Dave H. Painted side goes up. My website : wnbranch.com
"I like my Pullman Standards & Budds in Stainless Steel flavors, thank you!"
QUOTE: Originally posted by dougal I agree. The hobby isn't fun with all of this garbage going on. To make matters worse, my last four railfanning trips were disasters, it's starting to get very annoying.
Good Luck, Morpar
QUOTE: Originally posted by rda1964 James: I'm all for a bit of scratchbuilding show and tell. I suggest an "all in" date of July 4th, for symbolic reasons as well as my tendency to sloth. Also, not to sound like a broken record on the topic: I think it best to have two catagories, one for teens and first time scratchers, another "open" to all comers. Of course I'd not INSIST teens submit in the teens catagory. My aim here is to not overwhelm anyone first time out. Count me in. Randy
QUOTE: Originally posted by Dough Thanks Greyhound. One thing about the research though. Are there any books or websites that would offer at least rough demensions of cars? I was sitting here trying to measure a picture and then divide the length out to get its scale...Is their a better way?[;)] I even went to Trinitiy's website, and they have a few more demensions than the side of the car gives. That is a pretty cool site by the way. I'm not thinking that anybody would be too happy if I showed up in a railyard with tape measure in hand...
QUOTE: Originally posted by dknelson Here is an idea for a contest and it is borrowed from something my cub scout troup did, oh around 1960 or so. We were each given an odd assortment of stuff in a bag and told to "do something" with it. Maybe given each contestant the identical bag of bits of balsa and some brick paper and file cards and other odd stuff and see who has the most imagination to make something of it. I predict that the modeler with the best collection of articles by E.L. Moore and a wood burning tool might win this one! Dave Nelson
QUOTE: Originally posted by Morpar I really like the idea too. I have been working on casting Virginian style battleship gondolas, and have thought of making a mold for the modern style Thrall cars. I would scratch the master just to avoid copyright hassles, but where would the castings fall? Would they then be scratchbuilt, or kits? Are we looking also at quantity versus quality? Still some good questions to work out, but I am all for it! I think I'll hold off on the Thrall cars, just in case...
QUOTE: Originally posted by AntonioFP45 Dougal, Please tell up what happened on your railfanning trips. Four bad trips?! That's extreme! If you don't want to reply on this thread than perhaps you could post a new thread/poll on "railfanning trip experiences - ". Poll Categories maybe something like: Amtrak, Historical Society, Museum, Club etc. or the question wouild be Would recommend to friends , not recommend to friends, etc,. You get the picture! God Bless!
QUOTE: Originally posted by 4884bigboy QUOTE: Originally posted by dougal I agree. The hobby isn't fun with all of this garbage going on. To make matters worse, my last four railfanning trips were disasters, it's starting to get very annoying. I imagine dougal thought his last trips were diasters was because all he saw was NS black.[:D][:D][;)][:p] (just kidding) What really happened, dougal?
QUOTE: Originally posted by Snake A "scratchbuild off" sounds like fun and I would love to participate. Hopefully this can become something we do again and again. Some of us are retired and have more time than others to dedicate to modeling. I have read where some folks only have a couple-three hours a week for their hobby. I recommend keeping this in mind when setting start/end dates. The categories and the entry levels sound good. I guess the entries would have to be based on integrity. I.e. an experienced modeler would have to be honest enough to not enter his/her model as a "beginner". Enough "notice in advance" time should be allowed so that we have time to do research, get photos, drawings, etc. prior to starting the assembly/building process, again integrity would apply for the date you "started" building the model. Will you be considering those projects that are completely freelanced versus those that are a replica of a prototype? Looking forward to the "scratchbuild off" and reading all the "help" and "how to" questions that will be propagated by this competion. I am sure this will be a GREAT learning experience for us all. Have you considered asking MR if they would/could help with certificates/ribbons for the winners. It would be nice for the winners to have something to display on their layout for their efforts. Maybe a special note under their number of stars here on the forum. Keep us up to date on your decisions.
QUOTE: Originally posted by tpaulsen I qualify as what most of you would call an old fart and I think the concept of going back to scratch building is simply marvelous. I hope you guys get your contest up and going. More power to you. And, yes, welcome to the 50's. Model railroading was fun then too. Tom
QUOTE: Originally posted by Dough Thanks Greyhound. I'm going to give the shed a shot next weekend. I am in college as well and modeling constanly gets pushed down as a priority. I usually have big surges and then slow periods. My old hobby shop is now much more of a drive as well. But I'll give it a shot none the less and also pratice with some kitbashing before moving on. There is also a Model Rail show coming soon and I hope to pic up a few ideas as well as supplies there. I'm just trying to figure out what I need ahead of time.