Trains.com

Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Walthers Quality

7394 views
51 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    January 2009
  • From: Maryland
  • 12,865 posts
Posted by ATLANTIC CENTRAL on Monday, August 31, 2020 5:13 AM

rrinker

 Tell that to JD Power and Consumer Reports, where sister vehicles built ont he same assmebly line and just get different badges put on them get vastly different ratings.

 But really, unless you get one made Friday afternoon before a long weekend, if it's built ont he same line, using the same parts, by the same people - it has the same quality. Amount of detail has no bearing on it.

 Quality, for a model - is more in the motor and drive. Just because all the lift rings aren't indicidually installed doesn't really make it lesser quality, it's just lesser detailed. All the detail, even the stuff you can't see, on Rapido locos wouldn't mean a thing if they slapped a $10 drive under it. I can add a dress up kit with details to my fairly plain Stewart F units, that's not even expensive. But if I had to repalce the drive - that gets expensive. Luckily Stewart drives are quite good, Kato or Buhler motored ones.

                                 --Randy

 

 

Not to go too far afield here, but Consumer Reports? Really? That organization has so much built in bias it is unbelieveable. It does not matter how good a car is at what the manufacturer intended it to be, or how good it is for some people's needs, if it is not what Consumer Reports thinks a car should be, it gets a bad rating.

Sheldon

    

  • Member since
    December 2008
  • From: Heart of Georgia
  • 5,402 posts
Posted by Doughless on Monday, August 31, 2020 10:42 AM

I'd prefer to have the great smooth and quiet power train over the detailed shell. 

Maybe some companies are focusing on drive train and others focus more on the shell details. 

- Douglas

Moderator
  • Member since
    June 2003
  • From: Northeast OH
  • 17,201 posts
Posted by tstage on Monday, August 31, 2020 2:46 PM

Doughless
I'd prefer to have the great smooth and quiet power train over the detailed shell.

You and me both, Douglas.  You can have the most prototype-looking locomotive ever produced.  However, if it doesn't run well...then I have no use for it on my layout.  A poor running locomotive only leads to a frustrating experience.

Tom

https://tstage9.wixsite.com/nyc-modeling

Time...It marches on...without ever turning around to see if anyone is even keeping in step.

  • Member since
    September 2003
  • 10,582 posts
Posted by mlehman on Tuesday, September 1, 2020 1:10 AM

More reason for why Walthers gives you a top quality mechanism first...

Back in the day when you often built your own, the admonition was to get the loco running right before you started adding detail so there is no lengthy pawing over of the details, which were to be added after proper operation was achieved. Given Walthers long history and its ethos, I doesn't surprise me they still emphasize this approach to value and quality.

 

Mike Lehman

Urbana, IL

  • Member since
    January 2017
  • From: Southern Florida Gulf Coast
  • 18,255 posts
Posted by SeeYou190 on Tuesday, September 1, 2020 6:22 AM

Doughless
I'd prefer to have the great smooth and quiet power train over the detailed shell. 

Yes +1

Me too.

-Kevin

Living the dream.

  • Member since
    March 2016
  • 1,548 posts
Posted by PRR8259 on Tuesday, September 1, 2020 7:44 PM

OK, I've owned the older Proto 2000 SD60M, as BNSF #9290, and I've seen and test run the newer Walthers version and they are NOT the same, or even close.  The newer Walthers engines run significantly better than the earlier versions of the "same" model, and they all are heavy and pull like crazy, both new and old.  If you search online, the SD60M at one point was the pulling champion of HO diesel models and is still up near the top...

Detail on the new ones was a little on the light side for me, which is partly why I didn't buy the newest version, and I've since switched to all steam.

However, I have owned several recent Walthers GP-30's AND F-7's and I can tell you they are significantly better (ran significantly better) than earlier efforts (I did own several earlier LL Proto GP-30's)!  No, Walthers does NOT go for Genesis level detail.  Instead, they actually find middle of the road versions they can do that are actually pretty "correct" without adding all the details that Athearn puts on a Genesis level model.

I just recently sold a (practically brand new) Genesis GP-7 on Ebay.  It was a version from a few years back, and it ran poorly...very noisy motor and/or gears.  Buyer still hasn't given me feedback, but it was indeed mint.

Some people don't like the lack of spare parts from Walthers, and I can't help you there. 

My 2c.

John

  • Member since
    June 2007
  • 8,866 posts
Posted by riogrande5761 on Tuesday, September 1, 2020 10:44 PM

I'd be interested if Walthers would make D&RGW GP30 but so far nothing ... walthers runs are few and far between as well so I'm hoping ScaleTrains or Athearn Genesis does a high fidelity GP30.

Rio Grande.  The Action Road  - Focus 1977-1983

  • Member since
    December 2008
  • From: Heart of Georgia
  • 5,402 posts
Posted by Doughless on Wednesday, September 2, 2020 10:35 AM

PRR8259

 

I just recently sold a (practically brand new) Genesis GP-7 on Ebay.  It was a version from a few years back, and it ran poorly...very noisy motor and/or gears.  Buyer still hasn't given me feedback, but it was indeed mint.

 

John

 

Athearn has switched to LED lighting, finally, which has allowed me to begin purchasing Athearn models whereas I never did before.

Genesis has been hit and miss as far as noise.  Both motor noise and in the front truck tower.  While a motor noise may eventually break in, I have found that there is not much solution to a noisy truck tower, short of swapping out worm gears with another unit and getting lucky that it fixes the noise.

Now after purchasing a Genesis diesel, I immediately run it and check for excessive noise.  If it stays noisy after a few minutes on the test track, it gets immediately returned back to the seller under their return policy.  I'm not chasing down noises with a $250 detailed-fragile loco.

- Douglas

  • Member since
    March 2016
  • 1,548 posts
Posted by PRR8259 on Wednesday, September 2, 2020 11:28 AM

Douglas--

Well, hate to say it, but those are all contributing reasons to why I've switched to steam power only.  Granted, with steam power a certain amount of tinkering is often expected anyway, and if I'm going to have to do that, well, I figured I might as well just have steam power.

My son has Gensis 2.0 diesels, and indeed they are excellent.

John

  • Member since
    January 2001
  • From: US
  • 231 posts
Posted by EMDSD40 on Thursday, September 3, 2020 10:26 AM

When it comes to quality, I place more emphasis on the running gear than detail parts. A good quality and accurate paint job is also part of the equation. As far as Walthers specifically my experience has been less than positive. I will start with the early version of the 130 foot TT. Spent two years trying to get that working and gave up. Now it is a well known fact that had issues from the get go. Hundreds of dollars wasted, not to mention the time. It now resides in it's box under the benchwork. I do like the modern diesels and the family really picked up on that the past two Christmas holidays gifting me 15 of the EMDSD70ace locomotives. Everyone out of the box needed something repaired be it handrails, couplers or snowplow. These issues should have been caught in final QC before shipment. The most trouble I had was a UP unit that spit and sputtered down the track. Rather than return it ,I completely disassembled it for repair. What I found was extremely flimsy wipers on the wheels, wiring being 2 or 3 strands at best,wiring pinched in the weight, and loose clips on the PC board. Not to mention the truck assy was packed solid in grease as front wheel bearings on a 1960's car. So much for minimal lubrication. I was able to carefully reform the wipers and repair the wiring resulting in a decent running engine. Let me repeat these parts can very easily be broken...be extremely careful if you attempt repair. Through the years I've had issues with warped plastic frames and parts on autoracks and depressed center flat cars. They did replace 4 of the autoracks years ago. I have 300+ locomotives and 500 freight cars of various manufacturers. Experience with Athearn, Kato, Atlas, BLI, Accurail, P2K, Scale Trains and Roundhouse have been more positive across the board for roughly 45 years. At this point in my life I don't see purchasing much more of anything so it is what it is. Again these are my experiences and hopefully others find their purchases to be trouble free and feel it was money well spent.

  • Member since
    April 2020
  • 526 posts
Posted by Ringo58 on Thursday, September 3, 2020 10:36 AM

EMDSD40

When it comes to quality, I place more emphasis on the running gear than detail parts. A good quality and accurate paint job is also part of the equation. As far as Walthers specifically my experience has been less than positive. I will start with the early version of the 130 foot TT. Spent two years trying to get that working and gave up. Now it is a well known fact that had issues from the get go. Hundreds of dollars wasted, not to mention the time. It now resides in it's box under the benchwork. I do like the modern diesels and the family really picked up on that the past two Christmas holidays gifting me 15 of the EMDSD70ace locomotives. Everyone out of the box needed something repaired be it handrails, couplers or snowplow. These issues should have been caught in final QC before shipment. The most trouble I had was a UP unit that spit and sputtered down the track. Rather than return it ,I completely disassembled it for repair. What I found was extremely flimsy wipers on the wheels, wiring being 2 or 3 strands at best,wiring pinched in the weight, and loose clips on the PC board. Not to mention the truck assy was packed solid in grease as front wheel bearings on a 1960's car. So much for minimal lubrication. I was able to carefully reform the wipers and repair the wiring resulting in a decent running engine. Let me repeat these parts can very easily be broken...be extremely careful if you attempt repair. Through the years I've had issues with warped plastic frames and parts on autoracks and depressed center flat cars. They did replace 4 of the autoracks years ago. I have 300+ locomotives and 500 freight cars of various manufacturers. Experience with Athearn, Kato, Atlas, BLI, Accurail, P2K, Scale Trains and Roundhouse have been more positive across the board for roughly 45 years. At this point in my life I don't see purchasing much more of anything so it is what it is. Again these are my experiences and hopefully others find their purchases to be trouble free and feel it was money well spent.

 

I got a walthers AC4400 for christmas and the rear truck was dangling by the wires was able to fix it in 5 min but thats somthing that I shouldn't have to do. Especially when my family bought it for me.

  • Member since
    September 2002
  • From: North Carolina
  • 1,904 posts
Posted by csxns on Thursday, September 3, 2020 11:15 AM

Ringo58
walthers AC4400

What number is this locomotive can't find a Walthers AC4400 ?

Russell

  • Member since
    April 2020
  • 526 posts
Posted by Ringo58 on Thursday, September 3, 2020 12:01 PM

I'm not even sure it was an AC4400 maybe an ES4400. I don't care for GE stuff so I tend to stay away. All I know is that it's a UP GEVO

  • Member since
    September 2002
  • From: North Carolina
  • 1,904 posts
Posted by csxns on Thursday, September 3, 2020 4:46 PM

Ringo58
I'm not even sure it was an AC4400 maybe an ES4400. I don't care for GE stuff so I tend to stay away. All I know is that it's a UP GEVO

Thinks,saw some at the LHS on sale if the trucks come off i think i will pass on them.

Russell

  • Member since
    April 2020
  • 526 posts
Posted by Ringo58 on Thursday, September 3, 2020 4:51 PM

csxns

 

 
Ringo58
I'm not even sure it was an AC4400 maybe an ES4400. I don't care for GE stuff so I tend to stay away. All I know is that it's a UP GEVO

 

Thinks,saw some at the LHS on sale if the trucks come off i think i will pass on them.

 

 

Just ask to open them up first. It was a really easy fix, but still not somthing that should have to be done right out of the box. But they run very nice

  • Member since
    February 2008
  • 8,680 posts
Posted by maxman on Thursday, September 3, 2020 4:53 PM

Ringo58

I'm not even sure it was an AC4400 maybe an ES4400. I don't care for GE stuff so I tend to stay away. All I know is that it's a UP GEVO

 

 
Is that a steam engine?
 
Seems to me that if you are going to publicly criticize a company or product you should be pretty darn sure what you're talking about first.
 
Just an old guys opinion.
  • Member since
    April 2020
  • 526 posts
Posted by Ringo58 on Thursday, September 3, 2020 5:11 PM

No a GEVO is a 

maxman

 Is that a steam engine?

 
Seems to me that if you are going to publicly criticize a company or product you should be pretty darn sure what you're talking about first.
 
Just an old guys opinion.
 

No a GEVO is a Teir 4 Diesel locomotive built by GE. Theres too many models to keep track of and I prefer EMD stuff. And I have had multiple walthers units with hours of run time on them. And I'm not criticizing them. I like their stuff, was only talking about the detail on them. Did you read the whole thread?

  • Member since
    March 2016
  • 1,548 posts
Posted by PRR8259 on Friday, September 4, 2020 12:09 AM

Well, I guess EMD SD40 has experience with more Walthers engines than me.  Very sorry to hear of the problems with them.

John

Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Search the Community

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!