https://tstage9.wixsite.com/nyc-modeling
Time...It marches on...without ever turning around to see if anyone is even keeping in step.
James, Brisbane Australia
Modelling AT&SF in the 90s
QUOTE: Originally posted by Cthetrains Tips for starting out: 1. visit a local hobby retailer...HobbyTown, USA is fairly reasonable..proto2000 series steam locos are good quality, and won't kill the bank account, if you want to spend a bit more, Rivarossi has always been my preference...as for track code, ARTHILL is right, just 'tease him' a bit with the loco, and let him decide the detail work...and once again...remember..YOU got him addicted...hehehe
QUOTE: There are FP7's that were made by Roco and sold by Atlas, and more recenty by ER Models that are accurate. The Atlas Trainmaster (with and without QSI sound) is a Reading passenger unit, not a freight. The only Reading steam passenger locos I've ever seen are all brass, various G-class Pacifics. The Hudson is wrong, Reading never had any Hudsons. IHS has a Pacific done as Reading, similar but not identical to either a G1 or G3. It probably can be reworked (and there probably was an article in RMC on doing so at some point), but like I siad, the only truly correct Reading G's are brass and naturally not cheap. Cars are tough to come by - as far as I know, the current IHC cars are prototypes of NOTHING, while the older ones made by Rivarossi usually had at least one prototype they matched, even though they put any name on them they wanted. Thre's a web site listing just about every passenger car model made (in plastic) and what roads they're good for, but I don't have it bookmarked. The cars sold by Bethlehem Car Works are correct Reading cars - they are available in assembled form from Intermountain. But they only offered the coach and combine in RTR. If you want a baggage you'd have to build the kit. The really well-known Reading passenger train was the Crusader, with a streamlined Pacific. There is an old Penn Line kit for the loco, kinda crude but almost as rare and expensive as a brass piece. The 5 cars of the train are pretty much only in brass - I believe there's a set on eBay right now. Oh yeah, the older Rivarossi observation car (smoothside) is the Crusader observation! The train has 2 of them, one at each end, since there was no place to turn the entire train at the Jersey City terminal. And those were the only 2 cars like that ever on ANY railroad, yet that's what Rivarossi made. But the intermediate cars were never made by anyone other than brass, and the brass sets include all 5 cars anyway. After the end of steam, the same cars were pulled by the FP7's, until eventually the whole thing was replaced by RDCs and the cars sent to Canada, I forget if it was CP or CN. One of the observations still exists, now at the PA Railroad Museum in Strasburg. By the end of the Reading, all passenger trains were RDCs. Life-Like has various RDCs in the Proto1000 line that come lettered for Reading and have correct numbers for the type of car. No T-1 yet, last week they said 2 more weeks, so I'm hoping for a call from my guy next week. --Randy
QUOTE: Originally posted by TomDiehl Keep it simple at first, an Athearn F7 in Reading colors, a couple passenger coaches, you can buy trackin a set to make a simple loop or loop with passing siding, and an MRC power pack. Anniversary: buy a couple freight cars and a Reading caboose. A subscription to Model Railroader Magazine Valentines Day: building kits, a couple small industries, a station, a house or two. If he picks up the hobby after this, he'll be telling you what he wants. If not, you don't have a HUGE investment.
QUOTE: Originally posted by piccolotess So if I bought some track locally....at a local flee market...
QUOTE: Originally posted by piccolotess I looked at the IHC web site....very nice variety of passenger cars....but definitely doesn't look like it has very good detail.....very cheap looking.....I hate to say it but I have a bit of an eye for good quality....darn antique collecting....and photography hobby.....just don't think the IHC is lacking detail as you put it. Did you see what James Mitich wrote? how the set isn't quite authentic and also that reading did not in fact have Dome cars. James made a very good point....if it's up to me I want to go historically accurate more then anything else.....even if that means me buying individual pieces....darn my perfectionist and historically accurate side! What is ABBa Arrangement? Oh gosh all of you are tooo helpful....I'm researching everything everyone is saying now...it's going to take me quite a bit of time......you guys might have thrown tooo much at me....but i'm learning a lot!!!! Only, six more pages of these posts to read, translate into English, and understand yet....thanks everyone! Tess
QUOTE: Originally posted by piccolotess Did you see what James Mitich wrote? how the set isn't quite authentic and also that reading did not in fact have Dome cars. James made a very good point....if it's up to me I want to go historically accurate more then anything else.....even if that means me buying individual pieces....darn my perfectionist and historically accurate side!
QUOTE: Originally posted by mthrules May I suggest a nice O gauge starter set from MTH. They have made very nice Reading sets and other trains. Here is their website: www.mth-railking.com Another option is Lionel www.lionel.com
QUOTE: I looked at the IHC web site....very nice variety of passenger cars....but definitely doesn't look like it has very good detail.....very cheap looking.....I hate to say it but I have a bit of an eye for good quality....darn antique collecting....and photography hobby.....just don't think the IHC is lacking detail as you put it.
QUOTE: Gosh....adding sound....tom, you mentioned something about adding sound to the steward reading FT.....so it doesn't come with sound....for some reason I couldn't get that page you sent me to open up and I was having problems through work getting that page to work.....going to try again at home....so the stewart doesn't come with sound....how much do you think it would cost to get the decoder added? I guess thats not something a mechanically minded guy like keith could do himself is it?
QUOTE: Whats the difference with power packs....I don't know anything about that stuff yet....I'm picking up on other things.....MRC power pack????