Jago Thats a real nice yellow 1218 when you find one like this do you a... leave the paintwork as found b...give it a clean and polish or c...go the whole hog and go for a repaint just curious as to your approach to these great trains
Thats a real nice yellow 1218 when you find one like this do you
a... leave the paintwork as found
b...give it a clean and polish or
c...go the whole hog and go for a repaint
just curious as to your approach to these great trains
Hi Jago,
In answer to your question I would have to say "It depends". Somewhere on the forum I have a post about my philosphy of collecting. I'm not sure how to link it here yet. I'm still getting used to the changes. Briefly, I tend to buy the best conditon item that I can afford. That gives me lots of variation in the condition that I collect, and I have on occasion upgraded to a better condition item, and then the theory is to sell off the lesser graded item. So far I have not sold many items off just because I have been working at filling in the missing items in my collection.
The basic standard is to buy items in original conditon.
I do the basic amount of clean up - I appreciate the wear the items have. Those dents and chips represent a lot of fun experienced by the string of owners.
I don't do any repaint or touch up myself - mainly because I haven't tried it yet. And I don't buy anything anymore with the intention of restoring it. That might be an aspect I will attempt when I reach retirement
While I don't buy many repaints, I do like a few; mostly items painted in colors that American Flyer never tried, especially if I think they look good.
If an Item is uncommon or unlikely to come up often I might buy it if is in relatively rough condition just to have it in my collection. But I will keep an eye out for a better example. And if I miss an example I usually just keep looking. These are mass produced toys, there are hundreds and thousands of them still hiding in attics and closets. Another example will come along.
I think this might have been a bit long than you had expected, but I thought I would be thorough.
Northwoods Flyer
The Northwoods Flyer Collection
of
American Flyer Trains
"The Toy For the Boy"
I went over to York yesterday in the hopes of adding something to the collection - no joy - not much in the way of prewar Flyer - at least not what I was looking for. So except for the cost of gas and tolls I brought back everything I took over there....oh well, maybe next time
You might want to hold off and read Bob Keller's post from yesterday afternoon re archives and old photos. Believe he said a lot of stuff will be uploaded over the weekend including old pictures..
Jack
IF IT WON'T COME LOOSE BY TAPPING ON IT, DON'T TRY TO FORCE IT. USE A BIGGER HAMMER.
Hi all,
This is my first post on Trains.com. I am 66yrs of age and was given two AF 3/16th O sets for my first Christmas in 1942. I currently have in 3/16th O the Atlantic(4-4-2), Pacific(4-6-2), & Northern (4-8-4) engines. In addition in 3/16th O I have the diecast freight cars (box, cattle, coal, tank, gondola, & caboose. I'm looking for the crane car. I have the 3/16th O diecast passenger cars and combine car. I have the tinplate freight cars with the exception of the crane car and the flatcar with girder load. I also have the 3/16th O tinplate passenger cars in Pennsy red and the mail car in Pullman green. I have an S guage #342 yard goat (0-8-0) that I hope to convert to O and the S guage Pullman observation that I hope to convert to O.
X2000 asked some months ago, about a prewar 3-rail set believed to be late thirties. I do not know if it is a set but I believe the items are 3/16th O guage. If so, his description matches the #565 Atlantic style (4-4-2) diecast engine with sheet metal tender that has a single wire connecting the tender's 3rd rail pickups to the engine. The boxcar seems to be a #478 which is tinplate painted white on the sides with red painted roof and doors. The #482 flatcar with log load is tinplate and came with apple green paint or in black paint. The lighted caboose #484 is tinplate with red paint roof and sides and white painted ladder/railing front and back. All of these are nickle journals and latch-and-pin couplers.
Hope to contribute more about these in the future.
Hank
Hi all, this is a reply to three posts from June 7,8,9 of 2008.
The posts were Q&A about Lionel and AF competition to go scale and I agree with the answers given. I would stress that Lionel 700E Hudson and the B6 switcher were absolute scale detailed 1:48 engines with triple action. The AF decision to go to 3/16th in O allowed them to produce scale length engines without the 72" diameter special track required of the scale Lionel items.
In my collection are the Northern, Pacific and Atlantic in working condition by AF. In addition I have the reproduction Lionel Gold Hudson Mellinium and the reproduction K-Line B-6. Both are, as were the origionals, by Lionel, higher detailed than the AF. But, the origional Lionels were equal to two weeks wages in price and the AF's were about one weeks wages. What is so great about AF? The lack of compromise as to length and the ability to operate on 040 track. This also shows in the passenger cars. No need for compression of length. An example of the difference is to see the Pacific style engines by Lionel and AF. Although Lionel is brutish in appearance, it lacks the correct front wheels and is 2-6-2. The AF K5 Pacific is like a thoroughbred - long and lean. Lionel in the late 30's, early & late 40's, & 50's did not have triple action on the Atlantics or Pacifics. AF had triple action. AF had triple action on the Northern, Hudson, Atlantic, and 0-8-0 yard goat.
Best,
Hi Hank,
to the forum. Its good to have you here. Thanks for posting the information about your collection and about 3/16 American Flyer. It was produced for such a short period of time, and yet it doesn't seem to get the attention that it deserves as the transition it was from Chicago Flyer's O gauge to Gilbert's S gauge. If you have the capability to post some pictures of your equipment it would be great to see.
Thanks for posting and come and visit often.
Updates
With the new format the page index was rendered obsolete. I've updated the index which is now on pp. 21 (note July 2021 - this too is obsolete). I also went back and began the process of updating the pictures which underwent severe shrinkage. Hopefully, sometime this weekend I'll be able to add some new text and pictures to this thread.
Mersenne6
Flyer and Gilbert Friends,
I know this item is not Pre War but I thought some here could point me in the right direction. A forum search did not give me many clues.
While cleaning out my Mom's basement today I found my American Flyer #312 engine (knuckle couplers) from my childhood. I long thought this was gone. Still in the original wrap and in a flooded basement I was surprised to see it free of rust or damage. The cars and accessories stored away from the engine have surface rust but should be OK. The cooler which was used to store track and switches looks as if it had filled with water at some point, and was not a happy sight. My Dad died in 1964, and I last ran these trains before 1969. I did make a track plan copy before I had to dismantle the platform before I got married in 1975. My Mom passed away this past July and I am very Happy she saved these trains for me. Another thing I found with the engine was a worn copy of the 1957 American Flyer catalog, and toward the back in the special car section was a note made by my Dad circling the Crane car, with a check mark and a big OK next to it. He never got to get that car for me, but for some unknown reason when my local train shop went out of business a few years ago the owner brought out that exact car and suggested I buy it for display on my Lionel platform. I didn't know why I wanted it but I bought it. Now I do. Who says parents don't watch out for you after they are gone.
Anyway I am thinking I may want to try and recreate the layout for my Grandsons. Does anyone have any thoughts on how hard it will be to get back into American Flyer after all these years.
Best Regards,
Ken
Hi Ken,
It is indeed amazing how toy trains can be woven into the fabric of your life and memories. I am sure that there are many folks who will read your message that will have similar stories. My trains from my childhood were both American Flyer S-gauge and prewar American Flyer O gauge.
It will be very easy to get back into American Flyer. There is a great deal of the vintage S gauge equipment available, although not nearly as much as there is Lionel equipment. With a little effort, some hunting and careful attention to budgeting you could probably replace all of the damaged items from your childhood trains. Or you can go the route of restoring them.
There is also a large amount of new Flyer made by Lionel currently if you don't want to shop the secondary market.
Once Sturgeon-Phish reads your note I am sure he will have some comments. If you can do a search on his entries to the forum you will see his S-gauge empire. He has managed to collect some very nice examples of the items from the era that you are interested in.
I think that you will be pleased at the smiles on your grandchildren's faces when they see the Flyer layout you will create, and my guess is that they will remind you of the smile on your Dad's face as he watched you play with your trains.
When I read your post it brought a smile. As stated, trains interweave our lives and span generations. The 312 is one of my favorites. Is yours a Smoke in Tender (SIT) or Smoke in Boiler (SIB)? Easy to tell, if there is a flexible tube (or a brass tube stub from the tender) between the loco and tender, you have a SIT, which means the smoke unit is in the tender. If not you have a SIB with the smoke unit in the boiler. What is cool about the SIB is when the loco is in neutral, the unit can sit and still produce smoke. Very neat!
Track and switches are fairly easy and cheap to come by, to get your railroad started. If you need help in getting it running there is lots of assistance and information available.
Thanks for sharing your story
Jim
Something like this:
Jim,
What a great picture! You could title it "Delight".
We have been a bit thin on pictures in this post recently. I think there are a number of reasons for that, including learning to use the tools again and I have had some problems with Shutterfly lately. So for today I decided to just post some pictures of trains. I consider this my version of eye candy. The "sets" that I am posting were not necessarily cataloged. The only thing they have in common is that the trucks in each picture all match each other. Enjoy!
Here is a set I picked up this weekend. It has the mechanican whistle you mentioned earlier in the post. I cleaned the wheels and pickups and she started running. Amazing. Any idea as to what this set is worth on the market, I would like to sell or trade it.
Hi n1vets333,
to the thread. As your research has already told you the set that you have was an uncataloged offering from American Flyer some time in the 1936-1938 era. It first appeared around 1936. The engine came in two versions; a wind up version (which had two styles of wind up mechanism) and an electric version. The engine had two different styles of back, a rounded back that was meant for passenger sets and a square back that was intended for freight sets. It appears that the engines were found with either type of back with either type of car. I would guess that is a result of Flyer using up existing stock. The cars that are in your set are also uncataloged. They came in two varieties, with either four wheels or eight wheels. If you scroll up a bit on this thread you will see some examples of the eight wheel cars. These sets must have been pretty popular and affordable because of their lower price. They show up pretty frequently. Most of the cars that I have observed are in a condition similar to yours, so I am guessing that they were well loved and played with.
As far as value is concerned: you know that they are worth at least what you paid for them. I do most of my purchasing on eBay and I think that with the exposure that items get on there it is a pretty good resource for what current market values are. When I consider buying an item I watch what the same item sells for in different auctions. I also set in my own mind what I am willing to pay for the item and what condition I will accept. I don't pay a great deal of attention to price guides. I don't have an example of this engine in my collection. However, in the photo that I mentioned above with the eight wheel cars, I purchased all of the components individually on eBay during the last year, to assemble that "set". I doubt that I have more than $125.00 invested in the whole set. I watched auctions for quite a while until I found cars in a condition that I was willing to have and at prices I was willing to pay.
They are a nice example of Flyer's lower priced cars. Good luck with what ever you decide to do with them.
Enjoying the World's Greatest Hobby,
Thank you for the response, they are a cool litle set, I might just end up keeping them, I actuallt bought them with a box full of ho passenger cars. I seen another hiawatha engine in one of the price guides and I thought I might have had a rare find on my hands. Overall this is a cool little set. Its amazing with a little cleaning how this little guy runs.
The Hiawatha is one of the more storied trains of the 1930s upper Midwest and represented one of the fastest steam engines ever built. Just to get you started http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiawatha_(passenger_train)
I'd keep it and, because of its age, leave it unrestored. But that's me.
1927 Jeffersonian Set #1306
In the 1927 catalog the top of the line Narrow Gauge set was the Jeffersonian
The Other Freight Cars IV
5 ½ inch cars 241/M241 Log Car
6 ½ inch cars #1106/1146
#1146
Note the solid piece of wood.
#3006
#3046
This car came in black, blue, orange, or green. The blue, orange, and green cars were decaled “American Flyer” on the crosspiece.
Finished lumber
The machinery car was cataloged from 1928-35 whereas the log car was cataloged from 1930-38. Except for identifying numbers the basic cars are identical. They came with either one or two crosspieces. The log car has lumber (unfinished individual pieces) and wire retainers whereas the machinery car doesn’t. However, as can be seen in the picture below, Flyer would make do with what was on hand. The car has brass plates #3206, lumber, and wire.
#406
Cataloged 1939. Similar to #3216 except it had link and pin couplers. Lumber load was a single piece of wood milled to look like a lumber load. Again the car could come with one or two crosspieces.
Note the single crosspiece
The Other Freight Cars IV - Addendum A
Here are some variations on the #3046 6.5" log cars.
This is the blue version that mersenne6 shows in his post. Mine is quite dark and usually looks almost black. It depends on the light that you view it in.
The Other Freight Cars V
The Caboose
#1111 – 5 ½ inch
#1111 version with off center cupola and brass hand rails and ladders.
#1114/1117 – 6 ½ inch
Earliest version with high Marklin style trucks
Later version with litho brown cupola
#1127
#3004/3014/3017/232
Green roof and silver rubber stamping
Orange roof and rubber stamping
Rubber stamp marking on underside of caboose.
3201/3211/411 - 9 ½ inch cars
All of these cars share the same stampings. The differences are trucks, couplers, and markings which can be either brass plates, decals, or rubber stampings. This caboose is usually found lighted.
Early version brass number tags darker red cupola
Later version decals and single color caboose and cupola.
The Other Freight Cars - Addendum B
As mersenne6 has illustrated there were a number of variation to the 3206/3216 Machinery/Log car:
"#3206/3216 Machinery car/Log car
The machinery car was cataloged from 1928-35 whereas the log car was cataloged from 1930-38. Except for identifying numbers the basic cars are identical. They came with either one or two crosspieces. The log car has lumber (unfinished individual pieces) and wire retainers whereas the machinery car doesn’t. However, as can be seen in the picture below, Flyer would make do with what was on hand. The car has brass plates #3206, lumber, and wire.
"
Greenberg lists 10 different variations of the log car and 3 variations of the machinery car.
Here are a few additional variations; let me post them in what I think is chronological order:
This version is similar to the one mersenne6 posted above, exept that it has two "American Flyer Lines" brass tabs.
Note the two brake wheels and type VII trucks
The Other Freight Cars - Addendum C
Wide Gauge Machinery Car and Log Car
American Flyer had similar cars in their Wide Gauge Line. The Machinery Car was numbered 4022 and the Log Car was numbered 4023. According to Greenberg there are several variations of both. There are variations in blue and some marked for Nation Wide Lines which is the name that Flyer sold trains under through J.C.Penny.
This is the 4022 Machinery Car
Set #1220 from 1926
The other day I started going through some boxes looking for items to put on the Christmas layout and I ran across this set that I picked up a short time ago.
New Jeffersonian set 1928-1931
One of the things that I enjoy about having a collection is going through all the boxes stored under the train table and finding things I only barely remember having. Each time I open a box it is a little like Christmas. I had that experience recently as I was looking for items to display for the Christmas layout. The set pictured in the entry above produced that kind of experience. Of course I couldn't just stop there. I also came across some other "goodies" including this set:
This is the New Jeffersonian that Flyer cataloged from 1928 thru 1931.
Northwood,
would you know where one would be able to get a brush plate fot a 4692 standard gauge Af?
thanks
Greetings QueensNY,
Unfortunately I am not a good resource for finding parts for American Flyer items. I have not done any repair or restoration on items in my collection. I am waiting for my retirement years to do that. I know that there are parts suppliers that other forum members have used. Eric Trickel has a catalog of items, and I have that, but I didn't see the part you are looking for. You might consider starting another thread with this question to catch the attention of other forum members.
Good Luck in your search,
Hi All,
I joined this group awile back and have enjoyed the informative postings. Recently, the name Eric Trickle was mentioned as a supplier of American Flyer parts. Can anyone supply his address and if there is an e-mail or .com site for his goods?
My specialty is in 3/16th O and have suffered long waits at my local hobby shop for simple items like coupler repairs. Hopping to speed the process.
Hank Betz
Warrington, PA
I'm glad you are enjoying the postings. I have Eric Trickel's Replacement Parts for PreWar Trains - Spring 2008 Catalog. He has two pages of parts for 3/16" O Gauge equipment. His address is:
541 North Charlotte Street
Pottstown PA 19464
email: TRICKELCASTPARTS@ YAHOO.COM
As I mentioned above I am not a knowledgeable source for replacement parts. There may be other suppliers that other folks on the forum may be aware of.
thanks for the response northwoods. I will send him an e-mail and see if he has it. If not i start a new post.
1938 Christmas List
In 1938 if you had the American Flyer Catalog you might have added the No.2 Freight set to your list for Santa
Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.
Get the Classic Toy Trains newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month