Great American Train Show Experience

[Anonymous]

I have not been to a good GATS show in about three years. I will not go to anymore until I hear that the ones in southern California are worth going to.

[CNW-400]

I've not been very impressed with the GATS here in the Chicago suburbs.

I think for most part the key is looking for something in particular, and knowing its worth ahead of time. I saw a few gems in with the junk, some were priced outrageously, some not so.

Mark

[Jetrock]

QUOTE: Originally posted by AggroJones

Jetrock probably was there. What was it like for you, dude?

No, I decided to skip the GATS show so I would have some cash in hand for the show at the Roseville Fairgrounds the first weekend of February. I was kind of disappointed by the one GATS show I attended, and I had a great time at both Roseville shows I have attended, so I think I'll stick to Roseville.

It's a bit longer drive, but it's cheaper ($4 admission instead of $6, parking is $1 instead of either $5 or parking clear over on Arden) and they tend to have a lot of nice stuff. Plus it's in Roseville, and thus easy to spend some time poking about and taking railfan photos of Roseville Yard after spending one's wad at the train show.

February 7 is also "free museum day" in Sacramento--all museums in Sacramento, including the CSRM, charge no admission.

[Anonymous]

Recently went to GATS in Arlington, TX. Spent more on parking and admission than what we purchased!!! I will be going to the Dallas Area Train Show today.

The layouts displayed are better and many more dealers but I will usually only buy something I can't get at my LHS--timetables, shirts or something unusual. My LHS is great!!

[DSchmitt]

I haven't been to a GATS in years. I used to participate with NTRAK in 3 or 4 a year. I've been to Pleasonton, Oakland, San Francisco, Sacramento and San Rafael. I felt Oakland (which I beleave they no longer do) was always a good show. Pleasonton OK and always fun. San Francisco varied but usually OK. San Rafael too small. Sacramento (which is closest to my home) had little I was interested in.

I think Cal Expo is a poorly designed facility. The parking lots are too far from the exibition halls, the buildings are too far apart, and there isn't enough cover to get out of the wind/rain in winter and the sun in the summer.

[csxns]

Charlotte NC on the 16 and 17.I will not go my LHS gets me everything.

[Anonymous]

Jan. 31 and Feb. 1 the GATS is going to be at Allentown, Pa.

[Anonymous]

waiting to get to get to the show on the 24.

[Anonymous]

I've seen many post concerning the GATS and probably 1/2 or better are critical of the GATS. The last one I went to, was in SO. FLA and it was a bust. Very few people there and other than the diecast trucks and cars that I found, most everything else was "dump city". Very disappointing. I don't really think I would waste my money going to another one.

[Anonymous]

It sounds like this could be any train show I've attended.Same Stuff Different Show.

[AntonioFP45]

Hey guys,

GATS here in Tampa, I thought, was enjoyable. A good mixture of new and used stuff. Saddening that some of you guys had negative experiences. In the plastic HO market, found lots of good deals. Yes there were overpriced items and junk also, but I have a habit of checking every vendor and display. Saw Atlas, Proto, and Kato units at an average of $25 to $35 cheaper than at the LHS! There was DCC! My wife's cousin bought an entire system for about 30% less than at the LHS. My friend of many years purchased a brand new Atlas SD35 unopened for $45! Plenty of kits and RTR stuff. Couple of nice layouts. Vendors overall positive and friendly

HInt: A very good time to buy: Apporximately 1/2 hour befoe the shows over and the vendors start packing their items. Some will be willing to UNLOAD there items and bargaining is possible, but don't get ridiculous-be cordial!

WILL ATTEND AGAIN NEXT YEAR!

[Anonymous]

VSM:

Based on my experience with the December San Diego GATS (comments in another thread) I'd say you are correct. Lots of entry level stuff and 'railroadiana'...whatever that is. I work from craftsman kits and there was very little of that. What there was was both elderly and over priced. Was my first show in some time and I was not impressed.

Randy

[bcammack]

They get one last chance at my $$ this June when they return to the Pasadena Convention Center in the Houston area. If they were back at the Reliant Hall like last year, I wouldn't bother, but at least parking is free in Pasadena and it's closer to home.

Regards,
Brett C. Cammack
League City, TX

[AggroJones]

QUOTE: Originally posted by vsmith

Is it just me or does it seam that most of these GATS events are designed around newbies and people that have very little previous experience with model RRing?

It seams like every time I go to a mainstream show like this, they only have the most generic things. Nothing is really geared toward experianced modelers, maybe a few vendors, but overall its very basic beginner stuff. And the items offerd for sale are often priced higher than my LHS.

Anyone else notice that?

Overpriced garbage. Old, damaged Model Power, Tyco, "starter set" LifeLike, and other disporportionate, low detailed crap being sold for $7. Rediculous.

Wasn't too much Accurail or MDC. And the little that was there was priced at or above MSRP.

[vsmith]

Is it just me or does it seam that most of these GATS events are designed around newbies and people that have very little previous experience with model RRing?

It seams like every time I go to a mainstream show like this, they only have the most generic things. Nothing is really geared toward experianced modelers, maybe a few vendors, but overall its very basic beginner stuff. And the items offerd for sale are often priced higher than my LHS.

Anyone else notice that?

[AggroJones]

Jetrock probably was there. What was it like for you, dude?

[dave9999]

My only complaint about the Pensacola, Fl show was absence of anything DCC. No decoders, no systems, no nothing! Dave

[Anonymous]

I have just returned from the GATS show in Indianapolis, IN. Frankly it was a bust! The Exposition Hall was less than half full of vendors. A number of regular vendors where absent. Of course it is the first weekend of the year and many railroader most likely streched a bit for Christmas. There where no computers. It seems to me that GATS has gone down hill the the past several years.

[brothaslide]

QUOTE: Originally posted by AggroJones

. . .Although most of the people are nice or pretend to be nice, some are damn racist. [:(] When you gather that many people in one location, you are bound to have some friction. But I can't let that stop me. . .

AggroJones,

I suggest buying the book SCAM by Rev. Jesse L. Peterson. I believe it will help you out.

Sean

[Anonymous]

QUOTE: Although most of the people are nice or pretend to be nice, some are damn racist. [:(] When you gather that many people in one location, you are bound to have some friction. But I can't let that stop me.
I came home with 2 Athearn PFE reefers, 1 Athearn Blatz reefer, 1 Walthers UP boxcar, Great Model Railroads vol 39 tape.

Total spending $58

You did pretty well, Aggro. [8D] I would hope the negative elements (racist) didn't prevent your enjoyment of GATS.

[Anonymous]

Thanks for the "heads up" on the GATS. It'll be here in the Detroit area on the 24th & 25th of this month. Last year I drove 1/2 an hour each way & couldn't find ANYTHING worth bringing home....... Hopefully this year will be different !!!!! 'Got $100.00 burnin' a hole in my pockets !!!!!!

Mark

[Hawks05]

you did pretty good for a show the size of those. i'd spend at least $150 easily probably. thas $150 that i don't have to.

[AggroJones]

The sun came out and today I attended the GATS at Cal Expo here in Sacramento, CA. Lately it has been like a hurricane. Hella windy, several inches of rain, and my back yard fence was broken down from this weather! [:(!]

Good thing it stopped storming today, cause after ridding a bus for 40 mins, I had to walk 1.2 miles to and from the fair grounds. Its a tremendous strain on my legs. Lots of walking. At least I don't have to pay $7 for parking! Once I'm in the show, I walked around scouting the overall map of where potential members of my fleet could be. [:)]
Then I evaluated what was crap, what was a bargin, what I should concider. I noticed alot of over priced garbage there, just like last year. [|)] I guess it broke even. I'm glad it didn't go further down hill since last time. They have a lack of high quality layouts on display. Mostly toy set ups or mediocre stuff.

Although most of the people are nice or pretend to be nice, some are damn racist. [:(] When you gather that many people in one location, you are bound to have some friction. But I can't let that stop me.
I came home with 2 Athearn PFE reefers, 1 Athearn Blatz reefer, 1 Walthers UP boxcar, Great Model Railroads vol 39 tape.

Total spending $58