I haven't seen a compilation chart. Each manufacturer has their own lists of what sounds are in each decoder.
--Randy
Modeling the Reading Railroad in the 1950's
Visit my web site at www.readingeastpenn.com for construction updates, DCC Info, and more.
Well, this is probably as good a place as any to post my own question.
I am considering adding sound decoders to my fleet of 50 or 60 locos, from various manufacturers such as Athearn, Stewart, Atlas, and others. Most are models of first generation diesels, such as EMD F units, GP7's, a couple Alco's ... you get the idea. I also have a few steamers, Bachmann Spectrums. So here's my question. Has anyone compiled a chart or break down comparison of available sound decoders, comparing price, features, reviews, current ratings, etc.? I don't want to spend money on something, only to find out there was something better/cheaper/more accurate, as appropriate. I currently only have a 4x8, but hope to change this as I equip my fleet.
By the way, although my profile shows me as new, I am actually a returning member after being away for a couple years.
Thanks in advance.
Brad
EMD - Every Model Different
ALCO - Always Leaking Coolant and Oil
CSX - Coal Spilling eXperts
jeffrey-wimberly The TCS decoders (including the MC series) conform to the NMRA standards and will work fine with the Digitrax system.
The TCS decoders (including the MC series) conform to the NMRA standards and will work fine with the Digitrax system.
Excellent! Thanks for the replies everyone, they've been a big help!
Modeling New Haven despite what his user name says...
Dr. Frankendiesel aka Scott Running BearSpace Mouse for president!15 year veteran fire fighterCollector of Apple //e'sRunning Bear EnterprisesHistory Channel Club life member.beatus homo qui invenit sapientiam
simon1966 I have the Zephyr and use many TCS decoders with no problem, several of them are the MC2, which is an excellent small decoder.
I have the Zephyr and use many TCS decoders with no problem, several of them are the MC2, which is an excellent small decoder.
That's good to hear! I'm loving all the positive feedback I'm hearing about the Zephyr too. So does the MC2 have a good amount of things it can do? See, told you guys I'm clueless about them.
Simon Modelling CB&Q and Wabash See my slowly evolving layout on my picturetrail site http://www.picturetrail.com/simontrains and our videos at http://www.youtube.com/user/MrCrispybake?feature=mhum
Southwest Chief Most likely, however I bet there are some exceptions out there. If the decoder conforms to NMRA standards (which I believe most if not all newer decoders do), then it should work fine with the Zephyr. I use a Zephyr and thus far it has handled all the decoders I've tried perfectly. This includes, Digitraxx, Soundtraxx, and MRC decoders. Not sure about your specific decoder question for the Bachmann GP30, but I'm sure someone else here will know.
Most likely, however I bet there are some exceptions out there.
If the decoder conforms to NMRA standards (which I believe most if not all newer decoders do), then it should work fine with the Zephyr. I use a Zephyr and thus far it has handled all the decoders I've tried perfectly. This includes, Digitraxx, Soundtraxx, and MRC decoders.
Not sure about your specific decoder question for the Bachmann GP30, but I'm sure someone else here will know.
Thanks for your help! I'll make sure to check whether the decoders I plan on using are to NMRA standards, and glad to know the Zephyr is working for you.
Eric97123 The Zephyr is a good choice as many on here use it. How big is your layout and how many locos will you be running? Before you buy the Zephyr if you plan on running multi trains at the same time, take a look at the Empire Builder.. It is a little more but you get more Amps, the DT402 throttle is fairly easy to use and you can run two trains at the same easily and if you are running more, it is easy to recall the locos that are off running but not on the throttle.
The Zephyr is a good choice as many on here use it. How big is your layout and how many locos will you be running? Before you buy the Zephyr if you plan on running multi trains at the same time, take a look at the Empire Builder.. It is a little more but you get more Amps, the DT402 throttle is fairly easy to use and you can run two trains at the same easily and if you are running more, it is easy to recall the locos that are off running but not on the throttle.
I only plan on running two to three trains max at a time since I only have a 4x8 layout, but I'm going with the Zephyr so if I plan to expand or make a new, bigger layout I can use my current control system. I have a feeling that the Empire Builder would be too big for any of my uses, but I appreciate the recommedation!
Chessie Sys. 3022Can I use any decoder with this system? For locomotives, that is.
Matt from Anaheim, CA and Bayfield, COClick Here for my model train photo website
Hello,
I've recently decided that I'm going to build my layout using the Digitrax Zephyr control system. I am new to DCC though, so I need a bit of help.
Can I use any decoder with this system? For locomotives, that is.
Also, I was looking at the MC2 decoder to put in my Bachmann Spectrum GP30. Is this a good choice for a decoder for me, and will it work with the Zephyr?
(Here's a link: http://www.bromsgrovemodels.co.uk/TCSDecodersMC2.htm)
Thanks in advance!