Trains.com

Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Minimum Aspects of a RR Yard for Prototype Realism

5745 views
20 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    May 2014
  • 372 posts
Minimum Aspects of a RR Yard for Prototype Realism
Posted by Big Boy Forever on Monday, December 14, 2015 10:50 AM

Just wanted to get some opinions on the minimum activities, like refueling, water, miscellaneous maintenance etc.,  AND minimum track arrangements of a prototype RR yard, that would transfer to a Model RR yard.

In other words, the "least" you could have in a RR Yard to truthfully say it is exactly a model of a prototype yard, but just tracks for sorting, is not enough.

I'm talking about a yard with some maintenance activities also.

As we all know, "space" is the main restriction to getting that prototype realism, 2nd after cost.

  • Member since
    November 2007
  • From: California
  • 2,388 posts
Posted by HO-Velo on Monday, December 14, 2015 11:15 AM

A great source is the Kalmbach book, "The Model Railroader's Guide to Freight Yards" by the late master, Andy Sperandeo.

regards,  Peter

  • Member since
    September 2003
  • 10,582 posts
Posted by mlehman on Monday, December 14, 2015 11:17 AM

Minimal? Like 3 tracks, maybe?

Two tracks to sort into (because you'd have to have at least 2 destinations to need to herd the cars around) and a runaround. The run-around could be part of one of the yard tracks (because really all you need are two stub tracks) or it could connect to part of the neighnoring main line in order to get on the other end of a car.

You could call a stub-end pair of spurs a yard, but without a run-around that's really  more like a pair of storage tracks. Just one track is nothing but a spur or siding. But that's splitting hairs a bit, which I'm sure someone's ready to do.

Mike Lehman

Urbana, IL

  • Member since
    August 2013
  • 3,006 posts
Posted by ACY Tom on Monday, December 14, 2015 11:43 AM

Mike is on the right track, so to speak. 

First, you need a track where a train can arrive.  Then you need a "thorofare track" which is usually kept open so that engines can run to the opposite end of the train; and you need about two, or preferably more, single end or double end tracks for sorting cars.

In some very spartan arrangements, locomotive servicing is occasionally done on one of these yard tracks, or even on the main line, with diesel fuel provided by trucks.  However, it is generally preferable to have at least one designated track for locomotive servicing.  In the steam era, an additional track was often used to store hopper cars or oil tank cars for locomotive fuel.  Steam engines also need a source of water, which could be a large tank, a simple standpipe connected to a city water supply, or even a simple hydrant and hose. It is usually preferable to have a turning facility for steam engines (turntable or wye), but this isn't always necessary.  This was discussed recently in another thread.

Tom

  • Member since
    June 2007
  • 8,892 posts
Posted by riogrande5761 on Monday, December 14, 2015 1:22 PM

Rio Grande.  The Action Road  - Focus 1977-1983

  • Member since
    February 2013
  • From: Saginaw, MI
  • 205 posts
Posted by Bob Schuknecht on Monday, December 14, 2015 2:48 PM

Big Boy Forever

In other words, the "least" you could have in a RR Yard to truthfully say it is exactly a model of a prototype yard, but just tracks for sorting, is not enough.

I'm talking about a yard with some maintenance activities also.

While you want maintenance activities, they are not required in a yard if your engines are diesel. During the 1980s Sundays were the day of the week with the most engines in the Chessie(later CSX) yard in Saginaw, MI. That was the day power from Midland, Flint, Grand Blanc and Port Huron were all brought into Saginaw for service.

 

You could have an engine or two assigned to a yard and once a week send tham to a nearby larger yard with service facilities.

  • Member since
    May 2012
  • 602 posts
Posted by NP01 on Monday, December 14, 2015 4:09 PM

I have thought a lot about yards because the "Givens" in my layout room created a non-traditional yard arrangement and I have been challenged. I get to test if my yard will work in the couple of weeks as I add a branchline and a track arrangement for a town which will be the current end of line on the main.

Excellent answers from prior responses. As you gather from those, you need the following key elements in addition to Engine Service:

  • An arrival/departure track to receive an inbound train on. Typically a two-ended siding off the main. Could be multiple sidings.
  • A lead track so when you pull car cuts out of the main yard track to put it on another, you don't foul the main line
  • A track to store cabeese if applicable
  • Number of yard tracks depends upon how many "destination groups" you have on your layout --for example when you are sorting an inbound train that came from the EAST at a branch point ... you could have three tracks: (1) all cars going to WEST main (2) all cars going to branch (3) local cars for industries in the vicinity of that town. 

Then I would ask a couple questions:

  1. Diesel or Steam? The former is simpler (= less space) so you could get away with a single track.
  2. What is your traffic level. Will you be sorting trains for several destinations? Will you be sorting 2 trains at a time?
  3. Will this also be a staging/ parking area? Both for the prototype and for the layout, we need a place for trains to go when they are not running.
  4. What is the route arrangement? Will it be at an end of line or a through-station? Is there a branch here?
  5. You you have team tracks in it?

There is an excellent write up on Classification Yards at: http://www.housatonicrr.com/yard_des.html

NP.

  • Member since
    August 2006
  • 1,519 posts
Posted by trainnut1250 on Monday, December 14, 2015 5:39 PM

I looked at a similar set of questions when I designed my yard.  I described the design process in an article on my website that you might find interesting.

Look in the Quick links Nav. Bar on the left and click on Yard design PDF
I hope this helps.  I also recommend the article on Craig’s site

 

Have fun,

 

Guy

 

see stuff at: the Willoughby Line Site

  • Member since
    September 2003
  • 10,582 posts
Posted by mlehman on Monday, December 14, 2015 6:00 PM

I went minimal with my dfinition because sometimes yards are just that, they serve a minimal range of needs. Engine facilities, caboose tracks, cleanout tracks, multi-modal ramps, etc depend on local needs. Another yard nearby might handle many or all of these, leaving nothing but some sorting to be done at a minimalist sort of yard.

Here's an example, a couple of pics of my Dove Creek Yard.

In the pic above, the  farthest left track is an industrail lead and not part of the yard, although it offers a handy place to shove a few cars into if needed. The next track, 2nd from the left, is the freight running track. It joins the main out of sight behind the industries on the left at the Dove Creek station. You can see it in this next pic, with the industrial track ending before getting to the station.

Finally, looking back toward where the first pic was taken from, the 2 track closest to the yard are the yard track proper. Both are double ended, which helps, but one or both could be stub-ended so long as there's a nearby runaround.

Note that the switcher and caboose just sit there, unless they need to move. Not too fancy, but serves Dove Creek just fine.

 

Mike Lehman

Urbana, IL

  • Member since
    December 2001
  • From: Northern CA Bay Area
  • 4,387 posts
Posted by cuyama on Monday, December 14, 2015 8:22 PM

There were a number of informative responses when last you raised a similar question:
http://cs.trains.com/mrr/f/11/t/229837.aspx

You might review the comments made and resources suggested from that go-round.

As many noted back then, the answer varies depending on the era, locale, and purpose of the yard (such as branch junction, interchange, industry suport, division point, etc.). And that is filtered further by the model railroad realities each of us faces.

If you have an actual model application this time, letting folks know what you want to do with the overall layout and how much space you have for the yard will help them provide you with useful answers. Discussing yards in the abstract may not help much with an actual layout design, IMHO.

If this is a theoretical discussion again, letting folks know that up front will help them direct their answers.

Real-life yards can be remarkably compact on branch lines and short lines. The modern era Ballard Terminal Railroad makes do with a yard that is two double-ended tracks and a nearby spur for engine service and storage. That's probably about the minimum ... and it goes on from there.

Tags: Prototype , yard
  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Monday, December 14, 2015 9:35 PM

Big Boy Forever
AND minimum track arrangements of a prototype RR yard, that would transfer to a Model RR yard.

That really depends on your prototype railroad, the actual prototype location, and the time period you are modeling. 

If you ever get the chance go to Steamtown Nation Historic Park in Scranton, Pa.  They have a timeline of the rail facilities at the museums location going back to the ~1870s.  Another place to look is Andy Sperandeo's book Freight Yards.  Also check out John Armstrong's book Track Planning for Realistic Operation.  These books will have the basic yard design concepts.  Kalmbach also has a Model railroader's guide to locomotive servicing terminals.  Finally, if you really want to get into the nuts and bolts of layout design, check out http://www.ldsig.org/.

Also you may want to decide if you are going to run operating sessions, or just run trains yourself.  This will influence your design choices. 

Big Boy Forever
In other words, the "least" you could have in a RR Yard to truthfully say it is exactly a model of a prototype yard, but just tracks for sorting, is not enough.

That would again depend on your prototype, era and location.  If you take a prototype track arrangement and start deleting tracks, you may find that your yard does not work correctly. 

My yard is based loosely on Rigby Yard, South Portland, Maine.  I have 2 arrival/departure tracks where trains are made and broken down and sorted for off-line destinations, 6 sorting tracks, 9 stall roundhouse (under construction), 130ft Turntable (yes my prototypes TT is only 105 or 115, dont remember, but I was in a hurry), machine shop, coaling tower, diesel fueling stand, sanding tower and sand drying house, ash pit (not yet installed), water tower and separate water columns, and a RIP (Repair In Place) track, caboose tracks, separate coach yard for passsenger cars and most importantly, my arrival/departure tracks do not interfere with the yard switching lead.  This is what I deemed to be the minimum.  Your results may vary.

If this is your railroads major shop facilities you will need quite and extensive backshop area connected to, or closely adjoing your roundhouse.  If you have ice activated refrigerator cars, you may need icing facilities. 

 

Moderator
  • Member since
    June 2003
  • From: Northeast OH
  • 17,247 posts
Posted by tstage on Monday, December 14, 2015 9:46 PM

HO-Velo

A great source is the Kalmbach book, "The Model Railroader's Guide to Freight Yards" by the late master, Andy Sperandeo.

And I found Marty McGuirk's The Model Railroader's Guide to Locomotive Servicing Terminals to be quite helpful, as well.

Tom

https://tstage9.wixsite.com/nyc-modeling

Time...It marches on...without ever turning around to see if anyone is even keeping in step.

  • Member since
    February 2015
  • 223 posts
Posted by Choops on Tuesday, December 15, 2015 9:27 AM

this is a good read.

http://housatonicrr.com/yard_des.html

Steve

 

Modeling Union Pacific between Cheyenne and Laramie in 1957 (roughly)
  • Member since
    February 2008
  • 2,360 posts
Posted by kasskaboose on Wednesday, December 16, 2015 7:13 AM

Great responsees, so you have a lot to consider when planning your yard.  Considering space is critical the yard should function.  No two people try to capture the same form of operations for multiple reasons.  What are you wanting from the yard?

On my stub-ended yard, I have an intermodal area, a loco service shop, and classification tracks. Having a stub-ended yard is fine, but I really wanted a double ended one.  Given the space limitations, I was unable to get one.  Being satisfied with what you can realistically replicate is more worthwhile than creating spaghetti bowl of track.

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • From: North Dakota
  • 9,592 posts
Posted by BroadwayLion on Thursday, December 17, 2015 10:26 AM

Major yards are naturally the terminals for the trains that call there. Locomotive maintenance will be done there, but not in the same yard. They will be separated and will have their own lead tracks, towers and rules. In maintenance yards there will be blue flags all over the place. Not so in a freight yard. There will also be RIP tracks near by.

 

There is a "Yard" in Dickinson ND, only a few tracks. Most trains do not even stop here given that they are unit coal trains, unit hopper trains, unit oil trains, unit tank trains, and unit grain trains. Only the local turn operates out of Dickinson, and yes there is an fueling and sand station there for these locomotives as Dickinson used to be a crew chang point. But BNSF increased the trip distance from 100 miles to 200 miles, and dropped the smaller change points. This is why unit trains pass without stopping. Or at least without stopping for crew and fuel. The are frequently held her to allow opposing trains to clear the main line before departing again. BNSF seems to run trains in slugs of three in each direction, and of course still have to have layups enroute to allow other trains to pass.

 The unit sand trains will not even make it to Dickinson, they will terminate here in Richardton. Road locomotives will pull directly into the Halliburton plant drop their cars, pick up the empties and scoot back out east where they came froom. I expect to see a lot of foreign or through power on these trains. The Haliburton plant has a six track RIP facility for the sand cars, what I do not know yet is if they will lease an entire fleet themselves or just receive whatever cars come in. I suspect they will lease their own cars since it seemse to me that they will store the sand in the trains until it needs to be transloaded to the transfer towers for loading the road trucks. Drayage can add up if you did not plan for that, and I can assure you, that with the quality that is going into this facility, the must have planned for everything. Why else have six tracks for car repair. This place is built to a higher standard than the main line. It has concrete ties and is well laid out. The mainline switches are automatic: controlled by Ft. Worth, the plant switches are manual, and a switch tender will have to drive around the property setting the turnouts as needed.

There do not seem to be any heavy maintenance facilities in our area.

ROAR

The Route of the Broadway Lion The Largest Subway Layout in North Dakota.

Here there be cats.                                LIONS with CAMERAS

  • Member since
    April 2005
  • From: West Australia
  • 2,217 posts
Posted by John Busby on Saturday, December 19, 2015 4:04 AM

Hi Big boy Forever

Well when you start taking tracks away from prototype yards they tend to start to not working .

In model railroads very few people have room to model prototype yards.

I figure that all loco facilities can be striped out of a yard because most model railroads have a seperate loco facility that can handle those.

That leaves what ever else is needed and this will vary quite conciderably

depending on what is needed at the location and what the "yard" is there to do

It can be anything from a couple of short dead ends, to taking up many miles of ground.

Bear in mind you must have un impeaded acsess to all areas of the yard for it to work properly.

arrivals and departures can just about be cut to one track.

then you nead at least a couple of tracks to sort out the train to where its going

a rip track.

Caboose track is optional depending on is loco close enough and do you even use cabooses.

Like I say it all depends on what the yard is for but I recon with some malice of forethought a working yard can be done with as little as two or three tracks.

Up to OMG that yard is massive

regards John

  • Member since
    May 2014
  • 372 posts
Posted by Big Boy Forever on Saturday, December 19, 2015 12:39 PM

Thanks for all the great replies. I'm pondering over all the different ideas given.

I didn't know that 2 simple tracks could be considered a RR Yard.

I always thought a yard had to be at least one arrival/departure track, with a few sorting classification tracks, (stub or double-ended), refueling, water(for steam), and sand, with at least a bare bones shed for some mechanical maintenance, and maybe 1 or 2 storage tracks for cabooses or special needs cars like hoppers or whatever. I was thinking "minimal" in that sense, sort of a stripped down version of a big yard. "Stripped Down" seems to be the modus operandi' of model railroading in any case.

I am in a possible housing transition mode, with very little time for actually building anything, so this is at best a theoretical armchair conversation on my end, but hopefully would be of interest to anyone thinking or designing a model RR yard of any size. I have a resonable assortment of HO model RR items, cars, tracks, engines a few buildings, but really can't put it to use until my situation is resolved. Ideally one would want a huge yard with all the bells and whistles, if you had the space and money to do it, but who has that here? Probably not too many.

I always think of "Jeffrey" the fine person and brave board member here who passed away a while back, as an inspiriation, when I talked with him. He was in dire straights with his health issues, had very little income, and carried on his model railroading with limited resources, and achieved great results. I'm not saying I am in any situation like his, I'm just saying that you can achieve great results with minimal resources, and in this case, I'm bringing up the specific idea of a minimal yard.

  • Member since
    September 2003
  • 10,582 posts
Posted by mlehman on Saturday, December 19, 2015 1:40 PM

Big Boy,

That's a thoughtful response. Thinking small does make things easier when you've got relatively limited space and resources. I didn't want to dismiss your idea of at least a small engine facility, just wnated to suggest that it's not an absolute requirement.

This is particularly so since the end of steam, which almost always need daily attention. Thus you had engine facilities even at small yards. With diesels, many small yards have either minimal or no engine faciliates, other than maybe a place where the fuel contractor can refuel a unit if it's away from its home base too long. So the need for engine facilities in a small yard depends somewhat on what era you model.

Of course, having more than 2 tracks is better. But oftentimes they can be recycled to other needs during ops, so long as you have need for an emoty track.

So contine to aspire to more varied yard space, but know that you can get a lot of satisfaction even with a few tracks.

Mike Lehman

Urbana, IL

  • Member since
    April 2005
  • From: West Australia
  • 2,217 posts
Posted by John Busby on Saturday, December 19, 2015 10:47 PM

Hi Big Boy Forever

Yes two simple tracks can be considered a yard.

Stripped down as you put it is also how the real railroads work as well.

They don't build anything they don't have to and don't lay any more track than they need to.

Which is why yard size changes over time both up and down.

Ours just don't get smaller after being made bigger.

Remember that the simpleist loco depot is on one track and eminently workable untill the line needs to service more loco's so what happens the depot becomes two tracks and so on.

Its exactly the same with yards.

So you are doing nothing that the real railroads don't do

regards John

  • Member since
    September 2003
  • 10,582 posts
Posted by mlehman on Sunday, December 20, 2015 8:20 PM

Found some example photos of Dove Creek Yard in action, so here's another one of what works for me in this situation.Big Smile

Mike Lehman

Urbana, IL

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Monday, December 21, 2015 8:27 PM

Big Boy Forever
I have a resonable assortment of HO model RR items, cars, tracks, engines a few buildings,

  What era is your current equipment from ( <1900, 1900-1930, 1930s-1950s, 1950-1970, etc).  This info, and the desired modeling period, will help us help you. 

Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Users Online

There are no community member online

Search the Community

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!