Either one will do. Both will handle at least 6-8 sound locos running simutaneously. the size of the layout doesn't realy matter, the amount of locos you're going to run at the same time does. The Digitrax will handle a few more than the NCE. I presonnaly prefer the NCE as it has a handheld throttle and the Zepher is a stationary throttle. You can always buy a utility throttle the run on the club's layout.
Jay
C-415 Build: https://imageshack.com/a/tShC/1
Other builds: https://imageshack.com/my/albums
The real question is how many trains you will be runnign on it at the same time. You could fill up an aircraft hanger with a layout but if you only ever run a single train, it won't stress a basic system.
The 3 amps on the Zephyr Xtra should be good for at least 8 HO locos - I've run that many on my original Zephyr with is 2.5 amps.
Since you club is Digitrax, if having local support available matters, go with Digitrax. Basic operation is pretty much identical with either system. Back when I went DCC, I researched the variou systems and went Digitrax mainly on the strengths of the Loconet command bus. Finally I am working on a layout that will actually utilize the capabilities for signalling and detection (well, I was when I went to DCC, too, but before it ever got that far my life situation changed and that layout was abandoned).
--Randy
Modeling the Reading Railroad in the 1950's
Visit my web site at www.readingeastpenn.com for construction updates, DCC Info, and more.
Good day folks
I'm currently working on my new layout which will be DCC this time around and looking for something that will be able to handle what I need but also not break the bank. I've pretty much narrowed it down to NCE and Digitrax. I like Digitrax because my club uses it and I like NCE because it seems easier to use.
However there are pros and cons with each. I'm trying to decide if I can get by on their starter sets or do I need to upgrade to the 5amps.
My layout will be a 8'x12' HO double track main line with a 5-6 yard/terminal and a few sidings/industries. It's based off the MRR track plan Eaglecreek and Northern Ry.
Most of my engines are DCC w/Sound and are by Atheran, BLI, Bachmann, etc.
My question is sort of two-fold.
1. Can I get by on using either of the above two basic starter sets Digitrax Zephyr or the NCE Powercab or would I have to upgrade to the NCE Pro Cab and Digitrax Super Chief or Empire builder?
2. All things considered price is a factor but what would you do if it was your layout?
P.S. I don't know a thing about DCC besides just using the throttles and running trains
Regg