Modeling Railroads of the 1950s Special MR editon

[SilverSpike]

QUOTE: brown_royce Posted: Today, 09:07:15
Is anyone still waiting to receive their issue? I still don't have mine!

Nope! Neither hide nor hair in these parts!

Maybe today, I'll check the mail again at lunch.

Keeping my fingers crossed though!

[Anonymous]

Is anyone still waiting to receive their issue? I still don't have mine!

[CNJ831]

Haven't gotten my copy yet but await it with great anticipation! Regarding further editions addressing different decades, I'd certainly think there would be decided demand for the 1940's and 1960's but, considering modeling interest breakdowns by decade that appear from time to time, I tend to doubt there would be wide demand for editions before and after these dates. Perhaps the 1920's-1930's could be combined, as well as the 1970's-1990's, for a broader (read more profitable) audience.

CNJ831

[cwaldman]

I think there was a note sbout displaying until December or something like that, so it should be on stands somewhere. I am doing the 50's 60's and 70's so this is great. Lots of good information. Plus the billboard article was very timely for me as I have begun to scratch build some. I have several done. But I did like the one picture of the ad being changed. Nice idea. I may have to use that concept on my next one.

Cletus

[CBQ_Guy]

I got mine a couple days ago in the mail. It's okay but there's something missing or slightly unsatisfying, though I'm not sure what. I think it could have probably used more meat . . . but I'm a bit of an info junkie so maybe it's just me.

Anyway, I'm really hoping they do one for the 1960's, the era I'm modeling.

[ereimer]

i don't model the 50's but i'm going to look at it when it hits the magazine racks anyway . i might buy it . what i think would be cool is if they'd do one every year but focus on a different decade . with my luck they'll do 50's to present date and then 40's backwards to the begining of railroads . since i'm modelling the 1900's it will take 9 years for them to produce the one i really want !

[bikerraypa]

I got mine the other day and have read it pretty thoroughly. It's got some good info, particularly about using billboards (as mentioned above). My pike is Fall 1956, and I had never thought to put up an "I Like Ike" billboard with the election only a month or so away. Doh!

Ray out

[Billba]

I received a copy over this past weekend. Haven't read much of it, but it looks like a good variety of subjects. According to Model Railroader's add, it is supposed to be in stores by August 30.

[Anonymous]

Do you have to order a copy, or can you buy one off the shelf? I really want it, but forgot when it came time to order.

[grandeman]

QUOTE: Originally posted by davekelly

It would be great if they followed this one up like you suggest. Would love to see one on the 60's!

+1

[potlatcher]

Based on these reports, I expect to see my copy in the mail this week, possibly even when I come home tonight. My primary modeling era is 1955 so I had no problem pre-ordering this magazine sight unseen, and I don't believe I will be disappointed.

However, my secondary modeling era is 1972, so here's my vote for Kalmbach to follow up with a 1970's version. The 1950's were a transition era from steam locomotives to diesel, but the '70's were also a transition era. First generation diesels were phased out in favor of second generation, timetable/train order and ABS were phased out in favor of CTC and radio dispatching, and many of the "old guard" railroads gradually disappeared into new mega-merger railroads (and some disappeared completely).

Opinions vary whether all these changes were good or bad, and no one can deny that a lot of railroads looked downright ratty during the '70's. Unlike the 1950's, it's a love-it-or-hate-it period for railroad fans, but I believe it is worth modeling.

I guess the only question for Kalmbach is whether modelers would take one look at the cover of a "Modeling Railroads of the 1970's" and say to themselves, "Yuck!" Or, would their curiosity be aroused enough to look inside to find a bunch of interesting modeling info that would be worth the cover price?

Tom

[bscroggi]

I got mine Monday and I think it is one of the best efforts Kalmbach has put out in a while. Davekelly, I think you are on track (sorry!) about following up with the 60's. Thanks Model Railroader.
Bud

[rexhea]

Got mine yesterday. Boy! It sure brought back some gooooood memories. Lots of good info and pictures.
REX

[SilverSpike]

Ordered it a few weeks ago, still waiting with much anticipation for its arrival.

[Anonymous]

I am waiting for the post staggers/mega-merger edition [:D]

But will have to pick it up at the newsstand, I forgot to pre-order. I am interested in the Diesel one they have coming.

[ARTHILL]

Got mine today. Could have been more, but as is, it is more than I expected. That's my era, so I loved it. They could do a volume 2 as far as I'm concerned.

[selector]

QUIT TEAZIN' ME!!!!

[Anonymous]

Yea, there's one article on setting the scenery, and they mention that billboards were quite common everywhere. It's been so long since I've seen a billboard that I completely forgot about them!

Funny thing is, I spent my first 6 years of life in the 50's, and this book reminded me of how much I've forgotten about them. [:P]

[selector]

Ordered one, but not here as of yesterday's mail.

[davekelly]

Man, I forgot all about this deal. Better hurry up and order a copy.

Joe,

It would be great if they followed this one up like you suggest. Would love to see one on the 60's!

Dave

[Anonymous]

Arrived in yesterdays mail, and it's great! I've already read about 1/3 of it. Lot's of great info on what the world of the 1950's was like, and how to make your railroad look like it's set in that time and place.

I believe it's a one-shot, though they may follow up with other decades if there's enough demand for it.

[Anonymous]

Has anyone received Modeling the1950s special edition yet? It was to be delivered by late august, however, Kalmbach usually is early. Wonder if this is a onetime magazine, or will it be annual like MR Planning and great model railroads? I am expecting this issue is going to be something great!