Gabe - don't leave - keep in touch.  After a while we'll evolve into a "new" group.  The old timers will tell their stories (again) and answer questions (again), and the newbies will bring new insight. 

LarryWhistling
Resident Microferroequinologist (at least at my house) 
Everyone goes home; Safety begins with you
My Opinion. Standard Disclaimers Apply. No Expiration Date
Come ride the rails with me!
There's one thing about humility - the moment you think you've got it, you've lost it...

  • Member since
    September 2002
  • From: Rockton, IL
  • 4,821 posts
Posted by jeaton on Friday, August 4, 2006 7:27 AM

Times change, people move on, the depth of interest in a particular area will wax and wane.  As a young adult, I worked on, ate, drank and slept railroads.  Later on there was family, different jobs and other hobbies and activites and my interest in the railroad business took a back seat in the, er... jumbo jet.

However, it is a most fascinating business.  One may leave for a while or maybe as in my case even years, but then you pick up a copy of Trains, or read a book such as "The Men Who Loved Trains" and it all comes back.

 

Jay

 

"We have met the enemy and he is us." Pogo Possum "We have met the anemone... and he is Russ." Bucky Katt "Prediction is very difficult, especially if it's about the future." Niels Bohr, Nobel laureate in physics

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Friday, August 4, 2006 7:18 AM
YAWN.....
  • Member since
    March 2002
  • 9,265 posts
Posted by edblysard on Friday, August 4, 2006 7:06 AM

Can't help it Mookie.

 

Look at the buckets...empty.

Need I say more?

Nothing is more sad than a milk junkie with empty buckets!

 

But the Mook hit it right on.

Between Mike Sol and FM’s “is so, is not, is so,” argument threads, and the “threads for everybody” it has become pretty much a topic wasteland.

Think about this; the thread directed towards Mr. Wrinn seems to be one of the few where ideas about future stories in Trains has been bandied about, with many good concepts being brought up and discussed.

Interesting, lively and free of the “I’m smarter than you” crud that has infected most of the other threads.

 

I know why CSXengineer is so quite…he is waiting for someone to ask him an intelligent question he can answer.

Me too!

There isn’t much he or I could add to the “I saw a red locomotive” style thread.

Ask about flat yard switching, I’m your guy…ask about running really hairy big freight trains, he has you covered.

Want to know how and why a hump yard does certain things, see Carl S,

Tell me you saw a red locomotive…..ok, and?

 

Although I can’t really speak for CSXengineer, I can tell you I am pretty tired of all the “UP sucks, BNSF sucks, CSX sucks, I wish they would bring back the Cotton Belt”, “I hate the new paint scheme ” threads…to us, this is a ongoing part of our daily lives…

Whether UP or BNSF sucks is all a matter of perspective.

 

If they sign your paycheck, then they don’t suck that bad…

 

For a lot of us, this is how we make our living, and reading how upset some one is over the shape of a logo is somewhat amusing, but not worth getting your panties all wadded up,…it is a tool to us, one of the tools we use to do our job, and we pretty much don’t care what color it is painted, so long as it works.

 

On the other hand, “What are the yellow thingies on the trucks of BN locomotives” is one of those questions that will have railroaders and fans scrambling to go see if they can find a yellow thingies, and get the answer.

 

I think what I am trying to get at is that a lot of the threads now follow the chat room format, instead of a question/answer/discussion format.

 

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and the right to express it, and you will find I am one of the first to defend those rights, heck, I even argued on the side of FM having every right to come here and make a fool of himself, but after a while, seeing UP sucks in every other thread, or reading about how someone hates the new paint on BNSF locomotives gets kinda tired.

 

Ed

 

23 17 46 11

  • Member since
    June 2001
  • From: US
  • 13,488 posts
Posted by Mookie on Friday, August 4, 2006 6:37 AM

The picture is to depict a kitty who lost her job on the railroad (through no fault of her own, of course) and has hit the skids and must now stand on street corners and ask the kind people for help. 

Actually, she has kibbles in her pails and needs milk, but is too lazy to go to the store.  The work part is just to tug at heartstrings and the head is down cuz she is admiring her new nail polish. 

Behind the scenes - Brother Carl sent that to me - I liked it so well, it has been on my office door for several years. 

La Mook 

She who has no signature! cinscocom-tmw

  • Member since
    December 2001
  • From: Aurora, IL
  • 4,515 posts
Posted by eolafan on Friday, August 4, 2006 6:06 AM
 Mookie wrote:

I plain ran out of questions.  But....thinking up new topics is everyone's job.  To keep the forum from getting as dull as it has, everyone really needs to think up at least one topic.  There are a lot of people out there with answers and they gladly share them - but even if you are in the "business", surely there is something you could either start a topic on or ask about. 

I don't think I am alone in saying that the back and forth between say FM and someone was waaay over my head - some of the simple things like "does lightning hit trains" were just right for me.  We need variety not nonsense.  I can't do megers and eastern railroads and management.  But I can do "what are the yellow thingies and where are they on the brand new engines?"  I know both answers now but only got one from the forum.  The other I chose not to post because it would be buried by the nonsense at the end of one day.  So I went behind the scenes and asked Houston Ed. 

So if you want an interactive forum and an interesting one, try doing some of the work - each and every one of us.  Lurkers - post at least one time.  Give us a chance to have a dialog, not a constant monologue. This many people surely can come up with something to discuss.

Gabe - enjoy your postings - in this case the forum needs a couple of lawyers.  Hope you will reconsider.  Read the diner forum to the baby - guaranteed happy results!

Mookie

 

OK Mook, I have a question...your puddy cat in the picture looks kind of sad to me....why?

Eolafan (a.k.a. Jim)
  • Member since
    June 2001
  • From: US
  • 13,488 posts
Posted by Mookie on Friday, August 4, 2006 6:03 AM

I plain ran out of questions.  But....thinking up new topics is everyone's job.  To keep the forum from getting as dull as it has, everyone really needs to think up at least one topic.  There are a lot of people out there with answers and they gladly share them - but even if you are in the "business", surely there is something you could either start a topic on or ask about. 

I don't think I am alone in saying that the back and forth between say FM and someone was waaay over my head - some of the simple things like "does lightning hit trains" were just right for me.  We need variety not nonsense.  I can't do megers and eastern railroads and management.  But I can do "what are the yellow thingies and where are they on the brand new engines?"  I know both answers now but only got one from the forum.  The other I chose not to post because it would be buried by the nonsense at the end of one day.  So I went behind the scenes and asked Houston Ed. 

So if you want an interactive forum and an interesting one, try doing some of the work - each and every one of us.  Lurkers - post at least one time.  Give us a chance to have a dialog, not a constant monologue. This many people surely can come up with something to discuss.

Gabe - enjoy your postings - in this case the forum needs a couple of lawyers.  Hope you will reconsider.  Read the diner forum to the baby - guaranteed happy results!

Mookie

 

She who has no signature! cinscocom-tmw

  • Member since
    October 2002
  • From: US
  • 2,358 posts
Posted by csxengineer98 on Friday, August 4, 2006 4:14 AM
i have been around...just nothing realy worth responding to in weeks... no good topics for me to add my 10 dollors worth to...
csx engineer

"I AM the higher source" Keep the wheels on steel
  • Member since
    April 2005
  • From: Nanaimo BC Canada
  • 4,117 posts
Posted by nanaimo73 on Friday, August 4, 2006 1:21 AM
The forum could certainly use some of your topics. MWH is posting some, under a different name since April. Overmod is not around, Old Timer and feltonhill have not been talking about steam lately, nor Peter-M636C about diesels. I have not seen CSXengineer on the new forum, the most genuine, human poster around. Murphy may have run out of railroads to start topics on as well, but he's trying to keep the forum interesting. Kissmy is now Champliansomething. Bigboy Elliot has problems of his own to deal with, although he was mostly on the modeling forum. I might do something on the IC next door, but I'm burnt out for now.
Dale
  • Member since
    June 2006
  • 1,432 posts
Posted by Limitedclear on Friday, August 4, 2006 12:30 AM

The Forum is DEAD...

Long live the forum....

Still travelling Gabe. Who says you can't get around in the RR biz...

LC

 

 

  • Member since
    August 2002
  • From: Turner Junction
  • 3,076 posts
Posted by CopCarSS on Thursday, August 3, 2006 10:43 PM

About the same. Just plugging away at work, and trying to get out on the weekends as much as possible. I've been having a pretty productive summer, and have managed to get out railfanning quite  bit, as well as enjoying some hikes both in CO, as well as a trip up to Yellowstone to meet up with some other photographers from the DPReview Canon forum.

August has turned on the calendar, and that means that fall isn't that far away. I'm hoping to get down to the Cumbres and Toltec for some fall color this year. They run a photo freight for Trains Unlimited Tours every year, and I was thinking about renting a 4x4 and chasing the train with that.

Congratulations on your new child! Hope all works out with that, and I hope you can find a little free time for trains, and hanging around here (I'd be sad to see you go, too).

Take care, and good luck!

-Chris
West Chicago, IL
Christopher May Fine Art Photography

"In wisdom gathered over time I have found that every experience is a form of exploration." ~Ansel Adams

  • Member since
    September 2002
  • From: West end of Chicago's Famous Racetrack
  • 2,239 posts
Posted by Poppa_Zit on Thursday, August 3, 2006 10:21 PM
 gabe wrote:

I fear I will not be coming back after this vacation.  Not out of protest, but just because the cite isn't very good.  That would be a BIG disappointment, as there are a lot of forum members I consider it an honor to have know.

Gabe

Jeez, Gabe, say it ain't so. I have always enjoyed your perspectives. Even when I operated here under a different name going back to 2000 or whatever -- mostly lurking.

Of course, no one is irreplaceable, but losing you would be a BIG disappointment to a lot of us. Ya gets out of forums what ya puts in.

"Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. They are not entitled, however, to their own facts." No we can't. Charter Member J-CASS (Jaded Cynical Ascerbic Sarcastic Skeptics) Notary Sojac & Retired Foo Fighter "Where there's foo, there's fire."
  • Member since
    December 2005
  • From: Cardiff, CA
  • 2,930 posts
Posted by erikem on Thursday, August 3, 2006 10:11 PM
I've found FM's postings to be generally informative as well - though I also disagree about the LCV's. I've also found M. Sol's postings to be informative as well, picked up a lot of interesting stuff on the CMStP&P from him - he's obviously partial, but he does come with a lot of facts.

- Erik

  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 2,434 posts
Posted by gabe on Thursday, August 3, 2006 10:07 PM
 CopCarSS wrote:

I think the forum is also taking a collective breather after all the "Thread For Everybody!" threads, and the resulting spoofing of the same.

Other than that, I haven't noticed it being a whole lot different than status quo, apart from the new look. BTW, you can find FM on the "open access" and "closed access" threads. There's still some lively debate in there.

What's new in your world Gabe?

A new child, which means when I am not working, I am raising her, which doesn't leave a lot of time for trains.  Other than that, it is pretty good.  I work a lot more than I should, but the work is interesting and fun.  If I could find just a little more time in my life for trains, this forum, and family--not necessarily in that order--I think I would be living the perfect life.

How are things with you?

Thanks for asking.

Gabe

  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 2,434 posts
Posted by gabe on Thursday, August 3, 2006 10:04 PM

Last summer, we had the problem of all of the Teany Boppers who were out of school and posting agressive posts . . . not that some of the younger people on here are valuable contributors.  But, it was a LOT better than it is now.

I fear I will not be coming back after this vacation.  Not out of protest, but just because the cite isn't very good.  That would be a BIG disappointment, as there are a lot of forum members I consider it an honor to have know.

Gabe

  • Member since
    August 2002
  • From: Turner Junction
  • 3,076 posts
Posted by CopCarSS on Thursday, August 3, 2006 10:03 PM

I think the forum is also taking a collective breather after all the "Thread For Everybody!" threads, and the resulting spoofing of the same.

Other than that, I haven't noticed it being a whole lot different than status quo, apart from the new look. BTW, you can find FM on the "open access" and "closed access" threads. There's still some lively debate in there.

What's new in your world Gabe?

-Chris
West Chicago, IL
Christopher May Fine Art Photography

"In wisdom gathered over time I have found that every experience is a form of exploration." ~Ansel Adams

  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Western New York
  • 193 posts
Posted by Richard A on Thursday, August 3, 2006 9:56 PM

I agree.  It is the mid-summer lull.  Actually, there seems to be more participation than last summer, but who's counting.

You can take a few weeks off and not be afraid of missing anythng. Smile [:)]

Whether your life is good or bad, trains will make it better!
  • Member since
    September 2002
  • From: West end of Chicago's Famous Racetrack
  • 2,239 posts
Posted by Poppa_Zit on Thursday, August 3, 2006 9:46 PM
No, not dead. Mid-summer vapor lock. Laugh [(-D]
"Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. They are not entitled, however, to their own facts." No we can't. Charter Member J-CASS (Jaded Cynical Ascerbic Sarcastic Skeptics) Notary Sojac & Retired Foo Fighter "Where there's foo, there's fire."
  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Indianapolis, Indiana
  • 2,434 posts
Is the forum dead?
Posted by gabe on Thursday, August 3, 2006 9:41 PM

Sorry,

I know I am being a bit of a defeatest and to quote my hero--Homer Simpson--no new C*%$.  But, I have got to say, the forum just is not the same since the change.

I have been on vacation since Tuesday, and I have been hopping on the forum as much as when I used to have a State government job and 70% productivity tended to embarass your collegues, and made you dare not work more than that.

But, the forum has just been absolutely dead lately.  Sure, there isn't kissmycindertrainfinder anoying everyone; but there also isn't the lively conversations and healthy disagreements that made this cite as great as it was.  I don't know if it is because the new format has chased some of the previous contributors away, or what, but it has just been dead for the last week.

As much as I hate to admit it, but I owe 18% of my train knowledge to futuremodal.  Not that he personally educates me, but some of the stuff he says prompts others to give very learned responses back.  In many ways, I think futuremodal is the most valuable contributor.  And, I think his missives should be encouraged.

But, there was not a single topic indicative of what really made this forum so great for me in the past this week.

I am a lawyer, and have a greater tolerance for the argumentation that people are trying to get rid of on here.  But, I think this falls under the "careful what you ask for, you might get it."

Alas, this is another example of the trouble of the great things in life you get for free, you don't have a lot of power to hold on to them.  What I would give for a LC - Greyhound dispute with Futuremodal with occasional refing by Mr. Hemphill et al . . .

Gabe

P.S. Does MP 173 still contribute; I miss Ed's contributions too.

Join our Community!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

Search the Community

Newsletter Sign-Up

By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Trains magazine.Please view our privacy policy