A model is built "to scale" if it is built "according to the proportions of an established scale of measurement" (Merriam-Webster). I believe that the 773 and all the Lionel F3s substantially meet that description. It has nothing to do with the level of detail.
The Merriam-Webster definition is one thing. Its common for special interest groups to have their own language and definitions. In the world of Lionel, a 773 would be considered semi-scale by almost all experienced collectors and operators.
Bob Nelson
I did not get a manual or a little plaque for my case with my MIB S-2.
:(
"The CC Hudson is scale."
In length yes, but I was referring to the fact that the 773 NYC from the CC I is a reproduction of a postwar Lionel toy locomotive, not an attempt at a year 2000 hi-rail locomotive, in terms of detail and appearance. By the way, this isn't meant as a negative comment as I have and love all the CC I and II locos, toy and scale.
Trying to update my avatar since 2020
MartyE and Kodi the Husky Dog! ( 3/31/90-9/28/04 ) www.MartyE.com My O Gauge Web Page and Home of Kodiak Junction!
laz 57 wrote: nblum wrote: The Century Club #1 from 1996-2000 were all repros of top of the line Lionel postwar locos (Hudson, Berkshire, Turbine, GG1, F3s), thus traditional O gauge (O31) and not scale. The F3s are near scale size. CC #2 from 2001-2005 (Niagara, UP M10000, FM Trainmaster, Empire State Express, and PRR Sharknoses) were all scale size locos.The CC Hudson is scale. It measures 24.5 inches. Negociates 0-42 curves. Sounds great too, best whistle that I have heard. I love running it.laz57
nblum wrote: The Century Club #1 from 1996-2000 were all repros of top of the line Lionel postwar locos (Hudson, Berkshire, Turbine, GG1, F3s), thus traditional O gauge (O31) and not scale. The F3s are near scale size. CC #2 from 2001-2005 (Niagara, UP M10000, FM Trainmaster, Empire State Express, and PRR Sharknoses) were all scale size locos.
The Century Club #1 from 1996-2000 were all repros of top of the line Lionel postwar locos (Hudson, Berkshire, Turbine, GG1, F3s), thus traditional O gauge (O31) and not scale. The F3s are near scale size.
CC #2 from 2001-2005 (Niagara, UP M10000, FM Trainmaster, Empire State Express, and PRR Sharknoses) were all scale size locos.
The CC Hudson is scale. It measures 24.5 inches. Negociates 0-42 curves. Sounds great too, best whistle that I have heard. I love running it.
laz57
The 773 can actually negotiate 0-31.
Thanks to both. I run the traditional size stuff and am always looking for good locos that are TMC and not to big.
Jim
CC #2 from 2001-2005 (Niagara, UP M10000, FM Trainmaster, Empire State Express, and PRR Sharknoses) were all scale size locos. Note added: The CC II locos are all intended as scale models in the hi-rail, not the toy train tradition of CC I locos. They are meticulously detailed and painted as scale models.
Are all of these locomotives traditional size as opposed to scale?
Thanks,
Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.
Get the Classic Toy Trains newsletter delivered to your inbox twice a month