This post is about a subject that I read about several years.
I have read that railroads in the south used "colored" (black) fireman, but those fireman could not be promoted to engineers, even though some where better engineers than the white ones.
I hope I have not offended anyone by this post as history is not always kind.
Ed Burns
Happily retired NP-BN-BNSF from Minneapolis. Yes, I was there as of M-Day in 1970.
In his writings Lucius Beebe mentioned seeing mixed and freight trains in the South with all-black crews, however these were on obscure short lines, not what we'd call the Class Ones.
For that matter I doubt you'd have seen black engineers on the Class Ones up North in the old days either, athough I could be very wrong on that.
And NP Eddie, I wouldn't worry about offending anyone, especially if you haven't set out to do so. The past is what it was, and history is what it is, and all we can do is learn from it and try not to repeat the mistakes.
And I remember the first time as a youngster riding a sleeper in Canada on CP or CN and finding it was attended by a white porter.!
After my folks moved from Texas to Florida in 1959 my hangout became Tampa Union Station. Both the Atlantic Coast Line and Seaboard Air Line employed black firemen. One fine black man worked the Tampa-Port Tampa phosphate drags. After the two railroads merged to become Seaboard Coast Line he was promoted to engineer. My best friend had gone to work for Agrico Chemical Co. and had a warm reunion with him when he brought a train into the Agrico yard. one night in the 80s.
While I was employed on the Santa Fe in Dallas in the 70s I worked with a black engineer from NY City. He could kick cars better than many of the veteran white boys could! We worked together and were a great ebony and ivory team! I retain many fond memories of those days.
As beautifully written as the Constitution of the United States is, the Freedom and Justice for All was written by slave owners. It took a Civil War to undo some of the wrong and sadly problems still exist in the 21st Century despite the Dream of the great Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. in the 60s.
A Mexican locomotive engineer saved an entire town from total distruction by taking a train loaded with TNT out of the town and paid with his life. Mexico celebrates Railroad Days in his honor each year. Native Americans and Chinese have also contributed to the history of railroads in America as well.
A Classic Trains special honoring all of these men and women is long overdue!
NY City did not hire blacks for subway service until at least the 70's. I know of at least one black man (who told me there were others) who wanted to run for them but was denied thus moved away from the city so he..and they..could get jobs in railroading. They did so and are great railroaders today.
RIDEWITHMEHENRY is the name for our almost monthly day of riding trains and transit in either the NYCity or Philadelphia areas including all commuter lines, Amtrak, subways, light rail and trolleys, bus and ferries when warranted. No fees, just let us know you want to join the ride and pay your fares. Ask to be on our email list or find us on FB as RIDEWITHMEHENRY (all caps) to get descriptions of each outing.
I've come across several references over the years of that being the case for many years in the South, that blacks could become fireman but never be promoted to engineer - much the same way blacks could be Pullman porters but not Pullman conductors, or be dining car waiters but not chief stewards. I don't know if it was much better in the North, but it probably wasn't as firmly set a policy as it was in the South.
Actually discrimination was often more rampant in the north than it was in the south and I think the Unions (BLE&F and BRT) had a hand in this situation. I can speak for the Illinois Central in the early 1950's. The IC had black firemen and brakemen but no engineers or conductors on its southern divisions at that time. However up north on the Illinois and Iowa Divisions there was not a single black train or engine crewmen (engineers, firemen, conductors, brakemen and flagmen). Also motormen, conductors, brakemen and flagmen in the electrified Chicago commuter service were all whites. I am pretty sure the Unions extracted an unwritten agreement with the IC to keep it that way. I'd be interested to hear what others know about the situation on other roads in the north.
Mark
About a year ago I watched a documentary on Philadelphia during World War Two. Seems the Philly streetcar system wanted to hire black men to replace the white motormen who'd gone to war. The motormans union was dead set against it and called a strike, shutting the system down. As the streetcars were essential to getting workers to the various war production sites in the area the Army was called in and soldiers ran the cars. A pretty ugly story.
You know, the South gets slammed a lot for discrimination and bigotry, but the folks up North weren't exactly blameless either. I remember a great Bill Mauldin political cartoon from the 60's showing a "Bull Connor" German shepard dog with some shredded clothing hanging out of his mouth talking with a French poodle. The poodle says, "Well, up North we just nibble 'em to death."
KCSfan Actually discrimination was often more rampant in the north than it was in the south and I think the Unions (BLE&F and BRT) had a hand in this situation. I can speak for the Illinois Central in the early 1950's. The IC had black firemen and brakemen but no engineers or conductors on its southern divisions at that time. However up north on the Illinois and Iowa Divisions there was not a single black train or engine crewmen (engineers, firemen, conductors, brakemen and flagmen). Also motormen, conductors, brakemen and flagmen in the electrified Chicago commuter service were all whites. I am pretty sure the Unions extracted an unwritten agreement with the IC to keep it that way. I'd be interested to hear what others know about the situation on other roads in the north. Mark
I have a 1929 Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen/CRI&P "Rules and Rates of Pay" book. There is in one section, I think dealing with applications to take exams for promotion to Conductor, where it says something like, "preference will be given to the senior white trainmen making application."
Jeff
I don't think I'd go so far as to say discrimination was MORE rampant in the North than the South, but in some ways the 'cultural discrimination' may have just as bad. In the North it was more cultural, in the South it was often enforced by statute and regulation. For example, the 1950's-60's desegregation of public schools in the South, and all the fighting that created, seemed very odd to my parents, both of whom had grown up in Minneapolis going to school with black kids in the 1920's and '30's.
Perhaps ironic is a better term, in view of the north prevailing over the south in a war about slavery and bigotry. It is the same up here in the hallowed halls of Canada. Bigotry is every bit as rampant and well-established as it is in any culture, nation, or population. People of most any persuasion, education, socio-economic status, skill set, moral philosophy, gender identity, and sexual proclivity harbour resentment and bias. It shows in their actions if not their words.
Crandell
wjstix I don't think I'd go so far as to say discrimination was MORE rampant in the North than the South, but in some ways the 'cultural discrimination' may have just as bad. In the North it was more cultural, in the South it was often enforced by statute and regulation. For example, the 1950's-60's desegregation of public schools in the South, and all the fighting that created, seemed very odd to my parents, both of whom had grown up in Minneapolis going to school with black kids in the 1920's and '30's.
'Actually discrimination was often more rampant in the north than it was in the south." You'll notice that I used the word "often". Yes there was de jure segregation in the south but de facto segregation existed in lots of places in the north. It was more prevalent in cities which had seen a large influx of blacks in the 30's and 40's , e.g. Chicago and Detroit. Blacks were viewed as competetiors for jobs and whites fled the inner cities for the suburbs as more and more blacks moved in. I lived the first 16 years of my life in an all white suburb of Chicago. Any blacks who happened to drive through after dark would be stopped by the police and escorted out of town. Needless to say no realtor would show a house to a black potential buyer or renter in that town. Unless you lived through them things like that are hard to believe today when we have come to respect an individual's civil rights.
Well that's true, I've heard blacks who came north in years back say they preferred the south because at least there were signs there saying "white only" etc. so they knew where they weren't welcome. In the north, they often had to find out 'the hard way'.
One thought about the original post...as unfair as it was that blacks could only be firemen and not engineers, or Pullman porters but not conductors etc., it's inspiring to note that these men were able to use these jobs to carve out a better future for themselves and their families. From what I've read, there was a generation of black writers, teachers, etc. whose fathers or grandfathers did hard work on the railroad to enable them to get a good education in a stable family environment.
wjstix One thought about the original post...as unfair as it was that blacks could only be firemen and not engineers, or Pullman porters but not conductors etc., it's inspiring to note that these men were able to use these jobs to carve out a better future for themselves and their families. From what I've read, there was a generation of black writers, teachers, etc. whose fathers or grandfathers did hard work on the railroad to enable them to get a good education in a stable family environment.
Absolutely right. Despite the limited upward mobility, Pullman porter, brakeman and fireman were considered to be prestigious occupations for blacks. In the south those who held these jobs were respected members of what was, at the time, a fairly small black "middle class".
One more comment about the de facto situation in the north. From 1945-'59 (with time out for the Korean War) I commuted daily into Chicago on the Illinois Central, from 1959-'62 on the Burlington and from 1962-'65 on the Erie-Lackawanna in New Jersey. On the commuter trains of these three roads I never once saw a black trainman. In light of Jeff's comment about the 1929 BRT/CRI&P agreement, I'll bet there were few if any black conductors on the Rock Island. I imagine the actual words disappered sometime from later union agreements but the unwritten practice continued on for many more years on a majority of railroads in the north. To the best of my recollection the limits for upward mobility of blacks in train service continued until the late 1960's or early '70's.
What I find kind of interesting is what broke the logjam. L&N should be remembered for having the 1st Black locomotive engineer.
What broke the camels back was the locomotive firemans union in the 1960's trying to have a situation were only "promotable" fireman would have job protection as locomotive fireman. The court case that arose out of the situation essentially gutted any de jure discrimination. As there were many blacks who were already hostling locomotives and who had been rules qualified it was not a big leap to the right seat of a train.(I think this was 1964 or so)(this was from an article I saw in Trains in the 1970's)
Then reading the article by Michael Gross about his stint as a locomotive fireman on C&NW. The impression I was left with was that particular union was not being given any respect. I guess eventually the Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen ceased to exist either by merger or loss of membership.
Thx IGN
Firemen as an occupation were on life-support from the late 50's when a Canadian 'Road declared them unnecessary on yard and frt diesel and electric locomotives. Featherbedders....they were us.
In most of SP-land, state's had full-crew laws, so frmn were hired (good for me.) And we joined the Bof LF & E---nginemen.
The law in Ca. was voted out by a Proposition in '64 during my 2 yrs of olive-drab. RR unions, seeing a whole membership eradicated (should I have said the national negotiations to kill the firemens' job went to Federal Arbitration which worked against labor and for corperate groups) went toward circling the wagons, for defense, of course.
The consolidation included the brakeman---BRT, the swicthmen (yard)---SUNA, B of LF & E-- -firemen (those still around) conducters----ORC.....and for yardmasters, dispatchers, and clerks. As loyal a B of LF & E member as I could be, I became a UTU (United Transportation Union) member which mimicked the B of LF & E similar to before my Viet war experience.
B of LF & E, the brain and heart of it lived in the new UTU, few brain-blasters and weak blood blood venues problems ensued, but the consolidation to me seemed to be valid.
Not given respect....
ceased to exist...merger or loss of membership
I don't want to have this guy tell my future.
I believe the article was in the August 1973 Trains magazine,
Tom
NP Eddie This post is about a subject that I read about several years. I have read that railroads in the south used "colored" (black) fireman, but those fireman could not be promoted to engineers, even though some where better engineers than the white ones. I hope I have not offended anyone by this post as history is not always kind. Ed Burns Happily retired NP-BN-BNSF from Minneapolis. Yes, I was there as of M-Day in 1970.
IINM, wasn't Casey Jones' regular Firemen on the Illinois Central African American?
"I Often Dream of Trains"-From the Album of the Same Name by Robyn Hitchcock
Sim T. Webb (yes - African American) was Casey Jones fireman that fateful night at Vaughan, Mississippi
The IC Engineer Casey Jones and his African American Fireman, Sim comes to mind...
Nothing is more fairly distributed than common sense: no one thinks he needs more of it than he already has.
If you are interested in a good treatment of the subject you might want to check out
Railroads in the African American Experience: A Photographic Pourney - Kornweibel
The title is misleading - it is a coffee table sized book and it does have photographs but it is, first and foremost, written history
Brother....the worst that could had happened when the rail operating brotherhoods merged as you said (BRT, ORC, SUNA, BLE & F) into the UTU. I've been a UTU member for nearly 40 years and I still shake my head at some the mind bogleing stands the UTU took over the years. A classic is the one in Texas in the early 80's when a black (UTU member) trainman sued the ATSF, the BLE and the UTU account he was denied promotion to engineer....account of need (the ATSF said!) of trainmen/conductors in his seniority district (I believe it was in New Mexico). But white trainmen were promoted in his district!!!
It all came down to the courthouse steps in Cleveland (where the BLE and UTU were headquarted at this time)...the ATSF had already settled, the BLE litterly on the courthouse steps...but the UTU? Oh no "we will fight the lawsuit" (he was asking for 25 million!). The UTU goes to court and of course LOSES---Big Time (not quite the 25 mill, but in the millions)...and the members of the UTU??? We got a dues HIKE for two years!
The BLE & F (Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen (which included Engineers/Locomotive Firemen and "firemen" in stationary positions: stations/yards/engine houses to stoke boilers to supply heat/lights/etc...my grandfather was a stationary fireman in the old Albany Depot)) was absorbed into the United Transportation Union (along with the ORC, BRT, SUNA and Yardmasters) in 1969. Craft autonomy was maintained in the UTU, with engine crews denoted by UTU-E and Conductors/Trainmen/Yardmasters denoted by just UTU. An aside, this was told to me by old timers I worked with in the early 70's: The BLE&F knew that the Firemen jobs were going to gone in a few years (the late 50's), they tried to backdoor the BRT, by telling the RR's that they would throw any switches that the head end brakeman had to throw in the yards/manilines to keep the firemen and do away with the head brakman!
Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!
Get the Classic Trains twice-monthly newsletter