Trackside with Erik and Mike, Vol. 61

[Modelcar]

....This week it has to be Erik's night shot. I must admit night shots are a favorite of mine.
It looks like a good night shot to me with rather sharp rendition.
I have nothing against Mike's shot it just happens to be up against a night shot that I prefer...

[Datafever]

I love train yards.  I love rural America.  To compare these two pictures is like trying to compare apples with oranges.  I like both of them.  How does one truly decide which of two incomparable objects (or pictures in this case) is better?

Thank you both, Mike and Erik, for the wonderful work that you do to put together this column.  I enjoy every installment.

[samfp1943]

You guys are killing me!

   First; I am not a pohotgrapher, more of a point and shoot with my Wal-Mart disposable.

   Second; I enjoy all the pictures you put up for us to see.

   Third; What is the prize for the"winner" in this contest? 

        A keg of Milwaukee's finest foamy soda, and a wheelbarrow full of J-ville Brats?

[edblysard]

Bergie gets my vote too, although I am biased just a bit towards yard shots…go figure!.

The fact that the train is indeed snaking through a “canyon” of other cars just rings my bell, so to speak, plus the shape and texture of the cars on either side of the locomotive add to the illusion.

Everyday working sight for me, but that might be the reason it attracts me more than Mike’s shot.

[PBenham]

No need to get out the Vermont quarter, Bergie gets the vote from me! That night shot is a winner! It took more than just reliance on the camera to get that to work, in fact, I'd say Bergie had to ignore some of the camera's systems. (calling for use of a flash or whatever.)
Mike's shot is too routine when stacked up against the night shot. Erik's effort pays off with me.

[TimChgo9]

Wow, tough to choose.

I like Erik's picture alot, the discoloration from the sodium vapor lights give the scene a surreal quality, that I quite like. It imparts a feeling of "late night-around-the-clock" activity that railroading is all about. I like the composition too, the "canyon" created by the two trains on either side, let your eyes go right to the subject, the oncoming freight. Very well done photo...

Now, Mike's is just as good. I love the sharpness, and the colors in his photo. He captures the train nicely, and it is very well done, lighting is even, and it is a nice looking scene.

I am going to have to flip a coin on this one.

Heads = Erik
Tails = Mike.....

And the result is: Heads. Erik gets my vote.!

[blhanel]

Extremely tough choice today- both are very cool shots.  I flipped a coin and went with Eric's.

[spokyone]

I did not like the pic that Eric submitted for judging. That pic would win if it had been daylight. Oh! I loved his pic of BNSF2017. So I voted for Mike this month.

[CShaveRR]

I thought the lighting problems came from the discoloration provided by the sodium vapor lights all around the yard.  Nonetheless, I voted for Erik's this time, because it gave the same feel of busy-ness that Mike's did in the last contest.  I'm seeing more than one thing happening here (or getting ready to happen), and that is real railroading to me. 

I've often said that I'm not a photographer, and even when I hang out with talented people like CopCar Chris, nothing is likely to rub off on me.  So photographers may choose Mike's colorful shot--and there's nothing wrong with it that I'm aware of.

[senshi]

Went with Mike's this time.  The night BNSF shot is good but the flare off the head unit throws the lighting off the picture off for me.

[Bergie]

I just posted the latest installment of Trackside with Erik and Mike in our new section within the Railroad Reference area of TrainsMag.com.

Read Trackside with Erik and Mike Volume 61

Voting for Trackside with Erik and Mike now occures at the top of the Trackside with Erik and Mike section. Click here to vote.

Please add your comments regarding this week's photos here.

Thanks, Erik