As always, YMMV. My ex years ago had a Tyco set in a box that was preserved along with most of her childhood stuff in her parents house.
My standards were a good deal lower back 25 years ago and I did think about upgrading the several freight cars in that box. But there was really nothing special about them. Add to that the roof walk on the box car was molded on and looked pretty crude. The same went for the other freight cars.
In the end I decided it wasn't worth the trouble to upgrade cars that looked so toy-like, poor as I was then.
That said, I've seen some unique freight cars such as the light gray Santa Fe cylindrical covered hopper never made in a higher quality version that some have gone to the trouble to upgrade.
And of course my modeling era precluded some unique cars a too old to be of interest to me - including the helium car, interesting and unique as it is.
I like converting train set cars to Kadee body mount couplers as these cars can be had for next to nothing at train shows vs $20 to $40 for RTR cars.
There are literally boxes and boxes of 2-3 dollar freight cars at some of the bigger train shows - enough to choke a small landfill. I'm guessing the few that get bought are by parents with small children who don't mind spending a few dollars to get little Johnny some trains for cheap and no worries if they get abused cause they didn't cost much. But some may be of interest to club folks who need models that can also take abuse and not cost much.
It's a time vs money trade off. If you have lots and lots of time, you can convert more trainset train cars than you can possibly imagine. The down side is most still look very toy-like; if thats acceptable - go for it.
For those that want trains that don't look so much like toys but are on a budget, there are still lots of good deals on kits like Athearn, MDC, LL P2K (higher detail), Accurail etc. I was at the Timonium show last spring and there were lots of nice looking used freight cars for sale that looks mucn nicer than toy train level and priced around $8 to $10 and were equipped with KD's. I picked up a nicely painted Accurail 40' PC box car with the ACI lable, KD's etc for $10.
By the time you spend upgrading a Tyco freight car, it's going to be close to be in that price range anyway and not necessarly look that good.
The good news is there is a whole continuum of models out there including those who are tight budget minded.
Rio Grande. The Action Road - Focus 1977-1983
I like converting train set cars to Kadee body mount couplers as these cars can be had for next to nothing at train shows vs $20 to $40 for RTR cars. Usually, use #148 couplers and Kadee boxes.
There is a Greenburg show in 2 weeks and I think that I will pick up a few cars to convert and practice weathering.
Joe Staten Island West
nemesys I will convert all of them to body mount the couplers.
Smart move. Our club outlaws talgo couplers because they can cause derailments on long trains -- if the slack comes in quickly it can shove the truck right off the rails.
If it hasn't been mentioned before, Kadee makes a kit (#246) with the proper drill bits and a 2-56 tap. At $8 or so you can probably get the parts seperately for less, but it's nice to have everything packaged in one place.
https://www.kadee.com/s-scale-tools-and-accessories-c-274_282_317/246-tap-256-and-drills-50-and-43-p-333.htm
I'm with you on older cars... modern detail is nice but it's also f-r-a-g-i-l-e. On our club layout, simple old Athearn, Roundhouse, and Accurail cars fare the best.
Aaron
I sent you a PM with my email address. You will need to change the <at> to an @ and the <dot> to a period.
.
including an email in a PM apparently does not work so well.
-Kevin
Living the dream.
Hello All,
Kevin, got the message but for some reason I can't reply to it through the forums.
I can receive messages but cannot reply. Do you have an email you can message me?
Hope this helps.
"Uhh...I didn’t know it was 'impossible' I just made it work...sorry"
jjdamnit Hello All, SeeYou190 JJ: Would you like another "special" Tyco operating dump car for your collection? If so, please send me a PM. I have one for you. Very kind of you!
SeeYou190 JJ: Would you like another "special" Tyco operating dump car for your collection? If so, please send me a PM. I have one for you.
Very kind of you!
JJ: I sent you a PM message about the car.
doctorwayne riogrande5761 Yes, what Wayne (of many pictures) showed you.... Hey! There weren't all that many pictures in my post!! The bulk of them were in the link, and I doubt that many viewers bother clicking on links. Wayne (proudly of many pictures)
riogrande5761 Yes, what Wayne (of many pictures) showed you....
Hey! There weren't all that many pictures in my post!! The bulk of them were in the link, and I doubt that many viewers bother clicking on links.
Wayne (proudly of many pictures)
If you've got it, flaunt it...
Gary
gmpullman riogrande5761 Occasionally there were freight cars made in train set quality versions like Tyco that have never been done in a finer high fidelity model. Case in point, the AHM/Roco helium car: Helium_tube by Edmund, on Flickr I hope to scrape the molded ladders and grabs off and repaint a few of these soon. Brass models are in the $400 range and the old Ambroid kit looked like a stack of pencils. http://tycotrain.tripod.com/ahmhoscalefreightcars/id3.html Regards, Ed
riogrande5761 Occasionally there were freight cars made in train set quality versions like Tyco that have never been done in a finer high fidelity model.
Case in point, the AHM/Roco helium car:
Helium_tube by Edmund, on Flickr
I hope to scrape the molded ladders and grabs off and repaint a few of these soon. Brass models are in the $400 range and the old Ambroid kit looked like a stack of pencils.
http://tycotrain.tripod.com/ahmhoscalefreightcars/id3.html
Regards, Ed
Tony Thompson has reworked that car: http://modelingthesp.blogspot.com/search?q=helium
It is a helium tank car, built in the 40's for the US NAVY, later used by private industry.
Sheldon
riogrande5761 nemesys Yes, I now see Tyco in a very different light! But there are still some of their cars that interest me... Occasionally there were freight cars made in train set quality versions like Tyco that have never been done in a finer high fidelity model. I've known people to upgrade a few like that or maybe there something sentimental.
nemesys Yes, I now see Tyco in a very different light! But there are still some of their cars that interest me...
Occasionally?
As a modeler of the early 50's there are a long list of 40's/50's era prototypes that have never been rendered in anything much better than an Athearn Blue Box or Athearn/Varney "tin" car.
But the good news is 80% of the people can't tell the difference, particularly in that specific era.
Now an Athearn Blue Box, Roundhouse, Bowser, Train Minature, early Walthers shake the box, etc, are for the most part better than a TYCO, LIFE LIKE or AHM train set car, but clearly not a Kadee, Tangent, Proto, etc.
Never seen that type of car before. It's some kind of tanker?
riogrande5761Occasionally there were freight cars made in train set quality versions like Tyco that have never been done in a finer high fidelity model.
nemesysYes, I now see Tyco in a very different light! But there are still some of their cars that interest me...
Intermountain wheelsets work fine in the Tyco frames, BTW
riogrande5761Yes, what Wayne (of many pictures) showed you....
Mantua's original offering, dating from the '50s, if not earlier, represents the AAR 41' gondola of, I believe, the late '30s...
...as does Accurail's more recent version...
Once you replace the moulded-on grabirons on both (and the clunky sill steps on the Tyco and Mantua versions) with metal parts, and add some underbody details to the older cars, the only noticeable difference is the oversize rivets on the older ones.Running in a train on your layout, they're not really poke-you-in-the-eye offensive, in my opinion. However, if you found them so, they could be scraped-off and replaced with 3-D rivet decals, as used on this cinder gondola, scratchbuilt on a Tichy flatcar...
Tyco and Mantua cars, especially at train shows, can be had for a buck or less, and provide excellent fodder for kitbashing or detailing. Even if you screw-up, it's not a big hit financially and serves as experience in such work. You'll learn at least as much from your mistakes as you will from your successes.
csxns riogrande5761 look at Tyco rolling stock in a very different light Jim,thought you were a Tyco kind of Model Railroader.
riogrande5761 look at Tyco rolling stock in a very different light
Jim,thought you were a Tyco kind of Model Railroader.
There you go thinking again.
SeeYou190JJ: Would you like another "special" Tyco operating dump car for your collection? If so, please send me a PM. I have one for you.
riogrande5761 nemesys Wow! You guys amaze me! Incredible work, Wayne. Well, if you didn't know, you can probably tell now that I'm kind of "restarting" in the hobby. I'm 58. I had my first train when I was 16. I lived in a small town back then. There was no internet, no way to really communicate with the external world except by phone. I forgot it for many years but last year, by accident, I came back to it. I started buying stuff and build my layout. I'm still experimenting. I rebuilt my layout 3 times, trying something a little different each time. Now, I think I have it in its definitive form for some time. These information you provide are invaluable to me. Thank you! Yes, what Wayne (of many pictures) showed you. Cliff Notes version: Cut off the coupler from the truck and body mount a Kadee #5 so it matches the Kadee height gauge. You may need to shim to get the height right. I'd attach with a screw. After you get over the sticker shock of the more recent but gorgeous rollling stock available from Tangent, ExactRail, Moloco and Athearn Genesis, you will probably look at Tyco rolling stock in a very different light Your call of course!
nemesys Wow! You guys amaze me! Incredible work, Wayne. Well, if you didn't know, you can probably tell now that I'm kind of "restarting" in the hobby. I'm 58. I had my first train when I was 16. I lived in a small town back then. There was no internet, no way to really communicate with the external world except by phone. I forgot it for many years but last year, by accident, I came back to it. I started buying stuff and build my layout. I'm still experimenting. I rebuilt my layout 3 times, trying something a little different each time. Now, I think I have it in its definitive form for some time. These information you provide are invaluable to me. Thank you!
Wow! You guys amaze me! Incredible work, Wayne. Well, if you didn't know, you can probably tell now that I'm kind of "restarting" in the hobby. I'm 58. I had my first train when I was 16. I lived in a small town back then. There was no internet, no way to really communicate with the external world except by phone. I forgot it for many years but last year, by accident, I came back to it. I started buying stuff and build my layout. I'm still experimenting. I rebuilt my layout 3 times, trying something a little different each time. Now, I think I have it in its definitive form for some time. These information you provide are invaluable to me. Thank you!
Yes, what Wayne (of many pictures) showed you. Cliff Notes version:
Cut off the coupler from the truck and body mount a Kadee #5 so it matches the Kadee height gauge. You may need to shim to get the height right. I'd attach with a screw.
After you get over the sticker shock of the more recent but gorgeous rollling stock available from Tangent, ExactRail, Moloco and Athearn Genesis, you will probably look at Tyco rolling stock in a very different light Your call of course!
Yes, I now see Tyco in a very different light! But there are still some of their cars that interest me...
Russell
Here's a Mantua (forerunner of Tyco) gondola, which originally had Talgo-type trucks, which were screw-mounted. Since the original trucks weren't especially well-done, I replaced them with ones from MDC...
I also installed Kadee #5s in their own plastic gearboxes, and since the car has a metal underframe, drilled and tapped for the screws...
EG&E 4519 is a Tyco car, with a plastic underframe. It had Talgo-type trucks, too, but they were the clip-in type. I cut off the coupler extension and added body-mounted Kadee #5s, then modified the clip-in trucks to be screw-mounted.
I first filled-in the over-size mounting holes in the underbody, using styrene rod inside of styrene tubing, then drilling to accept screws...
Next, the holes left in the truck's bolster after removing the clip-in portion were filled using suitably-sized styrene rod, from Evergreen....
...this allowed me to use solvent-type cement to add a piece of black sheet styrene to the underside of the bolster...
...allowing for a hole to be drilled through for screw-mounting the trucks...
Here's the re-worked car, with its modified original trucks and plastic wheels...
If you're interested in another type of modified Tyco rolling stock, this LINK may be useful.
Wayne
jjdamnitMost of my rolling stock is vintage 1970's HO Tyco 34-foot Operating Hopper Cars.
JJ: Would you like another "special" Tyco operating dump car for your collection? If so, please send me a PM. I have one for you.
I usually convert train set cars, like Tyco, to body mount couplers. The body mounts look better to my eye, and work far better when you are backing the train. The truck mount couplers (talgo some call them) tend to twist the trucks under the backing force and derail. I drill a hole to take a 2-56 screw thru the Kadee coupler box in the bottom of the car. If the under carriage is pure plastic I merely drill a #50 hole. If the undercarriage is metal I tap the hole for a 2-56 screw. Body mount works fine on 40 and 50 foot freight cars. Passenger cars I leave with truck mount couplers. The Kadee what-fits-what list will steer you toward truck mount couplers for cars that originally had truck mount couplers.
David Starr www.newsnorthwoods.blogspot.com
jjdamnit Hello All, Most of my rolling stock is vintage 1970's HO Tyco 34-foot Operating Hopper Cars. These came stock with Talgo style Horn & Hook couplers. What I have learned over the year of updating this fleet of almost 40 cars is... •I first tried the Kadee Talgo adapters. This allows you to use #5 couplers in the truck mounted Talgo style coupler pockets.The problem with this solution- -and any truck mounted couplers- -is they tend to derail when pushing or backing-up. •Next I tried the Kadee trucks with couplers mounted to them "Talgo Style". I experienced the same problems during reversing operations. •My final solution was to remove the Talgo style couplers. I cut the Talgo coupler pockets, upgrade the wheels to metal and body mount the couplers. It took a lot of time and money to reach the conclusion that Talgo-style couplers weren't worth the time, money and effort. My suggestion: Keep the O.E.M. clip-in side frame trucks, cut off the truck mounted coupler pockets. Upgrade the wheels to metal. Body mount the couplers with Kadee draft gear boxes; use #5 (or #148 "wisker") couplers. Enjoy smooth, free-rolling, cars with the reliability of Kadee coupling. Hope this helps.
Most of my rolling stock is vintage 1970's HO Tyco 34-foot Operating Hopper Cars.
These came stock with Talgo style Horn & Hook couplers.
What I have learned over the year of updating this fleet of almost 40 cars is...
•I first tried the Kadee Talgo adapters. This allows you to use #5 couplers in the truck mounted Talgo style coupler pockets.The problem with this solution- -and any truck mounted couplers- -is they tend to derail when pushing or backing-up.
•Next I tried the Kadee trucks with couplers mounted to them "Talgo Style". I experienced the same problems during reversing operations.
•My final solution was to remove the Talgo style couplers. I cut the Talgo coupler pockets, upgrade the wheels to metal and body mount the couplers.
It took a lot of time and money to reach the conclusion that Talgo-style couplers weren't worth the time, money and effort.
My suggestion:
Keep the O.E.M. clip-in side frame trucks, cut off the truck mounted coupler pockets. Upgrade the wheels to metal.
Body mount the couplers with Kadee draft gear boxes; use #5 (or #148 "wisker") couplers.
Enjoy smooth, free-rolling, cars with the reliability of Kadee coupling.
Thank you, it certainly helps a lot. To be honest, I've never thought about mounting the couplers on the car itself. What I did for a few cars was to cut the pocket on the truck and glue a Kadee gear box on it, then put the coupler in it. It think that's why I had been having some problems with some of the cars. I will convert all of them to body mount the couplers.
Thanks again!
nemesysI was not aware of the Athearn trucks. Are these snapping in place, replacing the cheap original plastic ones?
No. Athearn trucks, along with many others, are held in place with a screw. After removing the Talgo trucks, you fill in the hole with a plastic rod, and redrill for a screw.
Mike.
My You Tube
I use to carefully remove the coupler and put Kadees on.
I would put machined metal wheels on the trucks and use a truck tuner first and check the car for free wheeling. I think I used reboxx wheels not made anymore last I knew. Intermountain are very good. I like machined for the weight do not pick up dirt like Kadee wheels which can pick up dirt over time. They are not solid metal. Opinions vary.
Also, I do not like black wheels.
Edit.
I mad a three foot long solid strip of wood with a three foot strip of track on cork. Raise one end to simulate a two degree slope and see how the cars roll with NMRA weight.
Rich
If you ever fall over in public, pick yourself up and say “sorry it’s been a while since I inhabited a body.” And just walk away.