Trains.com

Polar Express Whistle - IMAX quality...

2009 views
9 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    December 2003
  • From: Austin, TX USA - Central Time Zone
  • 997 posts
Polar Express Whistle - IMAX quality...
Posted by Jim Duda on Friday, December 23, 2005 12:39 PM
Chapter 2 in my quest for the closest rendition of the PE whistle as heard in the IMAX theatres. Those of you that have seen the movie (2D or 3D), please share what steamer(s) you have (brand and type - Hudson/Berkshire/Mikado/Pacific, etc.) that most closely replicates the sound as in the movie.

This is more important than the loco type, even if it's NOT a Berk! All I have is the K-Line scale Hudson with TMCC/RS 4.0 and I love that deep, mournful whistle that actually changes "shape" depending on the speed of the loco.

What other steamers sound like the movie? This will determine what my brother will choose as his Christmas train.

Small Layouts are cool! Low post counts are even more cool! NO GRITS in my pot!!!
  • Member since
    July 2003
  • From: North Texas
  • 5,707 posts
Posted by wrmcclellan on Friday, December 23, 2005 1:16 PM
We need someone to comment if the Lionel scale Nickle Plate Berk of a couple of years ago qualifies. The loco sounds in the movie theater were awesome. I assume Lionel used recordings from the real 765.

Regards, Roy

  • Member since
    December 2003
  • From: Austin, TX USA - Central Time Zone
  • 997 posts
Posted by Jim Duda on Friday, December 23, 2005 10:03 PM
OK...one more time before I give up. Can someone recommend a steamer (any brand, any type) that can negotiate the O31 - O36 curves and has a whistle that sounds SIMILAR to the one in the Polar Express movie? I've given up trying to find an exact whistle.

The air whistle that comes in the PE just isn't close enough. The K-Line scale Hudson (TMCC w/Railsounds) is plenty close enough and I know there must be others.

I don't have any passenger type MTH PS-2 steamers to compare the K-Line to. I just need something closer than the Lionel air whistle...
Small Layouts are cool! Low post counts are even more cool! NO GRITS in my pot!!!
  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Jelloway Creek, OH - Elv. 1100
  • 7,578 posts
Posted by Buckeye Riveter on Saturday, December 24, 2005 10:33 AM
Jim, Would a TAS or DD add on get you close? BTW, the air whistle in the PE is pathetic.

Celebrating 18 years on the CTT Forum. Smile, Wink & Grin

Buckeye Riveter......... OTTS Charter Member, a Roseyville Raider and a member of the CTT Forum since 2004..

Jelloway Creek, OH - ELV 1,100 - Home of the Baltimore, Ohio & Wabash RR

TCA 09-64284

  • Member since
    December 2003
  • From: Austin, TX USA - Central Time Zone
  • 997 posts
Posted by Jim Duda on Saturday, December 24, 2005 10:57 AM
Buckeye - It sure is beginning to sound like there are ZERO whistles that sound like a real whistle from ANY manufacturer. Man, I just can't believe that! We don't care what brand, or what type of steamer...as long as it can handle the small curves. We really don't want to send the loco/tender to have a custom sound file installed.

Is the K-Line scale Hudson the only game in town?

When the lights are down, ANY steamer pulling the Polar Express cars will look "close enough" for us.

So, one more time, does anybody have a steamer whose whistle is not an embarrassment? I'm so desperate I'll call anyone and have them listen to my whistle to see what I'm looking for. Just e-mail me your phone number...jim.duda@ni.com

Sorry for the frustration.
Small Layouts are cool! Low post counts are even more cool! NO GRITS in my pot!!!
  • Member since
    July 2003
  • From: Crystal Lake, IL
  • 8,059 posts
Posted by cnw1995 on Saturday, December 24, 2005 11:04 AM
Jim, the whistle that sounds on the steamer with the K-Line Santa Fe Steam Chiet set is great - it rattles the rafters - that certainly sounds like the one in the movie to me (and our youngest)

Doug Murphy 'We few, we happy few, we band of brothers...' Henry V.

  • Member since
    December 2003
  • From: Austin, TX USA - Central Time Zone
  • 997 posts
Posted by Jim Duda on Saturday, December 24, 2005 11:25 AM
Thanks Doug! Is it TMCC - Railsounds?
Small Layouts are cool! Low post counts are even more cool! NO GRITS in my pot!!!
  • Member since
    March 2004
  • From: Jelloway Creek, OH - Elv. 1100
  • 7,578 posts
Posted by Buckeye Riveter on Monday, December 26, 2005 8:21 AM
Jim, my K-Line Mikado, like Doug's Sante Fe can really scream and it is TMCC-Railsounds.

Celebrating 18 years on the CTT Forum. Smile, Wink & Grin

Buckeye Riveter......... OTTS Charter Member, a Roseyville Raider and a member of the CTT Forum since 2004..

Jelloway Creek, OH - ELV 1,100 - Home of the Baltimore, Ohio & Wabash RR

TCA 09-64284

  • Member since
    December 2003
  • From: Austin, TX USA - Central Time Zone
  • 997 posts
Posted by Jim Duda on Monday, December 26, 2005 10:14 AM
I think we have made our choice and the K-Line scale Mikado with TMCC is the winner. He'll go with Fastrack (O36 circle) and either one of these transformers:
MRC http://www.wholesaletrains.com/Detail.asp?ID=20018632
MTH http://www.mth-railking.com/detail.asp?item=40-1000
I'm trying to convince him to add the TMCC Command Base + CAB-1 as long as he's biting the bullet.

Keeping my fingers crossed that the Mikado's whistle sounds closer to the Movie than the air whistle that comes in the PE set.

As for me, let's call this the "poor man's Polar Express"...but, when the lights are dim and you've had a few glasses of 18 yr. old Chivas, it looks (and sounds!) pretty dang close...! (K-Line scale Hudson, Williams baby Madison Burlington cars...)

Hey! I Believe!!!

(click to enlarge)
Small Layouts are cool! Low post counts are even more cool! NO GRITS in my pot!!!
  • Member since
    November 2003
  • From: Sandy Eggo
  • 5,608 posts
Posted by dougdagrump on Monday, December 26, 2005 11:48 AM
Jim, Sorry I couldn't get back to you but I felt like I was up to my armpits in alligators I was so busy Christmas Eve and day. I don't believe he will be disappointed. But I echo the sentiments about upgrading to TMCC. [tup]

Remember the Veterans. Past, present and future.

www.sd3r.org

Proud New Member Of The NRA

Join our Community!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

Search the Community

FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Get the Classic Toy Trains newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month