railsounds or sound commander??

[mpzpw3]

A small update. For some reason I forgot that the tender had 2 pick-up rollers for the whistle and bell sounds. Look before you post in my case! I have e-mailed Electric RR and TAS in regards to sounds. I really enjoy my railsounds add-on tender, but don't see much difference between it, and the samples the Electric RR have on the web-site (I do notice the price differance, though). I e-mailed TAS because I am interested in the turbo-smoke unit, if it will fit. Your opinions, and the replies from these companies interest me greatly!! Any help is always appreciated!!

[Anonymous]

Jon at Electric RR could probably tell you if the unit will work with a Williams e-unit. He's always gotten back to me within 24hrs with answers to my questions. Unless you're planning on eventually running command, Railsounds is a bit of a waste running conventional.

You can listen to samples of the sounds on the internet. Pick your favorite and have at it.

[mpzpw3]

I am wanting to add sounds to a Williams berkshire, and am not sure which way to go. I like the sounds of the sound commander, but after reading the website, doubt it will work with the electronic e-unit in the Williams engine in conventional operation. The railsounds kit from Digital Dynamics looks like it will work, but will have to add a tether and it looks like I will have to settle for Northern or Hudson sounds. Which one would be closer to the Berk? Any suggestions?