PC101, Thank you for the update and report on painting GT testing! I tried your technique with cleaning, scuffing the surface, and then painting. The Testors paints have worked very well for me. As you stated, using white as a basecoat then red or green is more visible than painting a single color. I did try painting a white base coat followed by a green or red dot. IMO, that is very visible and clearly highlights color. However, I was not very happy with my painting since difficult to make a realistic circle on top of the basecoat. I'll go with your white base cost then solid green or red on my GT's.
I do want to recognize JoeinPa for his excellent advice and encouragement to use Testors paint. Thank you!
I do find it interesting that some have been able to make craft paint stick to the GT's. I tried two different companies (Craft Smart and Folkart), scuffed versus not, and applying Vallejo surface primer or not. All failed. My paint was brand new and mixed thoroughly before applying to a washed/air-dried GT handle. By all means, give craft paint a try and please let us know your secret if you can make it stick! I now have a lifetime supply of Testors paint for the ground throws so my course is set.
dehusman I used craft paints when I used Caboose throws and it lasted years.
I used craft paints when I used Caboose throws and it lasted years.
I too have simply painted the handle with a bit of red, yellow, or green (as appropriate) craft paint and it's held up fine so far and that was a number of years ago.
Chris van der Heide
My Algoma Central Railway Modeling Blog
IDRick Looks good PC101, thanks for posting! Did you decide to not use a white background as on your previous GT's or am I attributing someone else's work to you? Looks good without the white. I will try it both ways when I paint my GT's.
Looks good PC101, thanks for posting! Did you decide to not use a white background as on your previous GT's or am I attributing someone else's work to you? Looks good without the white. I will try it both ways when I paint my GT's.
I have used white paint as the undercoat on all my GTs followed with the red/green paint.
I felt that using white for the undercoat I could use a thinner coat of red and green. IIRC without the white undercoat I needed to use a heavy/thicker coat of red/green which could/would scatch off easier.
I did try silver as the undercoat and did not like the results.
If you look close at my above reply you will see the white paint on the side with the red head and a little white on the green head where the arm contacts the head.
I could say with people's eyes and how it sees color, some may see a darker/lighter green and the same with the red. My father would see brown for red.
The only thing I did different with this one then with the other ones on my layout is scuff/sanding of the head. (testing purpose for this post)
I can't see where the painted surface of the head gets abused (*), when you start the throw you touch the end of the head and when completing the throw you are pushing down on the painted head touching the head with a finger/soft flesh.
* maybe one, when the operator over throws the GT and jams the head into the ballast.
doctorwayne I could never understand why the throw arm would require paint, but if I had to do so, I would have drilled a shallow hole in both the top and bottom of the throw arm, then added a drop of red (or green) paint in each dimple. With the painted area recessed, it would likely last forever.
I could never understand why the throw arm would require paint, but if I had to do so, I would have drilled a shallow hole in both the top and bottom of the throw arm, then added a drop of red (or green) paint in each dimple. With the painted area recessed, it would likely last forever.
I will just be painting the top faces of the throw arm, not the whole thing. PC101's method of painting a white base on the tip followed by a red or green dot has enhanced visibility. I like it, anything that helps me prevent derailments is worthwhile.
I tried center over springs to control turnouts. Inexpensive and work very well. However, with my aging eyes, I had issues with reading turnout direction on my switching layout leading to derailments. Thus, IMO, my move to CIGT with painted tips should lead to better operations on my layout.
Good to have you back Wayne!
I could never understand why the throw arm would require paint, but if I had to do so, I would have drilled a shallow hole in both the top and bottom of the throw arm, then added a drop of red (or green) paint in each dimple. With the painted area recessed, it would likely last forever.I kept my Caboose Industries ground throws on the staging tracks, but replaced the others with bent steel rod to finger-activate the turnouts.If anybody needs some Caboose Industries ground throws, I have 40 of them, all in good condition, for a buck apiece.
Wayne
As of now I would say the sanding/scuffing of the head is a good starting point.
Tonight it will get the green paint.
Keep the reports coming PC101! My Testor's paint is supposed to arrive this week and I'm looking forward to giving it a try!
So far with the scuffing/sanding of the head's surface and only the white paint applied, I have scratched lightly with my finger nail three times then seven times and the white paint is holding good. Now for the application of the red and green paint.
IDRick PC101, thanks for reporting your experiences with testors enamel on CIGT! Did you always use the testor's pens or did you sometimes use the bottled enamel? Please report back on how well the repaint adheres to the GT. I don't mind repainting, especially if gives another several years of use! BTW, love your idea of painting the tip white then spotting either red or green. Colors really pop!
PC101, thanks for reporting your experiences with testors enamel on CIGT! Did you always use the testor's pens or did you sometimes use the bottled enamel? Please report back on how well the repaint adheres to the GT. I don't mind repainting, especially if gives another several years of use! BTW, love your idea of painting the tip white then spotting either red or green. Colors really pop!
One of my Tester's paint marker (white) is dated 2/26/97. I do know that this marker is not the first one or the latest one in white for use on the CIGTs. I have just scratched off the red/green/white on a CIGT and scuff sanded the lever's head just to remove the shine and painted it white. Maybe tomorrow it might get the green and red coat.
Opps, I forget to answer your second question, I never used bottle paint on CIGTs, that would require a lot of shaking time and a brush or Q-tip. I think some of my Tester's bottles, the small ones have .15 or .20 on their lids.
The paint marker was fast for the job, shake, dapple the tip on a plate glass work area and paint the ground throw's head. I painted all the lever's heads white first and at that time very few were painted the red/green. Most heads were left with only the white paint. When that ground throw was in place with the switch/turnout then I would paint the lever's head for the main (green) and the diverging (red) route.
Now you have me looking at my CIGT's to see if any need maintenance.
My CIGT's throw lever heads have been painted with Testor's enamel paints since I started using ground throws, of course it is only me throwing them and who knows how often and which ones have been thrown more or less then others. Saying that, since this posted subject, I just started to scratch with my fingernail to see what happens, well the Testor's enamal comes off. So the real railroads have to paint and repaint their property do to weather and use why should my equipment be any different. Also my CIGT are of course all within easy reach.
I am going to rub the throw lever's head with fine sandpaper to ruffen it up some and repaint it, then let it dry for many days then scratch at it just to see what happens.
I've already ordered the Testor's paints and thinner.
I found this comment on a different forum:
"In the April 2006 issue of Model Railroader (page 36) is an article about "Curing chipped handrails", and it addresses a product called Plastic Adhesion Promoter #SXA 1050. The product is made by Specialty Performance Products."
Might be worth trying if painting Delrin handrails. My MR's are not organized, too lazy to search out the article...
UPDATE: I tried the Vallejo Surface Primer (VSP) + craft paints on a CI ground throw. A moderate single coat of VSP was easy to remove from the ground throw. Three thin layers of VSP, applied a few hours apart, was more durable than a moderate single layer. However, the combination of VSP + craft paint peeled off the ground throw by light probing with a skewer stick. Result: FAIL
For Option 2, I will try JoeinPA's approach where he cleaned the ground throw thoroughly and then applied Testor's enamel paint to the handle. The ground throws have retained their enamel paint spots since 2005. Testor's enamel paint bottles are available on-line at widely ranging prices ($2.69 to over $8). In my searching, Hobby Lobby had the best price.
You should be fine. You can always do touch-ups from time to time.
Simon
Thank you to all who replied to my thread! Lots of different options out there to add throw indication colors to my 12 ground throws. Implementation costs range from $13 to $32. I have decided to go with Vallejo surface primer (VSP) + craft paint due to having the lowest cost and alternative uses in other projects. There will be minimal waste and no product sitting on a shelf waiting for a purpose.
I have listed the price total for the different options below.
Vallejo SP + craft paint $13
Napa 7223 primer + craft paint $15
Michaels color pens + shipping + craft paint $18
Tamiya surface primer + craft paint $19
Testors bottles, thinner, shipping, craft paint $26
Testors paint pens, craft paint $32
We've had Delrin paint threads before. I recall the recommendation was a primer used by RC car modelers.
EDIT Forum member Zstripe recommended Polycarbonate Paint
Henry
COB Potomac & Northern
Shenandoah Valley
Hornblower Thanks for the tip on cheap paint pens at Michaels ($4 these days). I'll pick some up tomorrow, easiest solution and cheapest!
Joe Thanks for the tip on testor's enamel paint. Not available locally but could be ordered. A bit more than the paint pens + would need to buy paint thinner. A worthy suggestion!
I used Testors enamel that is in the little bottles. It has lasted since I painted the ground throw handles 2005.
Joe
I used some cheap paint pens I picked up at Michael's craft store. I painted one side of the ground throw handle red and the other side green. I have not had to repaint any after several years and several operating sessions where some operators can be a little rough on these ground throws.
Hornblower
Quick Follow-up I had two bottles of craft paint available to try (Craft-smart and Americana). Paint came off easily with a 10 hour dry time. The multi-surface version might work better but unfortunately not available locally in the desired colors (white, red and green).
PC101 Great idea to use a white background with green or red dot. Will use that idea on my ground throws! Will look for testors pens locally.
Simon Lots of different auto primers out there with a range in price. The Napa 7223 primer has some positive reviews online for uses on a model RR, leaning that direction if I go with a primer.
rrbell Nail polish, an intriguing idea! Will call a friend and see if she is willing to donate a dab of polish to one of my ground throws.
Lion I'm a cat fan and my cat enjoys watching the trains go by. At times he's tempted to go full Godzilla on the train but he gives the game away with black eyes and a wiggling butt. A sharp no and he resists and goes away sulking. The GRS machine is cool!
If I remember right, someone used nail polish.
I paint white first on the throw lever handle end then the red/green over the white which makes the red/green brighter, and I used Tester's paint pens over the years.
What is with ground throws. Use a GRS machiine!
The Route of the Broadway Lion The Largest Subway Layout in North Dakota.
Here there be cats. LIONS with CAMERAS
Dave, do remember the company name and product line? Some craft paints are labeled as multi-surface acrylics which may increase the odds of sticking to delrin. I'll have to take a look around at craft paints in town. They're cheap enough to try several different ones. Thanks for sharing Dave!
Dave H. Painted side goes up. My website : wnbranch.com
A good auto primer should also work.
I found a reference for Napa # 7223 primer in the forum railwire.net Author reported great success painting plastic hand rails and being able to paint over the primer with Accu-paint or Tru-color. It is available at my local Napa store. May give it a try.
Add in: A trainboard post also reported good results with the Napa 7223 primer and claimed one could paint over with Modelflex or craft acrylic paints.
ADD in 2: Apparently Vallejo surface primer also works on Caboose ground throws.