Larry
http://www.youtube.com/user/ClinchValleySD40
http://www.flickr.com/photos/52481330@N05/
http://www.trainboard.com/railimages/showgallery.php/cat/500/page/1/ppuser/8745/sl/c
"I like my Pullman Standards & Budds in Stainless Steel flavors, thank you!"
QUOTE: I still don't understand what's wrong with PC.
QUOTE: There's nothing wrong with the PC!
QUOTE: However my answer to the question "What's wrong with Penn Central" was simply in reference to "modeling the Penn Central".
QUOTE: In modeling the Penn Central, we can forget about the corrupt managment and it's dirty tactics.
QUOTE: Originally posted by PennsyHoosier LOL csxmu! Well, I'm glad you started the poll. And it turns out, PC ain't all that bad. Yes, we all know that all RRs have feet of clay. There is no perfect railroad (only the perfect engine--the K4). So let's appreciate what we had and what we have. Thank goodness for all you folks in MRing, who keep the older images ALIVE!
QUOTE: Originally posted by Paul3 AntonioFP45 wrote: QUOTE: However my answer to the question "What's wrong with Penn Central" was simply in reference to "modeling the Penn Central". QUOTE: In modeling the Penn Central, we can forget about the corrupt managment and it's dirty tactics. How can one seperate the railroad from the models? How can one actually model a railroad without asking why certain things were the way they were? It would be like becoming a Civil War re-enactor without knowing anything about the war or why it was fought. How can one be a fan of a railroad and not know or care about the RR's policies? Penn Central never had those glory days. Paul A. Cutler III
QUOTE: Good, intelligent points, but we're in this hobby for FUN. It's possible to model railroads like the Penn Central, care and be knowledgeable about its history, and not be overwhelmingly concerned about its policies.
QUOTE: I wasn't even aware that the NH was by then a "rolling deathtrap" as everytime I saw NH passenger trains, they were "zipping by" quietly behind FL-9s or EP-5s. (Those EP-5s did need a paint job!)
QUOTE: But in my humble opinion, you almost make it sound like modeling the PC is almost like modeling the horrid aftermath of the Europeon battle fields just after WWII.
QUOTE: I doubt if Penn Central modelers dwell on the bad history as very quickly and operating session would become quite depressing!
QUOTE: Many of modelers on This Forum model the Union Pacific. THEY KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON ----the lawsuits, the deliberate effort to disregard Amtrak schedules, the incredible hostility towards railfans, the poor treatment of the small shippers,-----yet these modelers while knowledgeable about UP's "lousy-points", they choose not to dwell on it but rather enjoy the paint scheme, locomotives, rolling stock, and rich history. IMHO, this same point can apply to anyone modeling the PC. Nothing more!
QUOTE: When (hopefully) I run my finished Penn Central Metroliners on someone's layout, I hope that the host or visiting modelers don't say "Blah! Penn Central!"
QUOTE: I was too young to remember the glory years of the NH , PRR, or NYC. My earliest experience of all three were in the 60's when the NH was already bankrupt and NYC/PRR were in dire straits..and it showed!!
QUOTE: As a child, It was a Penn Central engineer who gave me a cab ride up the Hudson in a PC E-8, a PC yard crew in former NH territory that showed me how they shoved hunks of wood under the rails to keep their RS-3 on the tracks.
QUOTE: This is why I found fascination with the PC and model it today. I don't care what happened or who was to blame. That is for the history books. I just want to model PC as I remember it....well maybe a little cleaner!!
QUOTE: Most of us have a favorite road that has been gobbled up in a mega merger and it may be fun to bash successors for a number of reasons, but that is what is great about model railroading, because we can pick whatever road and time period we want. Ken McCorry is doing just that with a super layout!!
Bill Carl (modeling Chessie and predecessors from 1973-1983) Member of Four County Society of Model Engineers NCE DCC Master Visit the FCSME at www.FCSME.org Modular railroading at its best! If it has an X in it, it sucks! And yes, I just had my modeler's license renewed last week!
QUOTE: Originally posted by AntonioFP45 10-4 on that PennsyHossier! Just one "little" clincher. I thought that it was the streamlined NYC J3a HUDSON! (Oh-oh! I'm in trouble now!)
QUOTE: Hmmmmm. According to some of the posters here, no railroad should ever be modeled.