Yes, very cool!
Also, along the lines of things that don't make any sense in tv or radio commercials, I've noticed this: that in almost every commercial there's a line or a visual that doesn't make any sense. Don't know why they do that but it shows how oblivious we become when commercial time rudely interrupts our favorite program.
eric2448 hon30critter Neat ad! I'd be curious to know how they chose the road name 'Columbia Gorge'. Perhaps they didn't want to use a more common railroad for fear of copyright infringement. Dave I believe it was filmed at the Colombia Gorge Model Railroad Club in Oregon. Like a few of you mention, the steam whistle may be more associated with trains than an air horn. Could be a very well thought out commercial or someone who doesnt know any better. We may never know. At least when the commercial opens, it sounds like a diesel, they got something correct.
hon30critter Neat ad! I'd be curious to know how they chose the road name 'Columbia Gorge'. Perhaps they didn't want to use a more common railroad for fear of copyright infringement. Dave
Neat ad!
I'd be curious to know how they chose the road name 'Columbia Gorge'. Perhaps they didn't want to use a more common railroad for fear of copyright infringement.
Dave
I believe it was filmed at the Colombia Gorge Model Railroad Club in Oregon.
Like a few of you mention, the steam whistle may be more associated with trains than an air horn. Could be a very well thought out commercial or someone who doesnt know any better. We may never know. At least when the commercial opens, it sounds like a diesel, they got something correct.
Ding, Ding, Ding, We have a WINNER, Yes that was filmed at the Columbia Gorge Model Railroad Club, in Portland, OR. That E Unit is a club locomotive painted for the Columbia Gorge Lines(CGL reporting marks).
I haven't been very active in the club for a couple of years now, and I hadn't even heard about this ad being filmed there, I happened to see it post on the OGR (O Gauge Railroading) forum. It took me a few viewings of the video to place it, that is the first scene you see on the right entering the layout room from the "Show" entrance.
Doug
May your flanges always stay BETWEEN the rails
You all have it wrong. It is not a steam engine whistle or a diesel engine horn. It is the sound an electric train makes. duh. I know because I have heard it on commercials for electric trains, and at train shows. Cute commercial.
Tempest in a teapot. I actually heard a prototype diesel locomotive use a steam whistle.
The arrival of 1971 (IIRC) was heralded in San Jose, CA by the wild blowing of a steam whistle. i actually went to the Lenzen Ave. engine terminal (since closed) to find out was going on. I wasn't the only one. Several railfans showed up looking for the source of that lovely sound. Turns out that one of the shop workers had connected the whistle to the steam generator of one of the Fairbanks-Morse Trainmasters used in SP commute service.
Like the man says, there's a prototype for everything.
Andre
Another steam whistle faux pas / anachronism was committed by no less than GE itself, in a commercial from a few years ago:
https://youtu.be/Co0qkWRqTdM
Starting about the 40 second mark, the kids says "My mom makes trains that are friends with trees" and you can hear the steam whistle howl in the background as the shiny new ES44 rolls by...
To be fair, though, it seems in keeping with the theme of the commercial. Earlier they showed planes with bird sounds in the background.
Dan Stokes
My other car is a tunnel motor
That's ok, I remember an episode of Special Victims Unit, where one of the suspects was a since retired professor with Alheimers ws running his model trains and his diesel locomotive had a steam whistle. Unfortunately for us model railroaders, we have to deal with the fact that sometimes movies and tv shows don't have "technical advisors" like other genres. My late father, a career fighter pilot, would get tickled when Col. Steve Austin would take off in one jet, fly another and land in yet another.
Marlon
See pictures of the Clinton-Golden Valley RR
I'm just a dude with a bad back having a lot of fun with model trains, and finally building a layout!
Very cool!
What a great ad. Even with the wrong sound the message gets across. I hope it plays on TV as well as on the internet.
rrinker Or the air WHISTLES on the FL9's..... --Randy
Or the air WHISTLES on the FL9's.....
--Randy
I was going to say, it could be a Hancock air whistle.
Modeling the Pennsylvania Railroad in N Scale.
www.prr-nscale.blogspot.com
Modeling the Reading Railroad in the 1950's
Visit my web site at www.readingeastpenn.com for construction updates, DCC Info, and more.
TheWizard ...or maybe they do know the difference, and its just some darn good advertising.
...or maybe they do know the difference, and its just some darn good advertising.
TheWizard ...or maybe they do know the difference, and its just some darn good advertising
...or maybe they do know the difference, and its just some darn good advertising
Got attention, didn't it.
Sort of similar to the old actor's comment on a bad review. "I don't care what they call me, as long as they spell my name right."
(And then there are those latter-day locos that had both steam whistles and air horns...)
Chuck (Modeling Central Japan in September, 1964)
Haven't seen it in the NE on TV or internet.
Get the train to tne kid to get him started in the hobby, that's the important part. He'll figure out the difference. Hopefully they equipped the loco with the proper decoder.
Have fun,
Richard
They aren't the only ones that don't know the difference between steam whistles and diesel horns. Even my 5 year old great grandson noticed that on one of the Paw Patrol shows; same scenario, a diesel loco sounding a steam whistle. He wanted to know why they did that? I told him the people who make these animated shows don't know about trains; maybe they should ask you before the make them! He just laughed and said 'Yeah, I guess so!"
-Bob
PS: Yes, he is only 5.
Life is what happens while you are making other plans!
I did a search and did not find this so forgive me if this has already been posted.
This ad played while watching videos on YouTube. Hats off to Fedex, very cool to see this. Yes, steam whistle with a diesel loco, but other than that... I wonder if its online only or actually plays on TV? Anyone?