I don't believe that I would classify any of them as easy-to-use. But time spent learning the program does pay off. I have designed a couple of hundred different layouts with 3rd PlanIt and I’m happy with the program. (I don't routinely use the 3-D or train-running features, but they seem to work fine)
I also own a copy of CADRail and it works well. I’ve also used XTrackCAD and tried the demo of AnyRail. One of the differences between the programs is in the user interface, so try them before you make the investment in dollars and/or learning time.
IMHO, 3rd PlanIt works more like a familiar Windows program as compared with CADRail and XTrackCAD, whose user interfaces are more like a traditional CAD program (click-move-click). That was an easier learning path for me. Like 3rd PlanIt, AnyRail also feels to me a little more like a Windows program than the others.
Personally, I prefer a commercial product with support offered by the developer. Others have had good results with open-source offerings.
For any of these programs, the learning curve will be steep. For a single layout just for yourself, the time investment to learn the program may not be worth it compared to careful to-scale hand-drawing with accurate templates of the turnouts you plan to use.
Good luck with your layout.
Byron
Layout Design GalleryLayout Design Special Interest Group
gary233Which have you used? Which do you like best? Why? Which is truly easiest to use and creates the most accurate plan that you can transfer to construction?
Back in 2011 I used XTrackCAD. I decided to try something free first and just stuck with it, using it for a year or so before deciding to build. It has some learning curve, so use the tutorial to try it out. I got used to it and how to combine using the brand name (template) track pieces with custom drawn curves, etc. I would use it again.
I can't compare to others as I did not try others. Someone here will be able to do that.
Some older threads via a google search:
https://www.google.com/search?safe=active&rlz=1C1CHBF_enUS759US759&ei=kV27W7rWK4LIsAXB6q3IDQ&q=site%3A+cs.trains.com+track+plan+software&oq=site%3A+cs.trains.com+track+plan+software&gs_l=psy-ab.3...27218.29832..31770...0.0..0.87.414.5......0....1..gws-wiz.......0i71.9Mto6c4o4cU
Paul
Modeling HO with a transition era UP bent
I used RR-Track to lay out my N scale. Cost varies depending on package you purchase. It has some flaws but it worked well for me. I tried some of the freeby versions available and none worked well for me. I have seen many comments by others that say they like other packages but I have no experience with them.
I should note that my layout was done with Kato Unitrack. If you are using flex track, I suspect that there are other packages out there that will do a better job.
Paul D
N scale Washita and Santa Fe RailroadSouthern Oklahoma circa late 70's
Hi,
After 30+ years I’m tearing down my model railroad. I bought a new home with a space for a new model railroad. 30 years ago I designed the layout with pencil and paper. Today, there are several products available that will do a better job. EACH says they are easy to use and have pretty much the same features.
Which have you used? Which do you like best? Why? Which is truly easiest to use and creates the most accurate plan that you can transfer to construction?