QUOTE: Modeling failure? How about modeling an effort to avoid failure. Too bad they didn't make it. Perhaps it took the failure of PC to get the government more involved with the loans and Stagger's act. How many railroads were saved because PC's failure woke everyone? Would that be a failure then?
QUOTE: what about the railroads that were willing participants with racism? That's ok if they were financial successes? The Norfolk Western was a powerhouse during the time they took advantage of cheap black labor and prison folks to build tunnels. Somehow that to me is worse than throwing away a bunch of papers in a station basement or selling a diesel before some guy to purchase it. But because they had economic good years that's an ok line to model?
QUOTE: Yes, every railroad had its ugly side. Be it economic, management, social whatever. What does make modeling a railroad fun is the memories that it invokes in its owner.
QUOTE: What was interesting was the comments and stories I got from ex PRR/PC employees about their PC experience. It wasn't all bad most related how they kept the rr running with chewing gum, baling wire , duct tape etc.
QUOTE: by Paul 3 By why would anyone want to model this "ugly side"? Penn Central was all "ugly", all the time
"I like my Pullman Standards & Budds in Stainless Steel flavors, thank you!"
QUOTE: Goodness Paul!, I honestly feel that a number of us, including me, clearly communicated the reasons!
QUOTE: Not disrespecting you, but while you're very knowledgable, you also seem to be a little on the "extremist side",...
QUOTE: ...especially considering that you weren't there as things were unfolding in the late 60s and early 70s! America in general, had a completely different mentality and PC was one of many companies doomed to fail! There was even corruption in WASHINGTON! (anyone here besides me remember Watergate?)
QUOTE: It seems that your style is to model a railroad era where things were "going well". That's fine, but from what you've stated, according to your modeling "guidelines" any railroad or time period where things were not "rosy" is depressing and is a waste of time doing so!
QUOTE: My goodness, I'm so glad that at 41 I don't think this way! I'd really be feeling bad that I was around during that time instead of feeling greatful!
QUOTE: If that's the case, no one should model ANYTHING! Automobiles, up until the late 80s were unsafe in collisions Many buildings up until the 1980s contained asbestos Rape and Wife Battering up until the early 90s was often not taken seriously by the police Polio devasted millions until Doctor Salk came along Today we worry about wack-job terrorists........now that's depressing! Why model any time period? IT's ALL FULL OF DEPRESSING MOMENTS!
QUOTE: Penn Central, while "ugly", as you say was not ALL UGLY. With all due respect, you weren't there!!! I was and so were some of the guys on here. Again, many of us model what we saw and experienced. For some of us, the memories are VERY PLEASANT! Why can't this be understood?? It's simple for me. The Penn Central gave a happy, but shy boy who looked out a New York apartment window everday a lot to sigh and smile about as he waited for his dad to come home from work!
QUOTE: O.K, now for the "so called" ugly let's see the following: (A) The E33s, which remained in NH colors for a while were beautiful looking machines hauling lonnnnnnnng freight trains.
QUOTE: {B) The Metroliners, were touted as the Fastest, sharpest looking passenger trains in America. Most of the travelers on these trains wore business attire!
QUOTE: (C) The GG1s were still "flexing their big biceps" as they hauled freight & passenger trains on the Northeast Corridor at 70+ mph.
QUOTE: (D) Long distance passenger trains from SCL and Southern were hauled by the PC on the corridor. Penn Central was able to maintain the schedules the majority of the time.
QUOTE: So "beauty" and "ugly" is in the beholder's mind. "Depressing and Model Railroading" just don't go together!
QUOTE: Again, In modeling the PC a knowledgeable modeler can acknowledge but not have to "worry or care" about the bankruptcy, corruption and everything negative. Come on! Nobody is holding a 50,000 Volt Police Taser on a modelers head yelling "Look you punk! Make sure you model the guys destroying property or stealing, or setting the Maybrook Bridge on fire! You got that?!"
QUOTE: Paul, modelers WANT TO RELAX AND HAVE FUN.The sad info can stay in the history books!
QUOTE: I'm sorry you take such an affront to what I posted earlier. No railroad has a "clean" period. Often times present "clean" periods are a direct result of some "ugly" action decades past. You wouldn't model NW prior to the mid 60's? Well, NS is still using the tunnels and fills made by racist policies. Not having as much debt in building them can be partially responsible for today's bottom line.
QUOTE: I'm sure if you would tell us what railroad and era you model, there are folks here that will find reasons you shouldn't be modeling it just as you found against PC. It's just the way things go.
QUOTE: Originally posted by dano99a QUOTE: Originally posted by csxmu QUOTE: At least he didn't waste the space on another UP layout. My thoughts exactly!![#ditto] HAHAHAHHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, sorry I thought that was pretty funny. It is in fact a nice layout, I could really care less if it was PC or UP or PRR or C&O or B&O or ATSF or SF or Espee or BNSF or, or, or NNGDVCHBSLKVNFVJHBFV...... [:)] it is a really nice layout that I can only dream of owning something like it someday or even better own the house that it lives in.... [:)]
QUOTE: Originally posted by csxmu QUOTE: At least he didn't waste the space on another UP layout. My thoughts exactly!![#ditto]
QUOTE: At least he didn't waste the space on another UP layout.
QUOTE: By KenmacPrr: By the way you PC haters the rr is now in the early Conrail era 1977-1982....
QUOTE: Originally posted by KemacPrr Hey Warthogdrvr thanks for the kind words regarding your open house visit.
QUOTE: We had about 750 people total at 3 open house events. The rr and my grass survived intact.
QUOTE: Glad you got to take the throttle for a run over the Buffalo line. I decided to let the crews do that as long as they kept an eye on the visitor and the signals.
QUOTE: The main reason I do this every year is my attempt to help the hobby.
QUOTE: It's fun to watch little kids walk around with the mini step stools I provide to get a better view of the rr and the parents backs appreciate even more. Kids are still fascinated by trains , sound equipted ones even more so. Hopefully I planted a small seed in one of the visitors that will take root later on to become a future model railroaders.