WHat confuses the heck out of peopel is that the CV numbers aren;t in order. After all, in the real world, things have a beginning, middle, and end - in order. But the addition of a midpoint speed CV was an afterthought and isn;t even a requirement for NMRA compliance, so it got tacked on AFTER the others. So the order is CV2, then CV6, then CV5 for start, middle, and max.
But hey, it wouldn't be as much fun it it werer all simple and straightforward.
--Randy
Modeling the Reading Railroad in the 1950's
Visit my web site at www.readingeastpenn.com for construction updates, DCC Info, and more.
Soo 61245 I've installed the Digitrax DH156IP decoder in my Genset and the engine ran fine. I made some changes to CV2 and it was still ok. But then I bumped CV6 up to about 20 and the engine ran rough and barely moved. Pushing CV6 up to 150 and it ran fine. Would the capacitors cause the problem I was having with CV6 set at 20? john
I've installed the Digitrax DH156IP decoder in my Genset and the engine ran fine. I made some changes to CV2 and it was still ok. But then I bumped CV6 up to about 20 and the engine ran rough and barely moved. Pushing CV6 up to 150 and it ran fine.
Would the capacitors cause the problem I was having with CV6 set at 20?
john
What you did by setting CV6 to 20 is make the medium speed creeping. If you max the throttle it would take off at some point. Typically it is set to half of CV5. From there you set up or down to speed match with other loco's.
Springfield PA
Pretty much any decoder with BEMF will be confused by the capacitors as they will not see the expected signal from the motor during the monitoring period. This usually shows up in Bachmann locos which have 1 to 3 small capacitors across the motor for RF supression. The purpose of those large ones Atlas used - I too am waiting to see what the explanation for that is. They're too large to provide much supression of the common frequencies which would cause radio and TV interference.
Soo 61245... Would the capacitors cause the problem I was having with CV6 set at 20?...
Would the capacitors cause the problem I was having with CV6 set at 20?...
I do not know if the capacitor caused the problem in your case. But it is at least very uncommon to have a large capacitor parallel to the motor. Atlas did not explain why they did that unique feature up to now. I monitor the Atlas forum and wait for an explanation.
However, it is save to assume that the designer of the DCC decoder did not expect that capacitor, Some decoders done worry but my two (ESU and Zimo) went havoc. It suggest just to temporary remove one capacitor wire from one side of the terminals at the PCB. It is an easy test and you know if your decoder likes the capacitor or fights it.
Reinhard
Hamltnblue The DH165IP would be a better choice. Here's a pic of one installed. It's the small square board on top of the factory board.
The DH165IP would be a better choice. Here's a pic of one installed. It's the small square board on top of the factory board.
Excellent photo. Thanks.
Do you have ever try to connect the ditch light wires to DH165IP? Does it workable?
Enjoy Model Railway
rrinker The Genset has an 8 pin plug, you can use a less expensive decoder with an 8 pin plug instead of the complete board replacement. --Randy
The Genset has an 8 pin plug, you can use a less expensive decoder with an 8 pin plug instead of the complete board replacement.
Hi Randy,
Thanks your suggestion. Because I found Genset has two set ditch light function. I would like to use four output to connect them and I can use F1 and F2 to control them on different direction. But I know I have to re-work the ditch light PC board first.
faraway I feel sorry for you, that is tough luck. But without any diagnostic possibilities it might be a good idea to send it to someone.
I feel sorry for you, that is tough luck. But without any diagnostic possibilities it might be a good idea to send it to someone.
I sure hope I didn't damage the decoder. The very first one I tried to install, a tsunami, I fried the sucker! Ouch! Ever since then I've been having a professional installer do it for me. I thought this was a quick plug and play, ...maybe not.
Michael
CEO- Mile-HI-RailroadPrototype: D&RGW Moffat Line 1989
Hmm, ya I thought it would be fairly straight forward install. I've been having bad luck installing decoders. So I'm just sending it to an installer who has done work for me before. And hopefully he'll figure out what the problem is.
I don't have another decoder to test, and my NCE system can't run DC. I don't have a regular DC pack.
Might be a bad decoder or bent pin.
Do as the previous poster suggested and replace the plug with the original to try in DC.
If that works try another decoder. If you don't have one maybe you can steal one from another loco to try it. The decoder doesn't have to fit, just leave the shell off to test.
I do not see a failure in your description. That what I did. I did cut the old wired to/from the capacitor close to the terminals on the PCB. I hope your somewhat longer old capacitor wires (they are in fact connected to the motor) are well insulted and did not make wrong contact.
I suggest just to swap the decoder with the dummy plug and see if it still runs ok with DC. Next step would be another decoder. That can all be done within a minute with the shell still open.
Help!!! It's not working. I tried using address 03, and completely nothing, no movement, no lights. I just installed the decoder, it's NCE N14SRP. I cut out the big capacitors and just left the wires from them tucked in. Was I supposed to connect those black and red wires somewhere?
All I did was remove the 8 pin plug, and plugged the decoder in. The orange wire from the plug to the #1 on the factory board. It has a wiring harness, and I put that where the capacitors were.
What did I do wrong?
Yes, the factory board is still in. The DH165IP is about the size of a quarter with the 8 pin connector underneath. It simply plugs in to the 8 pin connector on the factory board.
I'm going to be installing a decoder in my Genset this weekend. So you kept the factory board in? Please explain.
Also I will be removing the large capacitors.
It's my first time to post in here. I would like to inquire can we install Digitrax DH165K0 decoder to Genset?
If they got wired wrong it would probably go poof - but just the capacitors, not the motor on the loco.
Two 100uF caps connected like that make a 50uF bi-polar capacitor. Whatever reason they felt they needed that much - well, I'm still waiting.
Hamltnblue The way the capacitors are wired is that the 2 negative leads are soldered together with the 2 positive leads going to the motor. Maybe some have the polarity of one of them wrong and causing the poof.
The way the capacitors are wired is that the 2 negative leads are soldered together with the 2 positive leads going to the motor. Maybe some have the polarity of one of them wrong and causing the poof.
Mine are soldered in the same way.
Back to back electrolytic caps make a non-polarized capacitor - since electrolytics are polarity sensitive this is important since they are across the motor terminals and can be either polarity, depending on if you are going forward or reverse.
Depending on just how big they are, there will be an inrush when power is first applied, and when changing directions, although a normal DC pack should absorb this with no problems. On anything with a pulse form of power, it will appear as more or less of a short depending on the pulse frequency. For example, the capacitor supplied with the old Soundtraxx DSX and DSD decoders that went in series with the speaker, blocked low frquencies but allowed higher ones to pass. Parallel to the motor, the capacitors will appear 'open' to DC (high resistence) and more of a short (low resistence) as the frequency goes up. The exact resonant frequency is determined by the capacitor value as well as the motor inductance. The smaller the capcitor, the higher the frequency - thus the small caps on Bachmann locos to absorb RF frequencies that could interfere with your TV or radio. These large ones seem to be more of a keep alive or power filtering device.
IN any case, a 'silent' DCC decoder uses high frequency PWM so that any 'singing' in the motor is above normal human hearing range. The capcitors will interfere with this. They can also block part or all of the BEMF from the motor which also doesn't help. Not all decoders are the same, if the 'silent drive' frequency is near the resonant frequency of the capacitor/motor circuit, or an integer multiple of it, it will be far worse than if the drive frequency was well offset from an even multiple of the resonant frequency. Some decoders, aprticular the European ones, have adjustments for this frequency, to better fine tune the decoder to a particular motor. Others pretty much have just an on/off for the silent running feature.
I'll wait to see what reasons Atlas gives for incorporating these large capacitors on an otherwise DC loco. It should be interesting.
I didn't note the value of the caps when I removed mine last night, but they were wired in series.
My thought was that they may be filtering the pulsed DC on the motor side for use with DCC systems that use Address 0 for DC. By attempting to filter maybe the value of the caps is tuned to the MRC frequency and looking like a short.
I'd love to see the reasoning for those caps. It CAN'T be RF supression, they are far too big to block the frequencies generally involved. My guess it it's some attempt at doing a keep alive for DC.
It's might work as-is for a decoder that doesn't have a high frequency drive, the Bachmanns with the little caps work fine when the decoder isn't a high frequency one, like the ones they provide for the DCC On-board locos. But those caps are so large they might also interfere with the non-silent decoders as well.
Or maybe the whole thing is a mixup by the Chinese factory - the specs said .01uF capacitors (liek Bachmann uses) and the factory thought they said .01F.
Hamltnblue What is the modification that is talked about here? Removing the caps? I just picked one up with a ditigrax DH165IP decoder. It ran very smoothe and silent in the LHS. I noticed that it has ditchlights which is rare for an atlas. I'll open it up and take pics later. Maybe even make use of the 6 function decoder with those ditch lights.
What is the modification that is talked about here? Removing the caps?
I just picked one up with a ditigrax DH165IP decoder. It ran very smoothe and silent in the LHS. I noticed that it has ditchlights which is rare for an atlas. I'll open it up and take pics later. Maybe even make use of the 6 function decoder with those ditch lights.
I have got two BNSF engines for DC only. They have the large capacitors installed. Both engines got a first test run with a very old DC supply. They ran smooth without problems.
My changes was triggered by reports of to little space to install H0 decoders. I did simply plug one into the 8-pin plug and tried to put the shell back. That did not work due to limited space. Next was a test run with a half open shell. I noticed very bad run at low speed on both engines with Zimo and ESU DCC decoders.
I ignored that problem and started search for a place for the decoder to install. I thought about some milling on the front weight and removed it for further analysis. That was the moment when I discovered the capacitors directly connected to the motor wires at the PCB.
Removal of the capacitors solved both problems. I got space for the decoder and the motor runs very smooth with the decoder.
I have no idea what for those capacitors have been installed with the long wires. It makes no sense to do that for any RFI reasons. You would take capacitors in the Nano Farad range and connect them as close as possible to the motor.
However, because the engine ran fine with an very old DC supply it would be overstated to say Atlas failed to deliver a DC version. Furthermore might be DCC decoders on the market that have no problems with the huge capacitors. I am somewhat carefully to blame Atlas because I did not fully understand what happened. It is just not very unusual.
May be someone with a functional Userid in the Atlas forum can ask for an explanation? I see quite frequent kindly responses from Atlas in their forum.
jalajoie Reinhard, Someone on the Atlas forum followed your instructions, he removed those caps and installed a DH123 in the enclosure. He is very please with the way his Genset now operates. I will let him know I transmitted his thanks to you.
Reinhard,
Someone on the Atlas forum followed your instructions, he removed those caps and installed a DH123 in the enclosure. He is very please with the way his Genset now operates.
I will let him know I transmitted his thanks to you.
Thanks and Thanks,
yep my Genset is running wonderfully, just got one left to modify. Thanks Jalajoie, I did not realize I was on here too.
Jack W.
jalajoie I am not much into electronics, what is the purpose of thes caps? Is it to suppress radio interference?
I am not much into electronics, what is the purpose of thes caps? Is it to suppress radio interference?
That is the usual function of a capacitor at that place. But you are using a much smaller capacitor to "catch" the higher frequencies only. This large capacitors do massive interfere with the motor control of the decoder. It is in some sense like a shortcut for the motor management of the decoder.
ps. I saw your posting in the Atlas forum. I can't post there because my multiple registrations have never been answered by the admins over there.