All this talk of the exM&StL Mashalltown, Iowa shops (from 2009 no less) misses one point. Part of the reason the shops lasted as long as they did, whether engine or car shop, was there was a clause in the original deeding of the land to the railroad. It was that a shop complex had to be maintained there or the land would revert to the city. I'd have to look for sure, but I think there was a time period involved like 100 years.
Anyway, once the CNW had taken over the M&StL they tried closing the shops. When the city found out, they said fine, we'll take the land back. The shops remained open.
I think today, (2020) that EMD was using them for warranty work. They were a few years ago, but I haven't been over that way for a few years.
Jeff
Thank you for mentioning the shops at Hudson (North Hudson), Wisconsin. I am please to have learned that the closure of the Hudson, WI., shops was in the late 1960's. I spoke with a fella whose father worked at the Hudson CNW shops in the 1960's and he said his dad was transferred to Iowa. I have visited the old shops several times and it looks like it has been many years since they were operated by the RR. A short section of the old spur leading from the main line to the old shops still exists. It is located just east of the St. Croix RR bridge as it crosses into WI., from MN. It was a considerable distance from the main line north to the shops and the tracks crossed a low lying bridge to access the Hudson facility. That low bridge is still in place, but the tracks, other than the short section of spur, are long gone. UP stil has a small building in operation, near the old shops. I think it is used for the bridge and building crew. Does anyone have any photos of the Hudson shops when they were in operation? Thanks for all your instructive comments. Mark Boy
Dan- North Fond Du Lac shops were an original Wisconsin Central- later Soo Line (and "new" WC as well) shop complex. The CNW did have a full roundhouse at their North Fond Du Lac facilities that handled locomotives assigned to the Lake Shore Division which was adjacent to the Soo shops and yard.
I know on the CNW the variety of shops around the system was a result of the mergers and takeovers of other railroads over time (Winona shops were the Winona and St. Peter shops, Hudson was the CMO shops, etc.).
Was it common to have repair shops along most subs of varying capability? Where did a place like Shops Yard (North Fond du Lac, WI) fit into the maintenance equation? I know that a lot of car work used to go on there, but what of motive power?
Dan
billioSomeone asked why the Oelwein shops were closed. After UP acquired CNW back in 1995, it decided to concentrate system locomotive heavy maintenance at North Little Rock, AR (edit -- ex-MoP). UP's North Little Rock Shop was newer and more modern, and Oelwein duplicated what it did, needlessly, and at greater expense, in the minds of CNW management. So Oelwein got the axe. Such a facilities consolidation is common in railway mergers.
This is incorrect- the Chicago and North Western announced the closing of Oelwein in 1993 and officially closed the doors at the shops on May 13, 1994- one full year before the UP takeover. (Even though UP was in the process of buying a controlling interest in CNW- they did not play into the equation.) Employees were offered positions at Proviso, Clinton, and Marshalltown upon the announced closing. Hospital trains of derelict and junk locomotives began ferrying out of Oelwein in the summer of 1993 and were complete by closing time in May 1994. The reasons for closing the shop were two-fold- one, the shops were located at the end of one of CNW's "Island" lines from Waterloo. All cars and locomotives bound for Oelwein had to be intermediately handled by the Iowa Northern between Cedar Rapids and Waterloo for CNW interchange. Two- the CNW was no longer doing any heavy rebuilds on it's locomotive fleet, and the remaining repair work could be covered by the existing shops at Proviso and Marshalltown.
As for the Marshalltown shops- they were built by the MSTL in 1950 as a diesel shop. In 1956 the work done there was transferred to Cedar Lake and Marshalltown became a car shop until the CNW merger when they converted it back to a diesel shop.
In 1984 the ex-CGW mainline from the Twin Cities to Oelwein Iowa was abandoned primarily because of C&NW"s aquiring the Rock Island spine line between the Twin Cities and Kansas City. The Rock Island trackage was much better engineered than the CGW and in better shape physically. This also meant that the ex M&StL line between Cedar Lake and Marshalltown Iowa was also redundant and was downgraded in 1980 and now mostly abandoned. The C&NW did keep the line from Oelwein to Waterloo for a few years to access the Oelwein shops. About the only CGW line open today is the line so that UP can access Clarion Iowa.
In the 1970's both the ex-CGW and M&StL mainlines were a wonderful place to watch trains. It was a hotbed of F units.
Carl
Railroader Emeritus (practiced railroading for 46 years--and in 2010 I finally got it right!)
CAACSCOCOM--I don't want to behave improperly, so I just won't behave at all. (SM)
CShaveRRFreight car rebuilding and major repairs were done at Clinton, Iowa, from the 1960s right up until UP shut the shops down. Passenger car work was done at California Avenue in Chicago--still is, for Metra's UP operations.
Thanks Carl! I assumed it was.
The road to to success is always under construction. _____________________________________________________________________________ When the going gets tough, the tough use duct tape.
The Chicago area had the big C&NW shops. Marshalltown was a M&StL shop complex that was upgraded by the C&NW after the 1960 buyout of the M&StL. The 1968 buyout of the CGW gained the C&NW the very large Oelwein shops.
IIRC, the M19A shop in Chicago is the only engine shop left on the former C&NW lines.
Jim
Modeling BNSF and Milwaukee Road in SW Wisconsin
Last time I was in Oelwein, the yard looked almost like the CGW had been reincarnated. Transco had many, many cars, mostly auto-racks but various other types too parked in the yard for repair. Business certainly seemed good.
bubbajustin zardoz Oelwein, Iowa Yep. I imagne that there major passenger car repair facility was in Chicago right?
zardoz Oelwein, Iowa
Oelwein, Iowa
Yep.
I imagne that there major passenger car repair facility was in Chicago right?
Yep. At 40th Street. Also, CNW passenger locomotive maintenance was at M19A in Chicago.
Someone asked why the Oelwein shops were closed. After UP acquired CNW back in 1995, it decided to concentrate system locomotive heavy maintenance at North Little Rock, AR (edit -- ex-MoP). UP's North Little Rock Shop was newer and more modern, and Oelwein duplicated what it did, needlessly, and at greater expense, in the minds of CNW management. So Oelwein got the axe. Such a facilities consolidation is common in railway mergers.
Anybody know the reasoning behind closing the Oelwein shops?
Huron is still active as a DM&E shop, complete with operating turntable. If the PRB project goes through a new yard and I presume shops will be built west of town.
Reality TV is to reality, what Professional Wrestling is to Professional Brain Surgery.
This is in a way sort of a loaded question- CNW's mergers did in fact make many changes to the CNW's shopping locations, but I'll take a stab at keeping it relatively simple.
For the most part prior to the CGW takeover- heavy locomotive repairs were done at the 40th street shops- there are excellent photos in the Flickr commons you can see taken in during World War II of the repair facilities that were once there. There were other immediate repair facilities as well (Chadron, NE was the Western Division repair facility, Huron, SD handled the Dakota Division, etc.)- when the CNW merged the MSTL they acquired the Marshalltown and Cedar Lake shops for locomotive repair, and the Oskaloosa shops for freight cars. Cedar Lake was like Oelwein in size and capacity, while Marshalltown was smaller.
Speaking freight cars the CNW had quite a few major shops that handled major car repairs before they were consolidated at Clinton in the late 1960s. These included Cudahy, WI, Hudson, WI, Winona, MN and the 40th Street shops in Chicago. The NWX shops for the refrigerator car fleet was in Baraboo, Wisconsin. After the CGW merger, Oelwein was incorporated as the main heavy repair facility and Cedar Lake and 40th Street were phased out (40th having passed on to RTA Metra). Clinton became the main car repair shop although Cudahy continued to do contract work on coal hoppers and the CNW's autorack fleet until the merger. I will have to look and see where the main heavy repair work transferred to when Oelwein closed.
Marshalltown was a mid-size repair shop (which in fact had been MSTL predecessor Iowa Central's main shop complex), comparable to the work that Chadron and Huron did- late in the CNW era it was make one of two contract shops on the CNW that handled maintenance work on the GE fleet (the other being Council Bluffs, IA). Having toured both Oelwein and Marshalltown when they were still active shops, I can tell you that Marshalltown was nowhere near equipped to do the work that Oelwein could. Hopefully that helps a little more to answer the question.
clarkfork I always thought C&NW had its major locomotive backshops in Chicago.
I always thought C&NW had its major locomotive backshops in Chicago.
I'm not sure where it was done pre-CGW merger.
WIARclarkfork I always thought C&NW had its major locomotive backshops in Chicago. Not sure about pre-1968 as I mentioned in my reply, but Zardoz and the other poster are correct in that after the CGW merger CNW used the massive Oelwein shops for a lot of their repair work.
Not sure about pre-1968 as I mentioned in my reply, but Zardoz and the other poster are correct in that after the CGW merger CNW used the massive Oelwein shops for a lot of their repair work.
Before the Oelwein shops were acquired in the merger with CGW and after the Oelwein shops were sold, the C&NW did most of its major locomotive maintenance at Marshalltown, IA.
After the 1968 merger/takeover of the Chicago Great Western, that is (Oelwein was CGW's big hub). Prior to 1968, wasn't Clinton, IA a major engine and car repair facility?
curtissjoyce Where did the CNW have their major repair and construction shops like the Milwaukee Road's West Milwaukee shops?
Where did the CNW have their major repair and construction shops like the Milwaukee Road's West Milwaukee shops?
IINM, C&NW's major backshop was in Oelwein, Iowa..
"I Often Dream of Trains"-From the Album of the Same Name by Robyn Hitchcock
Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.