Wood ties vs. Concrete ties.

[rrnut282]

NS installed steel ties on the new yard lead at Piqua Yard, used exclusively by Triple Crown (roadrailer) trains. No signal circuits to mess up.

When considering wood vs. concrete, it comes down to initial cost, traffic loads, and lifeteme (when is the next time you'll have an opportunity to work on the line). If the answers are high, heavy, and forever, concrete is the way to go. Everywhere else, wood ties will do nicely.

[BaltACD]

QUOTE: Originally posted by Leon Silverman

CSXrules:
Suspension Bridges flex a lot more than other types of bridges under the same conditions. This does not mean that railroad bridge do not flex at all. They simply experience minimal girations. I leve in South Jersey but still work and visit in Philafephia. when I stopped for traffic jams on I-95 overpasses or the Walt Whitman bridge, I could feel the roadway vibrating from the flexing of the structure. This movement cannot be tolerated by a train if is traveling at any kind of decent speed.

Get stopped on 'any' bridge and you can feel the bridge move in concert with other traffic that may be moving on the bridge.

I worked at a Interlocking Tower in Pittsburgh that was 'bolted' to the side of a bridge across the Allegheney River....made the mistake of leaving my Thermos on top of the desk while I went out to inspect a passing train.....came back in the office and found the Thermos on the floor in pieces....VIBRATION.

[TH&B]

I see steel ties in yards including switches, and no circuts are needed there. So there's lots of oppertunity to use steel ties.

[Anonymous]

The wood ties are used a lot around here in the Des Moines area. You can see them in front of apartment buildings and parking lots. They leave them next to the track bed when they take up tracks that they aren't using anymore. Some people just come up with a pickup truck and take them away. They seem pretty useful.

[richardy]

QUOTE: Originally posted by Hugh Jampton

QUOTE: Originally posted by richardy

QUOTE: Originally posted by james saunders

what bout steel the queensland rail system uses steel exstenvely for ties

Steel ties cannot be used in most of the US where train signal and grade crossing protection systems are present.

Why not? They're used in many other countries that have train signal and grade crossing protection systems.

Are they electric lines?

[Anonymous]

Because steel ties would create a short circuit and all the signals would be red. The signal system requires a short circuit from the wheels of a train in order to detect it, but it wouldn't work with steel ties unless there was insulation between the rail and the tie.

[Hugh Jampton]

QUOTE: Originally posted by richardy

QUOTE: Originally posted by james saunders

what bout steel the queensland rail system uses steel exstenvely for ties

Steel ties cannot be used in most of the US where train signal and grade crossing protection systems are present.

Why not? They're used in many other countries that have train signal and grade crossing protection systems.

[Anonymous]

QUOTE: Originally posted by Train Guy 3

Ties get used for landscaping quite a bit around here but they put a ban on burring cresote ties in the ground. Is that an EPA regulation.

Yes. A pile of ties on the ground burning, as already mentioned, burns at a relatively low temperature. Some creosote is vaporized without combusting and some is only partially combusted. Sometimes the partial combustion products are worse than the original creosote. Also, as already mentioned, a properly designed and properly operated combustion system burns clean (at least not worse than fuel oil, etc.) because of much higher temperatures. By putting a waste heat boiler on such a system, one can recover the energy and use it for something.

[richardy]

QUOTE: Originally posted by james saunders

what bout steel the queensland rail system uses steel exstenvely for ties

Steel ties cannot be used in most of the US where train signal and grade crossing protection systems are present. There is a short line here that uses steel crossties in the approach to and main body of a curve, one is placed about every 40 to 50 feet, the rest are wood. This line does not have train signalling and there are only three protected grade crossings using a very simple insulated island circuit without approach circuits. All of the ties in the island circuits are wood.

[Leon Silverman]

CSXrules:
Suspension Bridges flex a lot more than other types of bridges under the same conditions. This does not mean that railroad bridge do not flex at all. They simply experience minimal girations. I leve in South Jersey but still work and visit in Philafephia. when I stopped for traffic jams on I-95 overpasses or the Walt Whitman bridge, I could feel the roadway vibrating from the flexing of the structure. This movement cannot be tolerated by a train if is traveling at any kind of decent speed.

[Tulyar15]

In Britain in the last 10 years steel ties have become more prevalent. They were tried in the 1930's but the damp British climate meant they rusted too quickly (though this could be reduced by coating them in tar. In the 1980's the preserved Gloucester Warwickshire Railway was given a load of track with steel ties and they coated the good ones with tar and re-used them).

Wooden ties have tended to always be sold off here too. In some cases narrow gauge railways would buy them and saw them in half. Since the 1950's concrete ties have been widely used but London Underground still use wooden because they absorrb more sound.

[Train Guy 3]

Ties get used for landscaping quite a bit around here but they put a ban on burring cresote ties in the ground. Is that an EPA regulation.

[james saunders]

what bout steel the queensland rail system uses steel exstenvely for ties

[jeffhergert]

QUOTE: Originally posted by Murphy Siding

I've found that when I'm trying to find or follow an old, long gone ROW through Iowa,Minnesota or South Dakota cornfields,that the fences around the area will feature a lot of old ties as fence posts.

I've seen some of them fence posts that still had tie plates attached.
Jeff

[Anonymous]

Tie Tek produces a "recycled" tie that serves as alternative to wood and is cheaper than concrete ties. The company has been around a few years. They make the ties from post consumer recycleables such as milk jugs and tires.

http://www.natk.com/ttprod.html

There main customer is UP, but they recently got an order from BNSF. Looks like this might actually take off! There are some photos under the "investers" link...

[edblysard]

Along with Dave pointing out the fact that the creosote would gasify in the high heat of a power plant, you should note you also get creosote from most low temperature burning woods; it is a natural by product, most common with the sap woods like pine.
Check you house hold chimney, and you will find the creosote that is released when you burn wood slowly at a "low" temperature, like a fire in a fireplace coating the flue and chimney, in fact, creosote build up fires are the most common cause of chimney fires.

Old high school science experiment, place a popsicle stick in a test tube, hold it over a low Bunsen burner, rotate it as the wood stick chars, and note the liquid that collects in the tube...natural creosote.
What is used on railroad tie is petroleum by product, and at high temperatures, it burns as clean as household heating oil...

Ed

QUOTE: Originally posted by trainjunky29

Burn creosote--that's got to be good for the environment [:)].

[Anonymous]

Concrete vs. Wood ties are yet another thing the amazing John McPhee discusses in his two-parter on unit coal trains from the PRB (second part, NEW YORKER issue of October 10, 2005). He says the BNSF/UP shared triple track into the PRB region uses concrete and gives a couple of reasons why. I don't think he addressed the role that rebar plays, but otherwise he seems to be pretty much right on the money.

[dldance]

QUOTE: Originally posted by blhanel

I would've figured that they wouldn't be long enough to make a good fence post- by the time you buried enough of it to make it stable, your fence wouldn't even be three feet high.

When I worked for my Granfather in the 1960's, the railroad gave the adjacent landowner first dibs on used ties. Grandad really liked the switch ties as they made great corner posts for his bull pens. At that point a typical used tie had an additional life as a fence post of 10 - 15 years. Pine poles were only good for about 8 to 10 years.

dd

ps- we also experimented with concrete fence posts - good life but they were to heavy to handle and too expensive.

[Murphy Siding]

QUOTE: Originally posted by blhanel

I would've figured that they wouldn't be long enough to make a good fence post- by the time you buried enough of it to make it stable, your fence wouldn't even be three feet high.

If I remember right, they are usually about 8' long. I worked for a lumberyard that sold lots of RR ties. Inevitably, the customer was a grandpa, with his arm in a sling. He had a stock trailer that was full of manure, because he had just taken hogs to the sale barn. "Oh, and you fellers will have to slide them all the way to the front of the trailer, or the pick-up steers funny"[xx(]

[Anonymous]

QUOTE: Originally posted by trainjunky29

Burn creosote--that's got to be good for the environment [:)].

Most so-called "contaminated" woods can easily be gasified for energy production. The contaminates are removed during the gasification process.

[CSXrules4eva]

QUOTE: Originally posted by Leon Silverman

Cannot tell you what is done with old wooden ties. However, pressure treated wood still deteriorates over time if it is buried in the ground. The flexing of wooden ties you mentioned is NOT desireable for trains. If this was so. you would see suspension bridges used on heavy duty railroads. The various designs currently used are intended to provide an unyielding support for the track and trains.
Poured concrete block does, indeed, have very little strength. However, prestressed concrete can support tremendous loads because the concrete always sees only a compressive (where it is extremely strong) load. This is accomplished by stretching the rebar prior to pouring the concrete. Once the poured concrete cures, the rebar is released. In attempting to regain its original length, the rebar now compresses the concrete block. The block will now not crack unless the generated bending moment force exceeds the residual compressive force.

I do have a question here, if the wooden ties did indeed flex, why wouldn't the other bridges like the truss type bridge, the arc bridge, the cable stay bridge or the beam type bridge work, would the suspension type bridge be the only bridge that would work? I personally would think that the cable-stay type bridge would be better. Just curious.

[blhanel]

I would've figured that they wouldn't be long enough to make a good fence post- by the time you buried enough of it to make it stable, your fence wouldn't even be three feet high.

[Anonymous]

Seems to me that concrete ties (or in British, "sleepers") are pretty much the norm on heavily-used European tracks.

[Murphy Siding]

I've found that when I'm trying to find or follow an old, long gone ROW through Iowa,Minnesota or South Dakota cornfields,that the fences around the area will feature a lot of old ties as fence posts.

[Anonymous]

Much of the time they sell the whole lot to the highest bidder, who also gets to haul them away. Some are good, some are better, some are not. Most go to the landscape industry.

[Big_Boy_4005]

Carl, next time I go to Menards I'll have to look. I have this image stuck in my mind of large gray "wood like" objects, with all the creasote leached out, and huge checks and splits down the length. Very rustic, but not necessarily the best long term solution for holding back earth. It is possible that that was the reject pile after the customers had cherry picked off the better ones.[swg] The joys of self service lumber.

Another place where old wood ties go to die is railroad museum operations. They like to buy the ones just above landscape grade. Maybe Menards is buying the ones they remove.[:P][;)]

[CShaveRR]

Believe me, Big Boy, those ties that make it to the landscape people are far from being "some of the worst ones". At least they still look like ties!

[JDV5th]

Old wooden ties- highly valuable for residential retaining walls, right?

[Big_Boy_4005]

Some of the worst ones often end up in the landscaping market, or at least they used to. I'm not sure if they let the creasote out into the general market place anymore.

Concerte ties have disadvantages too. Put a train on the ground, and all the chipped ones need to be replaced. Wood usually survives derailments

[Anonymous]

Burn creosote--that's got to be good for the environment [:)].