I like the P42s'. After hearing that all the way to Denver CO. I’ve learned to love it!
Which ones do you all like?
The road to to success is always under construction. _____________________________________________________________________________ When the going gets tough, the tough use duct tape.
The Nathan M5, with five tuned horns, was expensive to buy and trouble to maintain right, but sounded beautiful when it was tuned properly--absolutely haunting.
The best sounding horn was the Nathan M5.I have heard them on SPs Train Masters.It had an AWESOME sound.
I like the horns on the new GE's ( dont like the GE's lol but the horns are nice)I also like what we have on our SD 40's at the ICE, and the ones we had on old BN units on the BNSF.
Yes we are on time but this is yesterdays train
Thanks for the input all!
bubbajustinI like the P42s'
I believe those would be Nathan K5LAs.
I like the K5LAs on NJT, specifically those on the PL42ACs and Multilevels. When the NIMBYs complained about them being too loud, NJT's MMC restricted them (just asking for trouble). The PL42s and MLs, however, were factory restricted, so they do not sound retarted. Some of them were so screwed up by the MMC, that you can barely hear them. Fortunately, a few have not been restricted, so they are still loud and in tune, such as those on the PL42s and MLs (which are restricted, but still sound fine).
4112 has a Nathan P01235, which was originally on a E60CH. 4112's K5LA was destroyed after hitting the catenary in Summit, so it was replaced with a leftover P01235. This thing sounds pretty cool, and is either unrestricted, or restricted the proper way, so that it actually sounds NORMAL.
My Model Railroad: Tri State RailMy Photos on Flickr: FlickrMy Videos on Youtube: YoutubeMy Photos on RRPA: RR Picture Archives
ns3010 bubbajustinI like the P42s' I believe those would be Nathan K5LAs. I like the K5LAs on NJT, specifically those on the PL42ACs and Multilevels. When the NIMBYs complained about them being too loud, NJT's MMC restricted them (just asking for trouble). The PL42s and MLs, however, were factory restricted, so they do not sound retarted. Some of them were so screwed up by the MMC, that you can barely hear them. Fortunately, a few have not been restricted, so they are still loud and in tune, such as those on the PL42s and MLs (which are restricted, but still sound fine). 4112 has a Nathan P01235, which was originally on a E60CH. 4112's K5LA was destroyed after hitting the catenary in Summit, so it was replaced with a leftover P01235. This thing sounds pretty cool, and is either unrestricted, or restricted the proper way, so that it actually sounds NORMAL.
Awesome! Thanks for the info!
The Nathan M5's and the Nathan P5's.
The M5's were throaty, loud and as the Nathan ad once stated "Strident without being offensive".
The Nathan P5 is the fabled "Swedish Chime" (whatever that was) as noted on the Mobile Fidelity CD "Mr. D's Machine". This disc has possibly the finest recording of a Nathan P5 ever made, and was recorded on a cold night many winters ago in the hills above Chatsworth, CA as the speeding westbound Lark approached from Northridge, where the engineer's excellent whistling is first heard, all the way up into Santa Susana Pass.
Amtrak equipped a couple of F40's with P5's, and we always had fun with them on the San Joaquins.
I have always appreciated the sounds of railroad whistles, horns and bells..Steam sounds were haunting and diesel sounds were unique to each railroad..Specifically, the Canadian Nationals Air Horns were special, and you knew it was a CN unit without looking
But FAST FORWARD TO TODAY... Living just of the Transcon (MP227.01), and with six crossings within slightly more than a mile..The sounds of diesels become more of the individual engineer's technique...Some folks can dance an sing and some have a tin ear, and no sense of the racket they can create( in spite of what the 'Rules' are. In particular, in the pre dawn hours, and don't let them meet. Sometimes a flock of geese can not HONK that much.
ndbprr The one on #4449. Not because of the horn but because of what it is on!
The one on #4449. Not because of the horn but because of what it is on!
Ha! Yah! Amen to that!
Thanks all for sharing. I've hered a "sick" horn before...
It needs a plain old Blaat horn.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O08jyhPcKFc
Personally, I only love women.
bubbajustin Which ones do you all like?
Anything but those god awful horns on the SD70M-2/ACe
A Nathan P5 on top of a trio of SD40-2s, one of the best sounds in the world.....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2eptqTii74s&NR=1
True Railfan!!!!!!
I wonder if this is the same guy, who back in the early 1960's had a set of air horns mounted on his pick-up truck, they were supplied by an air resovoir mounted in the bed. It was the first time I ever saw one of these so equiped vehicles.
He would pull up to some of the crossings areund Durango and blow it for the D&S passengers riding by behind one of their steamers. Quite a suprise for one of the unsuspecting tourists on the train.
Same type of deal down in the Alabama Coal fields; around Jasper and Birmingham, and North Alabama areas. During the 70's/80's the Dump Truck drivers would mount the horns on their Coal Trucks..Litterly, would scare the you know what out of motorists not paying attention.. At one time I think the HWY Patrol would give the offending truckers a tickety and stern talking to, as well.
Have only seen a few such horns mounted on OTR trucks. Seems some cops trake a pretty dim view of this type of scare activity. So the owners seem to be pretty judicious in the use of their RR Diesel Horns.
Here's some good old Chessie GP40-2s on a Circus Train:
Chessie GP40-2s
Here's a more recent pair of CSX AC4400s screaming by with 130 loaded coal cars:
Fast CSX AC4400s
Here's somebody who mounted a Chessie K5LA on his Ford truck!
Ford Truck with Chessie K5LA
Hancock 4700 Air Whistle
http://www.dieselairhorns.com/collection.html
This link has sounds of many airhorns:
http://atsf.railfan.net/airhorns/index.html
C&NW, CA&E, MILW, CGW and IC fan
I believe that there was an incident in past months with BNSF having an air horn stolen from a few locomotives. What a nut, but I bet he had the coolest horn in town!!!
How a R.R. determine what type of horn to install on their locomotive? Do we have a standard horn for locomotives? Its by the size or tonnage?
air horns (whistles) are generally an "option" which is modified from a builder standard based upon the customer's requirement or specification. Some railroads, such as Chessie System, actually went with the Nathan Co. and tested various musical notes and types of whistles on locomotives someplace out in Maryland or Pennsylavania, if I remember. This is how the K5LA came about, as Chessie wanted something, according to reports, that sounded more like a steam whistle, notre-wise, than the equipment then currently available.
I would have to say the 'old tuned' K5HL, which uses the 1, 1L, 2, 3, & 4A bells:
bubbajustin I believe that there was an incident in past months with BNSF having an air horn stolen from a few locomotives. What a nut, but I bet he had the coolest horn in town!!!
Norfolk Southern had that happen in Springfield, IL, at one point. Someone knicked a few horns off of the locomotives. "Best" part is, I got suspected at one point in that. Got a call from the NS Police Department, too.
Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.