Are these really neccisary to stop interferance or is this overkill regs from europe.
I've disabled the ones directly wired to the Bachmann motors I have (only about six-or-eight locos). They do not play well with DCC back EMF current sensing.
Even Bachmann says it is OK to remove them, I seem to remember reading in their "Ask Mr. Bach Mann" tech support.
Good Luck, Ed
The chokes don't really hurt anything - it's the capacitors, which in combination with the chokes form an LC filter. Removing the capacitors is easy, because they are in parallel with the motor leads, so they can be clipped off and you're done. The chokes are in series with the motor leads and if you remove them, you need to put jumper wires in their place to keep the circuit complete.
I haven't found a need to remove the chokes, without the capacitors they are just some extra length of wire.
--Randy
Modeling the Reading Railroad in the 1950's
Visit my web site at www.readingeastpenn.com for construction updates, DCC Info, and more.
They are required by the UK and EU. 4.7 micro Henry inductance. I have an LRC meter. I measured them some years ago. I did a lot of work with tuned circuits. They become a piece of wire, no resistance or inductance with the caps removed. You can see the stripes. The wire wound on a couple of mine are not marked.
Soime think the green ones are resistors.
Rich
If you ever fall over in public, pick yourself up and say “sorry it’s been a while since I inhabited a body.” And just walk away.
rrebell Are these really neccisary to stop interferance or is this overkill regs from europe.
betamax rrebell Are these really neccisary to stop interferance or is this overkill regs from europe. On another forum someone pointed out that the EU regulations apply to toys designed for children under eight years of age. Model trains are classified as "toys". This class of manufactures must have the RFI circuits installed if they are to be sold in the EU. Unfortuately they also see model locomotives equipped with a DCC decoder as a toy, where their price alone demonstrates they are not toys meant for children. So the OEMs have to comply with that regulation.
To my knoledge, Bachmann is the only company that does this. They sell models over there with about the same electronics but diffreent type locos, rolling stock over there. I have seen the catalogs.
The inductors don't hurt anything and might prevent conducted RF from impacting your other electronics. For example, that annoying buzz in my wireless headphones when I turn on my LED overhead lights... Digital signals are largely immune to RFI, so it shouldn't bother your WiFi or TV, but I'm no expert, just speculating.
Now if it messes with my ham radio, that would be a non-starter.
Genesee Terminal, freelanced HO in Upstate NY ...hosting Loon Bay Transit Authority and CSX Intermodal. Interchange with CSX (CR)(NYC).
CP/D&H, N scale, somewhere on the Canadian Shield