Fascinating stuff, Lionelsoni, thanks for posting. It's a wasted day if I haven't learned something new.
By the way, Lionel sold those DC to AC conversion units for trains sold in DC powered areas right up to World War Two. I 'm not sure but I don't believe they returned with war's end. American Flyer had conversion units as well.
Where they say If you choose to run with transformer set it to full power. You do not need to do that. I set the transformer where the Grand-son's LionChief train will not fly off the track and that way he can turn up his remote all the way up and still not cause any problems.
Joined 1-21-2011 TCA 13-68614
Kev, From The North Bluff Above Marseilles IL.
Toy trains have run on both AC and DC from very early times. At the beginning of the twentieth century, many locations had only DC available. In rural locations, windmill generators and batteries supplied DC; and sufficiently urban locations were supplied by Edison's DC distribution system, which was practical only for short distances. Lionel sold resistive voltage reducers for city dwellers, to drop 110 or 220 volts to toy-train levels, although the track would remain at a lethal voltage relative to ground.
Toy locomotives used universal motors, that is, series motors with laminated magnetic circuits and able to run equally well on AC or DC. In recent years, permanent-magnet DC motors fed from rectifiers have replaced universal motors, as better magnets and semiconductor rectifiers have become available. But these also can run on AC or DC: A bridge rectifier puts out DC whether it is fed from AC or DC. I have yet to encounter a modern locomotive that will not run on DC, even though the manufacturer says to use only AC. The greatest problem is shutting off a horn or bell which sounds continuously when DC is present.
So compatibility with both AC and DC did not really require any innovation.
Bob Nelson
Fascinating, they really thought this one through.
Firelock76Well, if it's a DC powerpack providing the juice to a Lionchief trainset, how can it run on an AC powered conventional layout? I must be missing something here....
It's by design.
Rob
BigAl 956Actually, modern Lionchief sets run on DC...
OR AC. LionChief & LC+ all run on AC or DC.
I agree and the kids love the remote. Go for it!
You're right KRM, those Lion Chiefs were working with AC. Oh well, why ask why?
Maybe a little bit of J.L. Cowan's magic is still floating around.
See my up-dated post below. Don't ask me how but they work fine on the AC transformers. Must be in the board. Sure someone will kick in with the facts.
https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=lionel+lionchief&qpvt=lionel+lionchief&view=detail&mid=6B8C19A086A4E9F52BFA6B8C19A086A4E9F52BFA&FORM=VRDGAR
Well, if it's a DC powerpack providing the juice to a Lionchief trainset, how can it run on an AC powered conventional layout? I must be missing something here.
Stupid question I know, but are you operating Lionchief or Lionchief Plus?
Firelock76 Which is why I'm not interested in any of the Lionchief line. If it won't operate on my conventional layout I can't use it. Lionchief Plus, another story, although I don't have any of those yet.
Which is why I'm not interested in any of the Lionchief line. If it won't operate on my conventional layout I can't use it.
Lionchief Plus, another story, although I don't have any of those yet.
Better look again Firelock, the Lionchief line http://www.lionel.com/products/lionel-junction-dinosaur-diesel-lionchief-set-6-81031 works just fine on our layout and the grand-son loves running his Lionchief line trains on it. Just set the AC transformer to where he can't drive it over the side and let him go. He is three years old.
Actually, modern Lionchief sets run on DC. They come with a DC power brick.
September 8, 2011:
"Yes, you should be able to do that. However, unless you also install an e-unit, he will be limited to one direction of travel.
"You could instead wire the bridge rectifier between the transformer and the track, with a reversing switch between the rectifier and the track. Then you will retain the train's ability to reverse. However, this may cause complications when running his other trains when it is set up for DC."
lionelsoni But with loss of direction control.
But with loss of direction control.
That is a good one Bob, you are the one that told me how to do it on the 1983 Commando Assult Train Set I got for my grand-son and you never mentioned that at that time and seemed proud of your suggestion. It worked for me.
These sets mainly where Lionels answer ( or should I say general Mills) for a low cost set to get out to the public.
They can be nice, Most collectors I know anyway, don't really want them because they are DC.
For table top loop as you said they are a ideal set(s)
Life's hard, even harder if your stupid John Wayne
http://rtssite.shutterfly.com/
Gargraves track would be nice to use with those cars, the Gargraves track lasts a long time. One thing I have found out with Gargraves switches is that they don't last all too long, one switch motor gave a problem and another switch track the rail looks like it is breaking in half on the switch.
If you can afford it try to use Ross Custom switches as they are better then Gargraves switches. You may have to cut the Ross switch down some to fit your layout.
Lee
No quirks I've ever heard of with Lionel DC. The 2 DC engines I have are very smooth performers.
Trains, trains, wonderful trains. The more you get, the more you toot!
I picked up two of these sets, a docksider set, and one yesterday, a Disney mickey mouse train set, I plan to weather them heavily and build a small two track O microlayout with Gargraves 3 rail flex.
Anything quirky about these sets that I should know about? I read not to double head them, which I don't plan to do. This will be a simple two oval tabletop layout for displaying at train shows.
Have fun with your trains
Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.
Get the Classic Toy Trains newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month