Login
or
Register
Home
»
Garden Railways
»
Forums
»
Garden Railroading
»
Minimum radius curves???
Minimum radius curves???
8720 views
9 replies
Order Ascending
Order Descending
jnichols
Member since
February 2005
From: Salt Lake City
388 posts
Minimum radius curves???
Posted by
jnichols
on Sunday, February 6, 2005 9:52 PM
I realize this topic has been beaten to death here and elsewhere, but there is so much conflicting information that I am not sure what to believe. I figure if I narrow my equipment list wants down to what will run on the space I have available, I would be better off than hoping for something that won't work. I am going to be using 1:20.3 F-scale stuff exclusively and will have equipment mostly from Bachmann and Accucraft....
Ok, on the indoor portion of my layout, I have to use 3' radius curves in order to stay within the space available (a shelf layout mainly). The largest locomotive I ever see running indoors would be the Spectrum 2-8-0 or any of the Spectrum geared locomotives and maybe a porter. Am I dreaming here, or will this stuff work on this kind of a radius? I also am concerned about the AMS/Accucraft rolling stock working properly with the stock couplers, will they be ok? I eventually plan on having some live steam, but that will always be on the outdoor part of the layout where I should be able to maintain 8' radius curves fairly easily.
Any information would be helpful, and I prefer to hear from people who have actually done this rather than read it somewhere. Thanks in advance... [:D]
Jeff
Jeff ww.trainshoppeslc.com
Reply
cacole
Member since
July 2003
From: Sierra Vista, Arizona
13,757 posts
Posted by
cacole
on Sunday, February 6, 2005 10:50 PM
I'm not sure about the AMS rolling stock, but the Bachmann Spectrum 2-8-0 should be able to negotiate a 3-foot radius because the center sets of drive wheels have no flanges, and the tender trucks will turn quite a tight radius. I have the AMS stock car set and the Bachmann Consolidation and have ran them around a 5-foot radius with no problems. The only way you can know for sure is to lay some of the 3-foot radius track down loose and see if the AMS rolling stock will go around it without derailing, and if the couplers will take that tight a curve without pulling the wheels off of the track or the corners of the cars hitting each other.
Reply
jnichols
Member since
February 2005
From: Salt Lake City
388 posts
Posted by
jnichols
on Sunday, February 6, 2005 11:19 PM
After doing some online research at the AMS website, I see where they have listed the minimum radius of the cars in the specs section. Although I believe the specs, I am sure there is some wiggle room (or at least I hope so) in the numbers. I sure would hate to buy a $100+ car (or a pair of them) simply to test the capability for running around a particular minimum radius. I have read elsewhere that the Spectrum Connie has been run succesfully around a 5' diameter (or 2.5' radius) curve, so I have some hope for that one but I haven't read much about the geared locomotives.
Thanks for the response!
Jeff
Jeff ww.trainshoppeslc.com
Reply
Anonymous
Member since
April 2003
305,205 posts
Posted by
Anonymous
on Monday, February 7, 2005 7:00 AM
Hi Jeff,
Just a quick question mate, where you mention 8' radius, do you mean diameter? I have aristo 8' diameter track and the connie runs perfectly (still a bit of a front overhang). I would love 8' radius but I would be in my neighbours garden!
Cheers,
Kim
[tup]
Reply
Edit
jnichols
Member since
February 2005
From: Salt Lake City
388 posts
Posted by
jnichols
on Monday, February 7, 2005 2:48 PM
Kim,
If everything goes as planned I should have 8' radius curves in the outdoor sections of the layout. I'm still working out all the details concerning this and I am waiting for the weather to cooperate a little before starting any kind of construction outside (and as there is 8" of new snow this morning this doesn't seem like it will be anytime soon... [:(]).
Glad to hear about the Connie running on 8' diameter curves. That gets me a little closer to my goal.
Jeff
Jeff ww.trainshoppeslc.com
Reply
Anonymous
Member since
April 2003
305,205 posts
Posted by
Anonymous
on Wednesday, February 9, 2005 7:32 AM
Jeff,
I'm relatively new to G scale as well, but have been modelling other sizes/gauges (larger and smaller) for many years. In the G gauge arena, I found I had to file the sides of the couplers slightly on my Bachmann 44/45 ton centercab switcher to negotiate 4ft diam (2ft radius) curves. Otherwise, the car following the loco would derail. I also found that my Aristo C-16 (with #2 and #3 center drivers blind) sometimes wants to "fall in" on the turnout curves. Hope this helps. cb
Reply
Edit
jnichols
Member since
February 2005
From: Salt Lake City
388 posts
Posted by
jnichols
on Wednesday, February 9, 2005 1:02 PM
Thanks for all the help. I have actually done quite a bit of research on the subject by calling various manufacturers and distributors and I think I understand this well enough now to move forward. I am going to use the Aristocraft 6.5' diameter curves inside. I will have to change my shelf somewhat, but this curve is much easier to manage than an 8' diameter curve given my space requirements. I have been assured by many that both the AMS rolling stock and Bachmann Connie will negotiate this curve with little or no modifications. As a side note, the 48" minimum radius rating on the AMS rolling stock pertains to an S-curve being used. If only 90 degree turns are used, a smaller curve can be used without problems... [:)]
Jeff
Jeff ww.trainshoppeslc.com
Reply
Chompers
Member since
April 2003
From: New York
214 posts
Posted by
Chompers
on Wednesday, February 9, 2005 6:57 PM
What some one makes a 6.5' diamiter curve.
i was lied to[banghead] [always wanted to use that bangy head guy] they said the next up from 5 feet is 8 feet .
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
[:O]
The P.C.&.M.R.R SA#14
Reply
Anonymous
Member since
April 2003
305,205 posts
Posted by
Anonymous
on Wednesday, February 9, 2005 8:43 PM
All my curves are 1.1 M which i think is about 43.3 " and i think this is about R3.
I wouldn't like any less than this as the trains look unreal enough as it is.
Rgds ian
Reply
Edit
Chompers
Member since
April 2003
From: New York
214 posts
Posted by
Chompers
on Monday, February 14, 2005 8:23 PM
I have a space that is 6' 8" wide, it is a protrusion into the yard. it is part of the main loop.
i have to us LGB R2 track for it.
that is the only place i have actualy levelled and ballasted the track.
don't whant to undo my work.
The P.C.&.M.R.R SA#14
Reply
Search the Community
FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER
Get the
Garden Railways
newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month
Sign up
By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from
Garden Railways
magazine. Please view our
privacy policy
More great sites from Kalmbach Media
Terms Of Use
|
Privacy Policy
|
Copyright Policy