I personally don't have one yet... I was just going off of the performance of my other BB engines, and that I had heard somewhere that the mech was based off of that for one of the diesels. The GP40 I used to have ran well.
Jack Derby If you want to Kitbashed the look, I'd try using the BB 4-4-0, old one (for cost reasons), and put new domes, stack, and cab on it, with a new. Tender shell, and repaint the whole deal.
If you want to Kitbashed the look, I'd try using the BB 4-4-0, old one (for cost reasons), and put new domes, stack, and cab on it, with a new. Tender shell, and repaint the whole deal.
Jack, if you are referring to oldtime Bachmann 4-4-0 (Jupiter, etc.), I would agree that the dimensions would be closer to the prototype shown. However, they are far from being good runners. The one I have is an OK runner, but I added extra electrical pickup wipers on the tender and changed the motor to achieve this. I also added DCC by hiding a decoder under a (new) wood pile in the tender. There is a new run of that model announced by Bachmann, but the price is probably beyond the OP's range. In that line of thought, there is also the oldtime Rivarossi and Mantua 4-4-0s. I have seen these in operation and they also suffer from the lack of power pickups. But I suspect that they are more robust than the oldtime Bachmann. The Mantua kits pop-up regularly on Ebay and they would provide the added enjoyment of building it...
Let us know what happens and please post your finished model!
Simon
S. Connor Thanks for the replies. I'm just hoping to find a "modern era"-circa 1920's- DC (without sound) 4-4-0. IHC seemed to look like it had the best quality for the model and price. EDIT: I'm hoping to kitbash this into the MKT 311, without having to do much more than replace a tender and repaint. Good enough is good enough for me.
Thanks for the replies.
I'm just hoping to find a "modern era"-circa 1920's- DC (without sound) 4-4-0. IHC seemed to look like it had the best quality for the model and price.
EDIT: I'm hoping to kitbash this into the MKT 311, without having to do much more than replace a tender and repaint. Good enough is good enough for me.
The Bachmann 4-4-0- modern looks very much like that engine. It is more exspensive but worth a shot. You should check it out!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Modeling the PRR & NYC in HO
Youtube Channel: www.youtube.com/@trainman440
Instagram (where I share projects!): https://www.instagram.com/trainman440
Hi. The IHC modern 4-4-0 was manufactured by Mehano. These were generally smooth runners for the price, with decent details (some molded). Not a very strong puller but that was also the case for the prototype. It's a pretty generic model, the dimensions are pretty close to the SP loco (Based on Westcott's book). John Pryke wrote an article in MR a few years ago on how to add details to a similar engine (Mehano 2-6-0). I also own a Bachmann modern American and I must say that it is a better runner. You might have pay an extra 50$ to get one, but the detail and running qualities are much better. There is also the roundhouse/athearn 4-4-0, but that one is harder to find. If you want to have fun re-detailing an engine, the IHC is a good candidate. You can also get all three like I did... The 4-4-0 is one of my favorites!
At one time I had an IHC 4-4-0 and it ran very nicely. The flanges were what motivated me to sell it. I do believe some of the newer ones had RP25 flanges. I could be wrong on that. YMMV
------
Greg WilliamsCanterbury, NBCanadahttps://www.gregstrainyard.com/
^ Well, there was the Old Time 4-4-0 too....
The IHC modern 4-4-0 is the 2-6-0 with a drive axle removed. I haven't tried the 4-4-0 myself, but I would expect it to have similar performance to the 2-6-0 since it's practically the same engine.
_________________________________________________________________
I have two IHC 2-6-0 Moguls and they are very satisfactory. Look good, run good, stay on the track. I would expect the IHC 4-4-0 American to be just as good. Since IHC has been out of business for several years, I would expect train shows and Ebay to be your only sources.
David Starr www.newsnorthwoods.blogspot.com
Yeah, our NMRA division clerk/paymaster has several of the Bachmann 4-4-0s with sound he purchased in the last couple of years. For the money, a darn good loco, but unless you can find a good deal on a used one will likely be more than $30, if that is the budget.
Mike Lehman
Urbana, IL
Try Bachmannn. That have some very good engines, many 4-4-0's in ur price range.
Hi,
After reading several threads about the above model on this forum, and others, there are still a few questions I have, so here we go with another thread...
I'm looking into a smaller loomotive for a light kitbashing project. I've come across the IHC 4-4-0, and boy, does it look good! But my expirience with IHC has been mixed. Their 2-6-0 is the pride of my RR for *detail, pulling power, durability, and (Lack of) motor noise*. Their 4-6-2 was a dissapointment for me.
I'd like to hear from some of you guys about this model if you have it, particularly how it scores in the above catagories (*). If it is anything like the IHC 2-6-0, I think it'd be a worthy adition to my fleet.
I'm looking for a DC version around the $30 mark (Ebay isn't very helpful so far), if you can point me in the right dirrection, that'd be a big help!
Thanks so much for your help- one model railroader to another.