Trains.com

Need Help Lionel CW-80 not compatible with MTH?

9494 views
8 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Need Help Lionel CW-80 not compatible with MTH?
Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 8:24 AM

Purchased a lionel CW 80 watt.My mth K4 won't run right.

The bell stay's on or whistle stay's on.Can't activate station sound's.

Is there any help out there? (i did reverse wire's)

  • Member since
    December 2005
  • From: Hopewell, NY
  • 3,233 posts
Posted by ADCX Rob on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 8:31 AM

Compatibility might be a secondary issue at this point.

Based on your description, it seem your CW might have one of the buttons, whistle or bell, stuck.

Do they both "click" like the direction button when you press them?  If not, you have a defective CW.  When you can verify that this is or is not the problem, then you can move on to compatability issues.

Rob 

Rob

  • Member since
    December 2004
  • From: Southwest of Houston. TX
  • 1,082 posts
Posted by jimhaleyscomet on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 9:06 AM

Spongebob,

If you just put a small amount of power to the track does the horn or bell continously blow.  On my "pre-fix" old ZW's I can run MTH PS2.0 engines but only if I run them slow.  Above a certain voltage it triggers the horn continously.  I don't think your button is stuck.  My K-line trasformer also blows my MTH horn continously.

Jim H 

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 9:15 AM

My William's F7 runs fine Trueblast horn & Bell work great.So i know button's function are good.

                           Tks

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 10:05 AM
 jimhaleyscomet wrote:

Spongebob,

If you just put a small amount of power to the track does the horn or bell continously blow.  On my "pre-fix" old ZW's I can run MTH PS2.0 engines but only if I run them slow.  Above a certain voltage it triggers the horn continously.  I don't think your button is stuck.  My K-line trasformer also blows my MTH horn continously.

Jim H 



Interesting... I have a Modern ZW that fires the whistle on my 6026W tender when above 12V... the KW does not... Can run my Williams Baldwin Sharks on the KW with no problems, but when used with the Modern ZW they cause it to short (3 powered units)... sent email to Lionel... got some cryptic response:

There may be a compatibility issue with the older electronics and the
new ZW.

If your set is drawing too much current, the new ZW will trip at 10
amps. It is a more sensitive device than the KW.

Now, they claim the new ZW can be used to power units in conventional mode... so why would they sell a product that incompatible with their own products?

I'm seriously considering selling the ZW and getting a Z4000... seems MTH can build things that are compatible with ALL manufacturers products... Banged Head [banghead]

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • From: Plymouth, MI
  • 1,615 posts
Posted by chuck on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 11:22 AM

Is the K-4 a PS-1 or PS-2 locomotive.  If it's a PS-1, it may not be able to run with modified sine wave transformers like the CW-80.  When QSI designed their original sound/control boards, they were based on PW variable tap transformers that put put near pure sine waves, not modern electronic units with modified wave forms that allow other "tricks" .  The modern "transfomer" units use modified output waveforms that interferes with the trigger circuits for electronic whistle/horn/bell "relays".  When QSI found out about the issues they began to modify their boards.  MTH chose to have the sound system cut out on later model PS-1 boards when they detected a modified wave form.  Other later generation QSI products have no problems with the modern power supplies (circuits were modified to accomodate non sine wave power).

Re 10 amp limit on the breakers.  All "Toy" train amps are limited by the UL/CPSC to a maximum of 10 amps per output channel.  If it's over 10 amps it's not considered a toy train transformer.  Even the Z-4000 is limited in this fashion.  The TPC's can handle 15 and 20 amps but they are not considered "toy" transformers.   All of the modern equipment is protected by fast acting breakers.  This is done in part to protect the much more delicate electronics found in todays toy trains.  The older PW transformers all relied on thermal breakers.  These were capable of handling transients in excess of their rated output, aka a consist that might pull 10.2 amps at start up but then operated below this once the train was moving.  The newer equipment can't/won't do this.

If you really need 10 amps for a consist, you need a power supply that exceedes 10 amps to run it well/properly.  I would try to give myself a 20% cushion.  Running at the edge is just begging for trouble.

When everything else fails, play dead
  • Member since
    November 2007
  • 13 posts
Posted by Spence on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 1:13 PM
Some CW-80 transformers do not play nice with PS-2 engines.  I had to replace mine with an MTH transformer.
  • Member since
    December 2001
  • From: Upstate New York
  • 899 posts
Posted by nblum on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 3:37 PM

The assumption that MTH transformers work well with other manufacturers equipment and Lionel's do not is incorrect.  There are instances where TMCC locos do not operate properly with the Z4000 and work just fine with the CW-80.  In general, each manufacturer's locos operate best with their own transformers because that's what they're tested with.  An example of what I'm referring to is the following comment from elsewhere:

 


 
  
I just brought one of my 3rd rail locos to a friends house to run it with his Z4000. I was unable to get the engine to go forward. Turned power on and got ding ding, and then turned off and on again to go forward and the engine was in the programing mode and each time I turned power off I would get a different set of dings.
It appears the unit does not shut down to 0 volts to allow the qsi system to go in forward.
Is there a fix for this outside of getting a old lionel transformer. We tried an old kw he had and it worked fine. Needless to say he was ?????? at the z 4000 and was going to take it back to his lhs

 

Neil (not Besougloff or Young) :)
  • Member since
    July 2005
  • From: Northeast Missouri
  • 869 posts
Posted by SchemerBob on Tuesday, November 27, 2007 4:22 PM
 spongebob wrote:

Purchased a lionel CW 80 watt.My mth K4 won't run right.

The bell stay's on or whistle stay's on.Can't activate station sound's.

Is there any help out there? (i did reverse wire's)

Yes, there is help spongebob. If this is a locomotive with Proto-Sound 2.0, then I've been in the same boat before. Last year I bought an MTH SW1500 with PS2. It operated fine on one of my older Lionel 80 watts, but when I tried to operate it on my CW-80, the horn would blast continuously and never stop. Apparently, the CW-80 does not run MTH Proto-Sound 2.0 locomotives very well. I think the horn blasting problem can be fixed by putting a lighted car (like a caboose or passenger car or something) on the same track. If that doesn't work, though, I would recommend you use a different transformer. Along with the whistle/horn sound issue, the buttons on the CW-80's are more sensitive to the pushes than other transformers, so there isn't any way you can activate the featurs of the locomotive that you need a whistle/bell button sequence for (like front & rear couplers, station sounds, factory reset, etc.).

Another note -- if you have Lionel's TrainMaster Command Control, and you have it all hooked up to operate both command and non-command engines (with a TPC), then the MTH PS2 locomotives operate fine with the CW-80, as I am doing right now. You can activate the couplers with the coupler buttons on the remote, and you can activate the station sounds by pressing AUX1 and then the buttons on the numerical keypad for "fast horn" and "fast bell".

If you don't have TMCC, then I would suggest you use a different transformer, preferably an MTH kind.

Long live the BNSF .... AND its paint scheme. SchemerBob

Join our Community!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

Search the Community

FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Get the Classic Toy Trains newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month