Bergie locking topic

[Anonymous]

QUOTE: Originally posted by darth9x9
Do you hate me so much just because I don't have enough stars yet to be considered on of the "in crowd"?

Well your 3 posts from a star LOL.[;)]

[Anonymous]

hopefully my last correspondence re: Mr. Carl-

I've been trying to just ignore the continued rumblings and ramblings on this topic for the past week or two, and by my staying out of it, and therfore not encouraging it, one would have thought that the absurdity of this topic would be realized, the angry voice would subside and hopefully realize that what he started wasn't appropriate or particularly of any merit to anyone.

Mr. Carl, please reread 'emaraldisle's above post, and then read your own comments regarding this topic being locked down because "it wasn't really condusive to model railroading and no good would have come from it if it had continued." You are absolutely correct ! This is the first and only thing you've stated that I cannot fault. Unfortunately, it was you who started that topic, made the attacks, and you still do not realize that, as a minimum, to continue this further, not only do you still apparantly misunderstand the (lack of) significance of the 'stars', but you are perpetuating the impression that you are a spoiled ***. You may want to cruise the other comments re: this nonsense on other threads that demonstrate that you should just eat a bit of crow, compose yourself, and then contribute positive stuff, or remain silent.

I had considered to just allow the sound of your one hand clapping on this issue to just dwindle away into oblivion, but when you allege that you 'exposed' someone (me) I cannot remain passive. I hope that I haven't offended anyone by my reponse to you, and I'd hope that when, and if you childishly spout off again as you did concerning someone else, that they'll slam you back into place in a heartbeat. This Forum is for the enjoyment of everyone, and each of us has but one vote, and we do that as many times as we care to. It is supposed to be fun, informative, and beneficial to everyone, whether they are a newbee or an experienced model railroader.

As an 'experienced' model railroader, which one would assume you are, as evidenced by your accolades displayed with your signature, your profile, and on your website, one would hope that you would bring a positive, self-confident, more mature and mellower attitude to this Forum. Frankly you appear to be angry at something that needs to be confronted and resolved before you jump on a Forum and start slinging mud and picking fights, especially with people you do not know, or have a valid issue with. . .

And I hope, as I believe most all Forum members do, that this topic will just die, because Bergie locked it down for good reason. To have it resurface under a new topic heading defeats what he was trying to achieve - that is, for all this negative crap to just stop. And I hope that it will do just that, for every post just brings it to the top all over again.
BILL

[darth9x9]

Hey bill mathewson,

Wow! Once again I am amazed at how we read the same thing and we all extract something totally different. (and this is in a nice, polite tone as to not let anyone take this as an angry post as so many have done in the past).

I never said I exposed you. I said people - meaning more than one. Your assumption that it was directed toward you shows you harbor some resentment still even when no one was singled out. This is amazing. Please get over it.

Then you just called me a spoiled *** and that I have some anger issue. This is simply not true. I will let your hurtful and non-condusive comments bounce off of me. But I know you feel better putting others down. Again, I don't want to be a self-appointed moderator on this forum or any other as so many have become.

[Anonymous]

I was afraid this would happen. As I said on the first page of this thread, that with opening another topic in reply to the locked topic that the arguement would come true. We have reopened the arguement. This went from someone stating that it was his first time seeing bergie locking a topic, to a continued arguement over the locked topic.
So please let's let this one die, Agree to disagree. and lets go back to something more productive. Before bergie has to come back on and dlock another topic.

Remember that this is the internet so others will different opinions and not agree with you. This is a great thing as long as we can hold ourseslves back from name calling.
Andrew Miller

P.s.I am not saying anyone is right or wrong.

[Anonymous]

I can't believe were on 34 posts. We were going over a month without a flame and now this comes up.

[philnrunt]

george745 is right, I never meant for this to be a continuance of the original problem, I was hoping that it would get some responses about the SD70MACs and how well the moderators do their jobs.
If there is anyway I can delete, disintegrate or destroy this thread, let me know how and I will.
My apologies to all.

[darth9x9]

Hey philnrunt,

Bergie does a great job. As I said before, he is very approachable. He is also level-headed, sensible, and even-tempered. I am glad that we such a person as moderator.

[Anonymous]

Just my $.02 worth-

Long time member of this board, occassional poster on topics that interest me. [8D]
I am a moderator at a camping website, and problems like these pop up all the time. As a moderator, there's a thin line you walk between deleting and censoring posts. In my experience, we've e-mailed people to "play nice" when topics that they've started or replied to seemed rude or tended to flame other members. In the year that I've been a moderator, we've only kicked off one member, and we(the mods) debated that for 3 weeks before we did.
As was noted here, this is a general discussion forum, so apparently anything goes. If people want to post opinions, fine, just take the personal attacks to private e-mails or private messages. Don't subject the rest of the board to your rants and raves.[:(!]
Bergie had every right to lock down that topic. I, myself, has had to lock a few topics down on the camping board, and e-mailed the person with the reasons why. It's Bergie's board to moderate, and his decision is final.
BTW-nice job, Bergie.[tup][bow]

[dehusman]

The tool of locking down threads.

Dave H.

[darth9x9]

I concur completely. [^]

[Big_Boy_4005]

Guys, is it really necessary to repeat last week's unpleasntness?

Bill C, you seem like a smart guy. That was a cool trick how you got the stars to appear in your post. I hate to say it but you are now cursed with a star of your own, and if you aren't careful you will have 2, and there is nothing you can do about it.

Let's face it, this topic should never have been started. But every time Bergie has intervened, and it hasn't been very often, someone always wants to discuss it. There is no need to discuss it, it's over. Personally I wi***hat he hadn't locked the other one, because I was under the impression that it was over. The lock is so unusual, that it causes a buzz on those rare occasions that Bergie uses it.

I thought this topic had ended too, but every time it moves out of sight someone feels the need to post to it. EVERYONE PLEASE STOP!!! Just don't post to this anymore. I'm not telling you, I'm asking you nicely, for the good of the of the forum. I have seen this before, and no good comes from this.

Thank you.