Trains.com

Help with Scale

2754 views
25 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    January 2007
  • 3 posts
Help with Scale
Posted by toothmark on Tuesday, January 16, 2007 2:48 PM

As I'm new to the hobby I want to buy things that match up.  Can someone help me discern the difference in the Scales. I have a LGB Forney and some Pico buildings. These are listed as 22.5-1, but I have seen a number of different scales.  How do I tell what scale I dealing with? Whst is the best/most popular scale for an outdoor setup?

Thanks 

  • Member since
    February 2004
  • From: Notheast Oho
  • 825 posts
Posted by grandpopswalt on Tuesday, January 16, 2007 3:25 PM

Dear Tooth,

Your question is sure to bring out a lot of opinions. The short answer is that there is really no solid way to define LGB's scale. It's close to 1:22.5 but can be off significantly in almost any of the dimensions (and not all at the same time), and they do not specify a scale. Most of the other manufacturers are pretty close to what they advertise.

The best thing to do is to compare an item you're proposing to buy to something that you already own. If the two look good together, meaning that they are about the same scale, then go ahead and buy it. 

Walt

 

 

"You get too soon old and too late smart" - Amish origin
  • Member since
    December 2001
  • From: Smoggy L.A.
  • 10,743 posts
Posted by vsmith on Tuesday, January 16, 2007 4:25 PM
 toothmark wrote:

As I'm new to the hobby I want to buy things that match up.  Can someone help me discern the difference in the Scales. I have a LGB Forney and some Pico buildings. These are listed as 22.5-1, but I have seen a number of different scales.  How do I tell what scale I dealing with? Whst is the best/most popular scale for an outdoor setup?

Thanks 

to keep the discussion simple...
-
In the most basic, you have Narrow Gauge and Standard Gauge everything scale wise falls into these basic catagories.
-
 In Narrow Gauge we have:
1/20.3 (Bachmann, Accucraft narrow gauge)
1/22.5 (LGB US Profile narrow gauge)
1/24 (HLW)
All use 45mm track to represent 3'-0" (+/-) gauge track
-
In Standard Gauge:
1/2something (LGB standard gauge)
1/29 (Aristocraft, USA Trains)
1/32 (Accucraft standard gauge, MTH)
All use 45mm track to represent 4'-8 1/2" (+/-) gauge track
-
Now the difference between narrow guage and standard gauge should be obvious to anyone with a little study of railroad history as I doubt anyone would confuse a D&RGW K-36 with a PRR K-4 Pacific as being the same gauge, however heres a general rule of thumb.
-
 If the roadname is a big Class 1 mainline name like Pennsylvania, New York Central, Union Pacific, etc. its a Standard Guage engine. If its some oddball line that you never heard of like EBT, Yellow Pine, Westside Lumber, Nevada Shortline, or the ever ubiquitous D&RGW, chances are its Narrow Gauge.
-
Now for what goes with what, Piko bldgs works well with all narrow gauge lines, not so much with standard gauge as they are nominally 1/24 scale. Your Forney works as 1/22.5 3' gauge engine but its modeled on a 2 foot gauge engine and as modeled can actually pass as a 1/20.3 scale locomotive, same for the 0-4-0 Porter.
-
As for popular thats really up to whatever you prefer.
New Bachmann stuff is now 1/20.3 in narrow gauge but rolling stock selection is still limited,  theirs plenty of stuff in 1/22.5 well still being offered by Bachmann LGB & HLW.

   Have fun with your trains

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, January 16, 2007 6:17 PM

This discussion about scale gives me a pain in the neck and a few other places as well. What Walt says is right, if it goes with what you have you are ahead.

Rgds Ian

  • Member since
    February 2005
  • 1,821 posts
Posted by underworld on Wednesday, January 17, 2007 11:01 PM

Also Marklin in 1/32 scale. There is no best scale.

 

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

currently on Tour with Sleeper Cell myspace.com/sleepercellrock Sleeper Cell is @ Checkers in Bowling Green Ohio 12/31/2009 come on out to the party!!! we will be shooting more video for MTVs The Making of a Metal Band
  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Thursday, January 18, 2007 6:10 PM

Undie there is one best scale but none of us could afford it or use it in all prcticality and that     1 : 1.

Rgds Ian

  • Member since
    December 2006
  • From: Florissant, Missouri
  • 493 posts
Posted by hoofe116 on Monday, January 22, 2007 5:55 PM

Ian:

I am so glad the other guy asked. I just went to my first train show last weekend here in St. Louis, and there were two somewhat vast rooms. There were two, (2), (II, as the Romans spelt it) dealers of G-guage. (I refuse to use 'scale' for obvious reasons.) There was one formidable old guy who had a G-gauge passenger set, rather tatty, as the English say. And that was it. Nothing else. (In G). I was lucky to find that one dealer, just a day's journey by fast car from me, who talked to me at great length. In gratitude, I bought a used Aristocraft turnout and two issues of GR. And right there, after reading both those issues, I became hopelessly confused with "Scale". I'm still confused about 'narrow gauge' vs 'standard gauge' since both appear to be 45mm. Now, I really don't care about scale, per se. So long as it looks good, that's fine. I worked to close tolerances for years, I sure ain't about to do it in retirement. In the other sizes, HO, etc, narrow gauge stuff is easily discernable by looking at the wheelbases. Now, if G gauge manufacturers are putting wide bodies or narrow bodies on the same set of trucks and calling one Standard and one Narrow, that ought to be made clear.

I got some ballpark prices on remote control, battery power, etc. I went and got some good beer, after, too. Good grief, that stuff's high. For me. But compared to other scales, it isn't out of reason; it's just intrinsically expensive, I suppose.

So it look like I'll do block wiring et al. There's a huge train show coming up in March a long day's drive from me, but we're going, because many guys there are using batteries and I don't want to give up yet.

I went out in the backyard and eyeballed the site of the future RR. Things looked grim under two inches of snow. Half is sloped (eroded) and half is terraced.

Les Whitaker

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Monday, January 22, 2007 6:10 PM

Yes Les you are right but you are talking to possibly thre wrong person about scale, as i just cannot be bothered with the intricacies of it. I have enough worries of my own when dealing whith my present projects.

I think when thet refer to narrow guage etc they are referring to the original prototype situation; not the model.

I am unsure about the relatationship between "G" and "#1" i think they are the same but i don't care about this aspect and i don't need tobe enlightened.

As far as i am concerned if it looks ok it is ok.

Rgds ian

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Monday, January 22, 2007 7:05 PM
 grandpopswalt wrote:

Dear Tooth,

Your question is sure to bring out a lot of opinions. The short answer is that there is really no solid way to define LGB's scale. It's close to 1:22.5 but can be off significantly in almost any of the dimensions (and not all at the same time), and they do not specify a scale. Most of the other manufacturers are pretty close to what they advertise.

The best thing to do is to compare an item you're proposing to buy to something that you already own. If the two look good together, meaning that they are about the same scale, then go ahead and buy it. 

Walt

 

Walt,

 

Always an interesting topic.

 

On that scale for LGB; LGB advertised for years and years that they build to 1:22.5 scale. That would be correct for Meter Gauge models on 45mm track.

As a matter of fact if you look at the second page of this PDF it still states:

"LGB trains are G scale (1:22.5) — four times larger than conventional HO-scale trains (1:87)."

Not quite factual in more than one respect, but still stated.

 

Tooth 

As a quick check for scale: take along a "normal" 1:22.5 figure and a "normal" 1:20.3 figure to check the door heights of buildings and rolling stock.

 

Hope that helps

 

ER 

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Monday, January 22, 2007 10:00 PM

Toothmark, scales are a bit like fractions; would you rather have 1/3 of a pie or 1/5 of a pie?  The 1/5 of a pie is smaller - but when you start to learn fractions, it doesn't seem right as 5 is larger than 3.

If an average person is 6 feet tall, in 1:22.5 scale he would measure out to be 72inches divided by 22.5 which is 3.2inches.  Going the other way, you find a figurine 3inches high. How tall is that in 22.5 scale? Multiply 3" by 22.5 and you get 67.5inches or 5 ft, 7 and 1/2 inches.

And if you are in Canada, it works the same in metric. A person 180cm tall would scale out, in 1:22.5 scale, to 180cm/22.5 or 8cm tall.  In 1:20.3 scale he would be taller; 180cm/20.3 = 8.87cm.  So, roughly, 1:20.3 scale is about 10 percent larger than 1:22.5 scale. 

E.R.'s idea is a good one.  Take a cardboard cutout of a typical person in the scale you like best and stand it beside something you want to buy.  If he can't get through the door, or if he doesn't come up to the door knob, you know this item isn't going to work well for you.

Hope this helps a bit.

Art

 

  • Member since
    February 2005
  • 1,821 posts
Posted by underworld on Monday, January 22, 2007 10:40 PM
 iandor wrote:

Undie there is one best scale but none of us could afford it or use it in all prcticality and that     1 : 1.

Rgds Ian

Yes!!!! 1 : 1 is best!!! When I get a piece of land I'm looking at buying an old passenger coach.

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

currently on Tour with Sleeper Cell myspace.com/sleepercellrock Sleeper Cell is @ Checkers in Bowling Green Ohio 12/31/2009 come on out to the party!!! we will be shooting more video for MTVs The Making of a Metal Band
  • Member since
    November 2005
  • From: Blackpool, Lancashire, UK
  • 448 posts
Posted by kimbrit on Tuesday, January 23, 2007 2:24 AM

Welcome to the world of garden railroads and straight into the issues of gauge and scale. Trust me guys, if it looks right then it is right, you will have plenty of time later when you have your track down to sort out all the different offerings of 1:20.3, 1:22.5, 1:29, 1:32 etc etc. In the meantime enjoy what you have, you can always sell it later if you decide on something else.

Kim

  • Member since
    February 2005
  • 1,821 posts
Posted by underworld on Tuesday, January 23, 2007 10:11 PM
 kimbrit wrote:

Welcome to the world of garden railroads and straight into the issues of gauge and scale. Trust me guys, if it looks right then it is right, you will have plenty of time later when you have your track down to sort out all the different offerings of 1:20.3, 1:22.5, 1:29, 1:32 etc etc. In the meantime enjoy what you have, you can always sell it later if you decide on something else.

Kim

I think you covered it well!!!

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

currently on Tour with Sleeper Cell myspace.com/sleepercellrock Sleeper Cell is @ Checkers in Bowling Green Ohio 12/31/2009 come on out to the party!!! we will be shooting more video for MTVs The Making of a Metal Band
  • Member since
    January 2005
  • From: Salisbury, England
  • 420 posts
Posted by devils on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 12:44 AM

 

 Vsmith's list
In Narrow Gauge we have:
1/20.3 (Bachmann, Accucraft narrow gauge)
1/22.5 (LGB US Profile narrow gauge)
1/24 (HLW)
All use 45mm track to represent 3'-0" (+/-) gauge track
Just to add the Aristocraft (ex Delton) narrow gauge C-16 and their Narrow gauge stock is 1/24 scale.
As narrow gauge stock varied so much in size and smaller railroads tended to hang on to old equipment it's not really a problem to mix scales 1/20-1/24 if it looks alright to you. Use the smaller stock to form a work train or local pick up, you could weather it to make it look older and well used. 
The bigger lines like the DRGW had the money to equip with a modern fleet of big locos but this is the exception rather than the rule.
Maybe an extended version of vsmith's guide to scales should be added to the pinned posts at the top of the forum to help newcomers?
  • Member since
    April 2002
  • From: Wisconsin
  • 1,839 posts
Posted by Rene Schweitzer on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 8:07 AM

Vic's list is good. We also have a (free) downloadable scale-and-gauge chart on this site:

 

http://www.trains.com/grw/default.aspx?c=a&id=28 

Rene Schweitzer

Classic Toy Trains/Garden Railways/Model Railroader

  • Member since
    June 2006
  • From: Oakley Ca
  • 1,407 posts
Posted by dwbeckett on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 1:11 PM
This Issue ( FEB07) has a two or three page blab about buildings even though they missed a few. hope that help's

The head is gray, hands don't work , back is weak, legs give out, eyes are gone, money go's and my wife still love's Me.

  • Member since
    August 2005
  • From: Texas
  • 182 posts
Posted by MTCarpenter on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 5:28 PM

What I’d like to see is photos of engines in side views and front views from the different companies to really see how they look next to each other.  I’m numerically challenged, so “seeing it” in a picture helps me tremendously.

Not a complaint, but just a wish.  Carry on...

"Measurement is the way created things have of accounting for themselves." ~ A.W. Tozer
  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 5:55 PM

I have had made a figure of myself for my garden railway and i am 1.7 m tall and my image is 76 mm; i only run LGB at 22.5 ; 1 so i guess that settles it.

Rgds Ian

  • Member since
    February 2005
  • 1,821 posts
Posted by underworld on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 6:02 PM

I think you are the only one I've heard of that modeled themself!

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

currently on Tour with Sleeper Cell myspace.com/sleepercellrock Sleeper Cell is @ Checkers in Bowling Green Ohio 12/31/2009 come on out to the party!!! we will be shooting more video for MTVs The Making of a Metal Band
  • Member since
    December 2006
  • From: Florissant, Missouri
  • 493 posts
Posted by hoofe116 on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 6:37 PM

MT:

Now, there's a great idea! I too wish there were pixes of the various scales side x side and end x end. I'd even buy a magazine or book that had that info--for G gauge. Just for my own information.

Les Whitaker

  • Member since
    December 2006
  • From: Florissant, Missouri
  • 493 posts
Posted by hoofe116 on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 6:40 PM

If you're speaking of the Feb issue, I read that article. As a rank newbie, it was useless. Not to denigrate the writer.

Les Whitaker

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Wednesday, January 24, 2007 6:57 PM
 underworld wrote:

I think you are the only one I've heard of that modeled themself!

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

Far from it! If you paid attention over the years, there are various and sundry in all kinds of different scales.

Perhaps the one with the largest "distribution" is Dr. René Wilfer, of PIKO. A likeness of his is delivered with every PIKO "Taurus" in 1:27.

The reviews that have been published on that engine didn't mention if the figure was also 1:27. Wink [;)] Big Smile [:D]

 

ER

 

 


 

  • Member since
    February 2005
  • 1,821 posts
Posted by underworld on Saturday, January 27, 2007 12:00 AM
 Stickler for Detail wrote:
 underworld wrote:

I think you are the only one I've heard of that modeled themself!

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

Far from it! If you paid attention over the years, there are various and sundry in all kinds of different scales.

Perhaps the one with the largest "distribution" is Dr. René Wilfer, of PIKO. A likeness of his is delivered with every PIKO "Taurus" in 1:27.

The reviews that have been published on that engine didn't mention if the figure was also 1:27. Wink [;)] Big Smile [:D]

 

ER

 

 


 

Well, he was the only one I'd heard of....now I know of more!!!

Thanks!

underworldBig Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]Big Smile [:D]

currently on Tour with Sleeper Cell myspace.com/sleepercellrock Sleeper Cell is @ Checkers in Bowling Green Ohio 12/31/2009 come on out to the party!!! we will be shooting more video for MTVs The Making of a Metal Band
  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 27, 2007 8:33 PM

Mate i havent actually, I only said i did to attract a whole lot of rubbish from the liks of Curmy.

Rgds Ian

  • Member since
    April 2003
  • 305,205 posts
Posted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 27, 2007 9:59 PM
 iandor wrote:

Mate i havent actually, I only said i did to attract a whole lot of rubbish from the liks of Curmy.

Rgds Ian

 

Dear Ian

You are such a card Big Smile [:D]

Curmudgeon didn't go for it and others probably thought that you would have had to resize one of your pictures to have something to work from.

BUT many know that you have a bit of a rocky relationship with photo software ..... so the chances were minimal to NIL. Wink [;)] Big Smile [:D]

Kind of warm Downunder, isn't it!? Wink [;)]

ER 

  • Member since
    July 2003
  • From: US
  • 1,386 posts
Posted by Curmudgeon on Sunday, January 28, 2007 12:28 AM

Oh, boy, oh, boy.

I can't wait for Kevin to see references to his beloved EBT as "oddball".

 Boy, he's gonna lambaste you in his next column for sure!

Search the Community

FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Get the Garden Railways newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month

By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Garden Railways magazine. Please view our privacy policy