QUOTE: Originally posted by gabe QUOTE: Originally posted by SP9033 Gabe Wrote: "I think building a levy is a local undertaking, and I think that is a definite mistake we may all point to." I think your wrong here Gabe, the responsibility for the levies around New Orleans have been historically for many years that of the Army Corp of Engineers. Its within their budget that funds are made available for the levies around New Orleans. They are the ones that engineer and contract the improvements and oversee construction. It is not the City of New Orleans. Good to see you here and posting. I miss your wit. Jim Jim, Thanks for the kind words. I understand your--and Jay's--point that much, if not all of the construction of the NO levy system was through the Army Corp of Engineers. There is no question that the both of you are right on that ground. While conceeding both of your very valid points, when there are several hurricanes in the Gulf that reach category 4-5 strength in the last decade, I don't think it is a fair excuse for the local government to say "whether it comes up and not where it comes down, that's not my department says Dr. Vernon Vaun Brown (sp?)." I am far from an avid studier of levies, but I knew of this problem last year. Certainly NO emergency management did years before this and had to know it was simply a matter of time before a category 4 or 5 hit the city. The levies protect local interests, local interests should be the first ones to blame if they are not proper. If the feds only built a category 3 levy, NO should have taken it upon itself to protect itself with category 5 levies when the problem became apparent. I just don't like the contention that "if the federal government does not fix a local problem, then the local government should be absolved of responsibility." But, I think your point about the Army Corp of Engineers is valid. Gabe
QUOTE: Originally posted by SP9033 Gabe Wrote: "I think building a levy is a local undertaking, and I think that is a definite mistake we may all point to." I think your wrong here Gabe, the responsibility for the levies around New Orleans have been historically for many years that of the Army Corp of Engineers. Its within their budget that funds are made available for the levies around New Orleans. They are the ones that engineer and contract the improvements and oversee construction. It is not the City of New Orleans. Good to see you here and posting. I miss your wit. Jim
QUOTE: Originally posted by eolafan I think your wrong here Gabe, the responsibility for the levies around New Orleans have been historically for many years that of the Army Corp of Engineers. Its within their budget that funds are made available for the levies around New Orleans. They are the ones that engineer and contract the improvements and oversee construction. It is not the City of New Orleans. Well, it may have historically been the provance of the Army Corps of Engineers, but running and protecting the city of NO and state of LA is the ultimate responsibility of those elected to city and state office...that's what they are there for!
QUOTE: Originally posted by Junctionfan Well I understand how Canadian laws and the basics of how it coordinates itself to work pretty well. Canada doesn't have 50 million agencies getting in each other's way. In Toronto, there was really bad snow storm and completely shutting down the city. Mel Lastman who at time was the major, called in the military which took over. Very effective, as the ambulances couldn't go through the snow, ARVs and APCs were used instead.
QUOTE: Originally posted by dharmon QUOTE: Originally posted by Junctionfan But Dan, didn't they already train for that scenario? What kind of timetable did they expect? I'm of course talking about FEMA. You're exactly the audience the networks love.....easy to convince, ignores reality and quick to mouth off. Don't let realities or facts dissuede you. You seem to have it wired.... I sure hope you're in charge if Canada has a disaster.
QUOTE: Originally posted by Junctionfan But Dan, didn't they already train for that scenario? What kind of timetable did they expect? I'm of course talking about FEMA.
QUOTE: Originally posted by Junctionfan Questions. Now I will say this, I find it odd that the national guard didn't evacuate the city to begin with. No offense to the police but trying to evacuate a city that size in a short period of time is out of the police's league. I don't understand this signing a waiver malarky and leaving them there.
QUOTE: Originally posted by dharmon QUOTE: Originally posted by Junctionfan What the hell is wrong with you dude? I hope I'm out of line hear but you really don't critisize a man who has had no sleep, low clean water, rampid crime, excriment and urine everywhere, near dead or dying bodies rotting and being feasted on by rats, listening to suffering and plees of mercy. It didn't take more then 48 hours to get supplies to Indonesia during the Tsunami but 5 days to get security forces and supplies into your own city? They did take too long. You would have to be a half-wit. I just he learned that Fidel Castro has offered and mobilized 2600 doctors if needed; 2600! If Bush doesn't except this, he is a bigger schmuk then I thought he was. What the hell is wrong with me? I would have to be a nit wit......<I was in the process of explaining my witless point of view, but I think that Ed has done a much better job...thanks Ed..who by the way is much closer to this then both of us...> So instead let's talk some realities...... First, I am extremely upset that this preventable tragedy has occured. Preventable because it did not have to end up like this. This is the three little pigs on a grand scale. If you don't take the time and spend the money to build the house right, then you're going to be depending on those that did to save your bacon when the big bad wolf comes a knockin'. And on short term note.....the big bad wolf didn't sneak up on them like the Tsunami did.....it came with warning......and on a long term note...the Gulf coast happens to be haven for wolves of this kind....they just haven't chosen to prey on the NOLA piggies for awhile.... so living in the straw house has it's drawbacks eventually..... Now let's talk about response...... You don't place anything near the epicenter that you expect to use later.....and that includes people..National Guard, FEMA guys, etc.....or they become casualties too. It's that simple. Bridges are down, power is out, roads flooded. So you need boats and helicopters...right? Where do helicopters that expect to live during hurricanes? They go away where the hurricane isn't and come back. They don't get buried in little holes, and hangars don't stand up to gale force winds real well. It takes time. Boats too....if you expect them to survive you move them or lose them. Plain and simple. Once it's over, you assess the situation, try to affect immediate life threatening rescues and marshall resources. Prioritization.....or triage let's say.....folks not in immediate threat of being swept away can wait a bit. If they can walk and talk to reporters, then they are not an emergency.....they can wait. Folks on a roof top surrounded by water get help first. And when they choose to shoot at the helicopter when it comes....it ain't coming back. Infrastructure is key...many roads are impassable, rail lines have to be cleared, soft ground cannot be used as a landing field for heavy aircraft. Stuff has to be done methodically or resources get wasted and spread out. You have to also look at the resources you are being offered and try to not bring in too much because, rescuers themselves require support...shelter, food, water..etc....and there becomes a point where there get to be too many manage and direct and logistics strain in itself. Some say put it on ships standing offshore....so the ships now have to ride out a hurricane...ever been in a hurricane on a ship...I have and its no fun. Providing the ship and it supplies are not damaged, the crew is in no shape to do anything but recover themselves. There's alot more involved than swooping down and magically grabbing everyone...alot more. And I know that. Its hard painful work to decide where assets get placed first. All we see is what the networks choose to show and they show the worst. Shepard Smith, plugged into Fox central is just as capable of telling folks to get to the Superdome as is anyone, but chooses to whine about the lack of help. He's not helping, just fanning the flames. Lots of countries are offering to help. That's great and truly appreciated. Some we could use, some we don't need. Like more people there...like I said more people starts to saturate the area becoming a logistics drain. It's not meant to slight anyone. But a methodical and rational approach has to be taken to sort the resources. So do I choose to not be overly sympathetic to the mayor of NOLA...sure. He was simply hoping to get through his term with nothing like this occuring.....he bet on status quo and lost. Blaming those trying to pick up the pieces isn't helping either. You are where you are, they are at ground zero....cut them some slack and give them the benefit of the doubt that they might have a big picture in mind. Dan
QUOTE: Originally posted by Junctionfan What the hell is wrong with you dude? I hope I'm out of line hear but you really don't critisize a man who has had no sleep, low clean water, rampid crime, excriment and urine everywhere, near dead or dying bodies rotting and being feasted on by rats, listening to suffering and plees of mercy. It didn't take more then 48 hours to get supplies to Indonesia during the Tsunami but 5 days to get security forces and supplies into your own city? They did take too long. You would have to be a half-wit. I just he learned that Fidel Castro has offered and mobilized 2600 doctors if needed; 2600! If Bush doesn't except this, he is a bigger schmuk then I thought he was.
QUOTE: Originally posted by dekemd I've listened and listened to the mayor of NO complain of no help. In one interview he said the Feds need to go get all the Greyhound buses and get them down there. My question is what happened to all the NO city buses and school buses? Why weren't they taken out of the city to higher ground and have them ready to help evacuate?
I tried to sell my two cents worth, but no one would give me a plug nickel for it.
I don't have a leg to stand on.
QUOTE: Originally posted by drephpe According to my wife, who should know because she works with the issue, TX has added approximately 26,000 new clients to the welfare rolls in the last 2 days, and that number is expected to skyrocket over the next week. And with only a hope of the state being reimbursed by either LA or the feds, so at this point their welfare is being paid for by TX taxpayers and, indirectly financially displaced TX welfare recipients. We're all happy to do it--no griping about it from our side-the welcome mat is out, as Ed has indicated. So under the circumstances, they have no right to gripe about the accommodations or turnaround time for sign-up and benefit receipt offered to them over here.
QUOTE: Reminds me of Mark Twain's exposition of the difference between a man and a dog.
QUOTE: Give the 14 year old kid in the johnboat a medal!
Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.