Trains.com

New hope for Penn Station (redux)

2483 views
27 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    July 2006
  • 1,286 posts
New hope for Penn Station (redux)
Posted by NKP guy on Thursday, November 4, 2021 7:58 AM

   Gov. Hochul intends to re-make the passenger concourse...and maybe give the station an entirely new name.

   "She said she thought the station should be renamed, possibly after a New Yorker, rather than for a 'neighboring state.'"   (note The NY Times corrected this mistake)

   Still, here's good news for all who use this tired, over-worked depot.

 

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/03/nyregion/penn-station-nyc-hochul.html?smid=em-share

 

 

  • Member since
    May 2003
  • From: US
  • 21,462 posts
Posted by BaltACD on Friday, November 5, 2021 7:39 PM

Sorry David - I didn't see a comment from tree68 - he lives in New York state, looks like everyone else had comments.

  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Saturday, November 6, 2021 12:40 PM

  • Member since
    December 2017
  • 2,375 posts
Posted by Lithonia Operator on Sunday, November 7, 2021 7:19 AM

I think that this approach makes sense. I hope that construction can begin relatively soon.

Still in training.


  • Member since
    September 2014
  • 112 posts
Posted by JC UPTON on Sunday, November 7, 2021 8:11 AM

From one of the other renderings, it appears that the plan includes closing a couple of blocks of W 31st St. to form a pedistrian "mall"...

Does anyone else see it that way?

Otherwise, looks like a wonderful plan...

 

from the Far East of the Sunset Route

(In the shadow of the Huey P Long bridge)

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • 1,286 posts
Posted by NKP guy on Sunday, November 7, 2021 9:38 AM

   (deleted)

Moderator
  • Member since
    May 2009
  • From: Waukesha, WI
  • 1,631 posts
Posted by Steven Otte on Tuesday, November 9, 2021 1:12 PM

Please do not copy-and-paste articles from copyrighted sources. Thanks.

--
Steven Otte, Model Railroader associate editor
sotte@kalmbach.com

  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Thursday, November 11, 2021 11:08 AM

Steve:  If you are referruing to my posting, I did not see anything about a copyright and  believed it was a New York State public announcement (incuding the picture I posted), not a periodical publication.  Since it is not preserved in my computer, I am asking you to enlighten me.  What publivcation?  Was it Railway Age. forwarded to me with thyat information missing?

Occasionally, a specific railfan will send me copyrighted material of his, and  tell me iy's OK for a Kalmbach website, but no place  else.

  • Member since
    May 2019
  • 456 posts
Posted by BEAUSABRE on Friday, November 12, 2021 1:28 AM

NKP guy
 "She said she thought the station should be renamed, possibly after a New Yorker, rather than for a 'neighboring state.'"

Yeah, something catchy like The Governor Kathy Hochul Railroad Terminal

Never mind that she's fighting a century of usage and custom. Millions of true New Yorkers still refuse to call Sixth Avenue "Avenue of the Americas"

  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Friday, November 12, 2021 7:41 AM

Steve, this  NOT copyrighted material, but a handout from the Governor's office.   ICYMI may copyright material, but if the Governor hands it out for distribution, it bis no longer under copyright.

ICYMI: Governor Hochul Unveils Commuter-First Vision For Penn Station And Revitalized Surrounding Neighborhood
New Plan Transforms Penn Station into Modern, World-Class Train Facility 
Reimagined Development Plan Reduces Density, Prioritizes the Public Realm and Social Services, Invests in Affordable Housing, Increases Transit Access and Shared Streets, Activates Pedestrian-Friendly Streetscape
Renderings Available Here
Governor Hochul today unveiled her vision for a new commuter-first world-class Penn Station and revitalized surrounding neighborhood that reflects the community's needs and focuses on public transit and public realm improvements. The plan prioritizes the reconstruction of the existing station while the station expansion and the Gateway Project initiatives, both of which the Governor strongly supports, continue on their federally-established timelines. Governor Hochul's new plan thus allows the expedited reconstruction of the existing Penn Station, 60% of whose users are subway and LIRR riders.
The new neighborhood plan comes after several months of collaboration and more than 100 meetings with community stakeholders, government agencies, and elected officials to improve on past plans and establish a new way forward. The plan announced today will also be subject to further public review and today's announcement is part of a larger public process that remains ongoing.
"I'm reimagining the New York City commuter experience. New Yorkers do not deserve what they have been subjected to for decades at Penn Station," Governor Hochul said. "The era of neglecting our Penn Station commuters and the neighboring community is over. New York leaders are expected to offer visionary ideas and take bold actions, and that's exactly what my proposed transformation of Penn Station accomplishes. This plan puts New Yorkers first, delivering the rider-focused transit experience and great neighborhood they deserve. Investing in Penn Station means investing in New York's future as we recover from COVID and build a more sustainable, livable city."
The current Penn Station - the Western Hemisphere's busiest transit hub, serves more passengers than LaGuardia, John F. Kennedy and Newark Airports. The relocation of Amtrak's operations to the new Moynihan Train Hall provides the opportunity to overhaul Penn Station, eliminating the bulk of the first subterranean level to open up the main concourse to natural light, improving retail and other user amenities, increasing safety and security, significantly expanding passenger circulation areas, expanding entrances and exits, and making it easier for passengers to navigate within the station as well as connect to their destinations beyond. The reconstruction of the station is expected to cost between six and seven billion dollars, and will take place between four and five years after the commencement of construction.
In terms of the surrounding development, which will help fund the project, Governor Hochul's new proposal still achieves the necessary revenues while notably scaling down the previous plan, and significantly expanding community and public realm benefits. The new plan takes into account recommendations from the Community Advisory Committee Working Group (CACWG), which worked in consultation with Empire State Development, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Amtrak and NJ Transit. The CACWG will continue to inform the plan through its build-out, and the Governor is directing the MTA to actively engage community stakeholders, transit, sustainability, and planning experts, as well as users of Penn Station from across the region, in the process of finalizing the project.
Reimagining the station is part of the Governor's commitment to ensuring equitable transit access and achieving economic development. This will be particularly beneficial for users of the forthcoming Metro-North stations in the East Bronx (Co-op City, Morris Park, Parkchester, and Hunts Point), for whom travel times to and from Midtown will be reduced by up to 50 minutes as a result of Penn Access.
Key features of the new proposal include:
New, World-Class Train Facility 
·Creates a single level, double-height train hall that doubles passenger circulation space on the new public level from approximately 123,000 square feet to approximately 250,000 square feet and eliminates the congested, cramped and crowded passageways in existing Penn Station
·Includes a 450-foot long sunlit train hall that is the size of Moynihan's and Grand Central's halls combined
·Simplifies navigation
·Creates clear sight lines to exits and entrances
·Adds 18 more escalators or stairs and 11 more elevators to platforms
Reduced Density
·Shaves off 1.4 million square feet of development from the previous plan and decreases heights for proposed buildings.
·Provides new design controls to protect views of the Empire State Building along 33rd Street
Public Realm and Social Services
·Adds ~8 acres of public space, including a 30,000-square foot plaza comparable in size to Rockefeller Plaza and mandates public space set-asides on each building site
·Creates a Public Realm Task Force comprised of community leaders and stakeholders, which will develop a plan of prioritized public realm improvements, to be funded by a Public Realm Fund, with initial revenue from redevelopment being dedicated to this fund
·Requires community facility spaces that will prioritize much-needed social services for the neighborhood, with a particular focus on New Yorkers experiencing homelessness
·Creates underground loading/unloading for MSG, taking trucks off the street
Affordable Housing 
·Allows up to 1,800 residential units, of which 540 would be permanently affordable
·Mandates one building as residential, which will include 162 permanently affordable units - more than the entire number of residences that would be displaced if the southern expansion of Penn Station occurs
Public Transit Access and Shared Streets
·Expands new underground corridors to the Sixth Avenue IND line, allowing users of the 34th Street Herald Square Station (B, F, M, N, R, W lines) seamless access to Penn Station
·Nearly doubles the existing entrances to Penn Station from 12 to 20, and requires developers to add additional subway entrances and exits directly to and from buildings, ultimately reducing density and congestion at over-crowded entrances
·Widens sidewalks throughout the neighborhood and recommends that 31st, 32nd and 33rd Streets become shared streets that prioritize pedestrians
·Adds protected bike lanes and greatly expands bike parking while reducing vehicular parking
Pedestrian-Friendly Streetscape 
·Limits the size of new building commercial lobbies
·Requires that 40% of every building frontage is an "active use" such as retail and community facilities
Janno Lieber, MTA Acting Chair and CEO, said, "Penn Station is the busiest transportation facility in the City, with six subway lines, countless bus routes, and soon four railroads, and we've been waiting generations for Penn Station to be upgraded. I am thrilled the Governor has decided to put an end to decades of delay and is insisting that we fix Penn Station now."
Empire State Development Chief Operating Officer and Executive Deputy Commissioner Kevin Younis said, "Governor Hochul's vision for a world-class Penn Station and revitalized surrounding neighborhood will not only enhance the commuter experience for passengers in New York City and the Northeast Corridor, but it will also be a forceful catalyst for New York State's economic development. The integration of commercial growth and public transportation is a model of sustainable growth for the future, and I applaud our partners in government and the private sector for this plan that will spur a revitalization of the business district surrounding the station for decades to come." 
Congressman Jerrold Nadler said, "I applaud Governor Hochul for understanding how vital Penn Station and Gateway are to the region, and providing clear direction that the transportation aspects of this project must come first. I look forward to working with the MTA, Amtrak & New Jersey Transit on how to turn this new momentum into a consensus-driven Penn Station design and shovels in the ground."
Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney said, "Governor Hochul is working hard to address the mass transit needs of New Yorkers and regional commuters alike. I will continue to work with her, community members, and my colleagues in government to ensure the best possible design for the new Penn Station."
Congressman Ritchie Torres said, "It is long past time for Penn Station to be brought into the 21st century and I applaud Governor Hochul's work to make this project a reality. A modernized Penn Station with access to and from the Bronx will bring working families shorter commute times as well as much needed access to jobs, healthcare, and education. New Yorkers deserve quality and reliable mass transit and I look forward to working with Governor Hochul to ensure Penn Station is equipped to bring our city into the future."
Senator Brad Hoylman said, "I'm extremely pleased to see the long overdue reconstruction of Penn Station as the central focus of Governor Hochul's revised Empire Station plans.  I especially appreciate the Governor's commitment to community and stakeholder engagement and am hopeful that this project will help address the neighborhood's urgent need for supportive housing and services for people struggling with addiction and mental illness."
Senator Liz Krueger, Chair, New York State Senate Finance Committee said, "I am glad to see that Governor Hochul has taken a hard look at the previous plan for the Penn Station area, and listened to the concerns of the community and local officials. Her new plan is much more appropriate, and focuses first on the needs of the New York commuters who have to navigate Penn Station every day, ensuring improved access to and from the station as well as between trains and subways. I look forward to continuing to work with the governor, her administration, and community stakeholders to deliver the best plan for the future of this community, our city, and our region."
Senator Leroy Comrie, Chair, New York State Senate Committee on Corporations, Authorities, and Commissions said, "I want to thank Governor Hochul and her team for making the correct decision to pivot on the Penn Station project, focusing on what's really important which is improving existing Penn to meet the needs of the riders and the community. I appreciate that she's going to enhance the ability of the community to have input with immediate public hearings to ensure that the proper density, the maximum amount of affordable housing, and that maximum access can be achieved in and around the new Penn Station." 
Senator Kevin Thomas said, "Penn Station has long provided a vital economic and social connection between Long Island and New York City. Upgrading and revitalizing this essential transportation center is a commonsense step that will bring huge economic benefits to our region and improve the lives of thousands of Long Islanders who rely on Penn Station every day. I look forward to working alongside Governor Hochul on this and other critical infrastructure projects that will help New York come back even stronger in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic."
Senator Anna M. Kaplan said, "Long Islanders have suffered with atrocious conditions at Penn Station for decades now, and the problems are far too great to be addressed by simple renovations alone. The vision for an entirely new Penn Station that will dramatically improve the daily commute for hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers is a game changer for our region, and something that must move forward expeditiously as we work to build back better from the pandemic era. I applaud Governor Hochul for her vision to fix the mistakes of prior generations through this transformative investment in world-class mass transit infrastructure, and I look forward to working with all the stakeholders involved to see this project through its successful completion." 
Senator John Brooks said, "The commuter traffic that flows through Penn Station is an essential aspect of Long Island's economy and our way of life. What has always been needed is strong, competent, and cooperative leadership to realize the vision of a 21st century Penn Station that meets the standards of the infrastructure capital of the nation. I can't thank Governor Hochul enough for her commitment and vision to reimagining a transit hub worthy of the communities it serves."
Assemblymember Richard Gottfried said, "I welcome Governor Hochul's decision to make the re-doing of the existing Penn Station a priority, and her commitment to work with the local community and stakeholders to make sure it is done right."
Assemblymember Judy Griffin said, "I am grateful that Governor Kathy Hochul is putting Long Island riders first and is prioritizing Penn Station with the announcement of this new Penn Station Proposal. I hear from the many LIRR commuters, residing in Assembly District 21 regularly, that they need to be prioritized at Penn Station. For the expensive cost of commuting, riders need to be provided with a safe and reliable commute and enhancing Penn Station to provide more light, more space, and accessibility will be a welcome relief to commuters. Although we have the impressive Gateway and Penn Expansion projects, it is essential that we have a proposal that focuses on making Penn Station and the surrounding area  up to par for our commuters, with the community's input included for a collaborative approach between MTA, ESD, riders, and the community involved. "
Assemblymember Fred Thiele said, "I commend Governor Hochul for taking bold decisive action to create a reimagined Penn Station that welcomes Long Island commuters and continues to serve as an important transportation hub for commuters from all areas, including Long Island's East End." 
Assemblymember Michael Benedetto said, "With the approaching advent of Penn Station Access and my Bronx constituents having direct access to mid-town Manhattan using Metro-North, I can only hope they'd arrive at a facility that is appropriate for the number one city in the world. I applaud Governor Hochul for her vision to create a modern day train hall where the existing Penn Station is today. This will be a benefit for all constituents, befitting the greatness of New York."
Assemblymember Amy Paulin, Chair, New York State Assembly Committee on Corporations, Authorities, and Commissions said, "Public transportation is essential to the lives and livelihoods of our region's residents and economy. A renovation of Penn Station would give a significant quality-of-life benefit to the over 500,000 commuters to New York City including Metro-North riders when Penn Station Access is completed. It would also support reverse commuters, benefitting New York's job market and economy. The way to build up and maintain ridership is to transform major hubs like Penn Station to serve customer needs beyond catching the train."
Assemblymember Taylor Darling said, "Constituents from my community and the whole of Long Island commute to Penn State on a daily basis. It is great news to hear that all commuters who use Penn Station will be welcomed in the future, to the city by a brand new state of the art station. This is a great announcement for the State of New York!"
Assemblymember Charles Lavine said, "I salute Governor Hochul and her team for their visionary improvements to Penn Station and its surrounding area.  Long Islanders have for too long been inconvenienced by the aging and cramped current rendition of Penn Station, when completed, this new transit hub will make traveling to and from the city a far greater experience."
Assemblymember Nader Sayegh said, "A Metro-North line going right to Penn Station will give Westchester commuters more ways to get to their destination in New York City, while at the same time, boosting both the Westchester and New York City economies. Our residents will take advantage of greatly improved reverse commute opportunities. Our gratitude to Governor Hochul and our fellow State Legislators who together with the M.T.A. worked tirelessly to promote this initiative which will impact our region for the next 100 years."
Assemblymember Phil Ramos said, "Penn Station is the essential juncture connecting Long Islanders and all we have to offer to New York City, but has over the years offered less than adequate service to the thousands of commuters it serves every day. Governor Hochul's plan for expanded rail capacity and a rider-focused experience is everything we could have asked for and I commend her administration for its responsiveness and service to my district."
Assemblymember Gina L. Sillitti said, "I am grateful to Governor Hochul for her review of the Penn Station project and the surrounding development. Having such a focused and thoughtful approach to improving access to the hub of transportation is essential. This will greatly improve the commuters experience to visit out great city."
Assemblymember Dan Quart said, "A complete renovation of Penn Station has been long overdue. Governor Hochul's revised plan prioritizes that need while also taking into account real community concerns over a lack of public space. New Yorkers deserve a modern, welcoming, and accessible transit hub designed for them, and I look forward to working with the Governor to realize that vision."
Manhattan Borough President Gale A. Brewer said, "I commend Governor Hochul for announcing that critical Penn Station improvements are moving ahead and will be will be taking precedence in the state's plan for the neighborhood. Penn Station improvements are long overdue and will improve our region's transit infrastructure. I look forward to working with the state on the plan's financing, open space, collaboration, and engagement with the community."
Bronx Borough President Ruben Diaz Jr. said, "I applaud Governor Hochul's vision for a new commuter-first world-class Penn Station. With the needs of the modern economy in mind, this plan includes innovative solutions to everyday problems facing commuters and will help us as we recover from the COVID-19 pandemic. With the coming of Penn Station Access, which will bring four new Metro-North stations to the East Bronx, this plan will allow Bronxites access to a train hall that's navigable, safe, and user-friendly."
Nassau County Executive Laura Curran said, "I thank Governor Hochul for making this project a priority for the tens of thousands of Long Islanders who will benefit from a reimagined Penn Station. I believe renovations at Penn Station are long overdue and these design changes can help speed up the building process."
Suffolk County Executive Steve Bellone said, "Long Islanders and all New Yorkers deserve a Penn Station that is a first class transportation facility. This plan hits the right note by focusing on transportation improvements and smart growth." 
Westchester County Executive George Latimer said, "We have been eagerly waiting for Penn Station Access, and now the announcement of Penn Station Reconstruction is further adding to our enthusiasm.  For Westchester's residents who live along the Sound Shore this is a game changer when it comes to commuting- and one a long time in the making.  The Governor's plan is taking Penn Station Access a step further by giving these commuters a well-deserved world-class modern train hall.  I am thankful to the Governor and to the MTA and for their hard work on this important project."
Councilmember Kevin Riley said, "The announcement today from Governor Hochul reaffirms her administration's commitment to improving transportation options and access for my community in the 12th District. I applaud her vision to redevelop Penn Station, bringing an open and easy to navigate train hall. When Penn Station Access comes online, it will provide some necessary investments to the subway infrastructure, which will help provide the improved service that our constituents deserve and rely on daily. I look forward to working with the Governor and the MTA to make this a reality." 
REBNY President James Whelan said, "Improving the experience in and around Penn Station will benefit millions of City residents and transit riders. Governor Hochul is to be applauded for moving ahead on that front as well as pursuing smart, transit-oriented development around one of the world's most important transportation hubs."
Kathryn Wylde, President and CEO of the Partnership for New York City said,"The redevelopment of this major transit hub and the surrounding area is badly needed and long overdue. We thank Governor Hochul for her prompt action to move forward with a project that is critical to the future of our city and region."
Carlo A. Scissura, President and CEO of the New York Building Congress said,"New York will never reach its full potential unless we rebuild Penn Station. New York commuters deserve a world-class train hub that welcomes them into the heart of the city, with the capacity to handle more riders from the Metro-North expansion and the Gateway Program. The New York Building Congress applauds Governor Hochul's commitment to rebuilding Penn Station, with a focus on a vibrant surrounding community, the creation of affordable housing, increased open public space and reduced sidewalk congestion with a connection to Herald Square to ensure that New Yorkers from outside of Manhattan have a seamless commute. Building is one of the best ways to get out of a crisis, and the new Penn Station will be a main stop on our journey to recovery."
Elizabeth Goldstein, President, The Municipal Art Society of New York said, "We are delighted that Governor Hochul is driving the Empire Station Complex project forward with existing Penn Station prioritized and other public benefits at the forefront.  New York City deserves a train station that is elegant, coherent and efficient, supported by a strong, thoughtfully designed public realm and a multi-faceted neighborhood born out of deep collaboration with the public."
Tom Wright, President and CEO, Regional Plan Association said, "Governor Hochul's decision to move forward to renovate and expand Penn Station demonstrates her leadership and commitment to achieving a once-in-a-generation opportunity. RPA has supported building the Gateway project and fixing Penn Station for decades - and recent poll results show the public supports this as well. Now is the time to move ahead; we need all the components of this vital project to proceed as quickly as possible. Working together, it is possible to deliver an attractive, safe, modern, accessible and unified Penn Station for all New Yorkers and the entire metropolitan region."
Renae Reynolds, Executive Director of Tri-State Transportation Campaign said,"We commend Governor Hochul for advancing her vision of a user-friendly and welcoming Penn Station with better accessibility and improved circulation. Governor Hochul has shown she is open to the engagement and input of stakeholders and the public. We look forward to working with the governors of New York and New Jersey, Amtrak, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, and New Jersey Transit, to implement a comprehensive plan and vision for Penn Station that meets the entire region's transit and mobility needs."
Lisa Daglian, Executive Director, Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA (PCAC) said, "A more inviting and user-friendly Penn Station is good for riders and good for the region, and we're glad that Governor Hochul is moving improvements to the top of the list. Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North commuters deserve a world class train hall - including West-of-Hudson riders who now come in via NJTransit and the new riders who will soon come in when Penn Access is complete.  As more people return to offices, their first choice should be to ride transit. Ensuring commuters have a welcoming and safe space to land - with plenty of amenities while they're waiting for their trains - will help get them back onboard.  They, along with subway riders who stream into and out of Penn Station will benefit from the new entrances and pedestrian spaces that will be developed from input from all involved stakeholders. The first place commuters see when they pull into New York City should be inviting, and we see that in plans for the new Penn Station. We're looking forward to these timely improvements that have riders in mind and will indeed be a treat to behold." 
Gary LaBarbera, President, Building and Construction Trades Council of Greater New York said, "This plan to transform Penn Station into a 21st century hub of transportation and opportunity will generate countless middle-class careers with benefits for our hardworking tradesmen and tradeswomen and spur investment that not only puts New York's economy on the path to recovery but builds for our future," said Gary LaBarbera, President of the Building and Construction Trades Council of Greater New York. "We thank Governor Hochul for her effective leadership in moving this ambitious plan forward and are prepared to get to work to build this New York City gateway."
Kyle Bragg, President, 32BJ said, "Our 32BJ members support the Empire Station complex proposal, which we believe will rebuild confidence in New York City by investing in our commercial core and transportation infrastructure. We are pleased that the State is moving forward with a plan we expect will yield hundreds of good prevailing wage jobs for building service workers and much-needed affordable housing, and we look forward to continuing to partner to make these important benefits a reality."
Lowell Kern, Manhattan Community Board 4 Chair said, "Manhattan Community Board 4 is very encouraged by the Governor's prioritization of the improvements needed to make Penn Station a world-class facility over the other aspects of this plan as previously proposed.  There are still a number of issues that will require a thorough discussion between the various entities and the local community, and we look forward to being a part of those discussions." 
About Empire State Development
Empire State Development (ESD) is New York's chief economic development agency. The mission of ESD is to promote a vigorous and growing economy, encourage the creation of new job and economic opportunities, increase revenues to the State and its municipalities, and achieve stable and diversified local economies. Through the use of loans, grants, tax credits and other forms of financial assistance, ESD strives to enhance private business investment and growth to spur job creation and support prosperous communities across New York State. ESD is also the primary administrative agency overseeing Governor Kathy Hochul's Regional Economic Development Councils and the marketing of "I LOVE NY" the State's iconic tourism brand. For more information on Regional Councils and Empire State Development, visit www.regionalcouncils.ny.gov and www.esd.ny.gov.
About Metropolitan Transportation Authority
The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) is North America's largest transportation network, serving a population of 15.3 million people across a 5,000-square-mile travel area surrounding New York City through Long Island, southeastern New York State, and Connecticut. The MTA network comprises the nation's largest bus fleet and more subway and commuter rail cars than all other U.S. transit systems combined. The MTA's operating agencies are MTA New York City Transit, MTA Bus, Long Island Rail Road, Metro-North Railroad, and MTA Bridges and Tunnels.  The MTA's provision of safe, clean, and efficient public transportation is the lifeblood of the New York City metropolitan area - linking millions of residents to cultural, educational, employment, and economic opportunities throughout the region.
About the Community Advisory Committee Working Group
The CACWG is comprised of Manhattan Community Boards 4 and 5, local elected officials, ESD, resident representatives, The Municipal Art Society of NY, Regional Plan Association, Tri-State Transportation Campaign, 34th Street Partnership, Grand Central Partnership, Building & Construction Trades Council of NY, 32BJ, Manhattan Chamber of Commerce, Transportation Alternatives, REBNY, We Act for Environmental Justice, and other stakeholders.
  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Friday, November 12, 2021 7:49 AM

Steve, for your information:  I do post material from Railway Age and the Jerusalem Post on occasion.  BUT:

I always rewrite in my own style, usually more consise and often convaying gtyhe same information in half the number ofwords.

I always credit the source of information.

I keep the quotes of transt and railway people and government officials exactly as  they are, but generally put all quotes from one person together in one paragraph, rasther than spreading out anf mixing the quotes as typical in the original material.

  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Friday, November 19, 2021 12:14 PM

So I guess the proposal to rebuild the old Penn Station went belly up.  

Sad.

  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Wednesday, November 24, 2021 8:48 AM

Was there really any practical proposal to restore the old station in all its grandness?

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • 1,286 posts
Posted by NKP guy on Wednesday, November 24, 2021 8:52 AM

daveklepper

Was there really any practical proposal to restore the old station in all its grandness?

 

 

No serious proposal that I've ever seen in 35 years of following this topic.

Besides, NYC needs a station for the 21st century, not one from nearly the 19th.

Excelsior!

  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Wednesday, November 24, 2021 9:14 AM

Glad that they will get just that!

  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Wednesday, November 24, 2021 10:07 AM

daveklepper

Glad that they will get just that! 

Dave, did you ever meet Frimbo?

  • Member since
    June 2002
  • 18,248 posts
Posted by daveklepper on Thursday, November 25, 2021 1:53 AM

I think I met Rogers Whittiker (Sp?) on a rear-mileage fantrip once.  No deep conversation occured.

Bill Hastings, Ron Ziel, Maurie Kliebolt, Jay Quinby,

And others

and Queen Elizabeth

and Golda Meir

  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Saturday, November 27, 2021 12:45 PM

daveklepper

and Queen Elizabeth

and Golda Meir 

Didn't know they were railfans!  Yes

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • 1,286 posts
Posted by NKP guy on Saturday, November 27, 2021 1:12 PM

Shock Control
Dave, did you ever meet Frimbo?

 

 

(raises hand)  

I did.

 

   It was easy to recognize E. M. Frimbo.  The first clue was that he looked like a stereotypical Episcopalian Senior Warden.  At 75, he was a tall, commanding presence with wavy white hair and wearing a pinstriped blue wool three-piece suit whose vest had the lapels favored by bankers and moguls.  I’d read once that he was said to look as if he were an executive in the New York Central’s Passenger Department, a simile which delighted him.

 

   The second clue was that he was stepping down from the Amtrak  business car on the rear of the publicity train that pulled into Cleveland on October 30, 1975 to herald the first run of the Lake Shore Limited the following night.

 

   Recognizing him, I walked right up and introduced myself as a faithful reader of The New Yorker, as a railfan, and as a teacher who’d brought his class along to see an historic event. I also reminded him of the letter I had written him a year or so earlier invoking his aid in the fight to keep Amtrak in the Cleveland Union Terminal and not build a new station on the cold and windy lakefront.  His wonderful responding letter explained in patient detail the economics working against just such a restoration. 

 

   We talked for a few minutes until he could spot someone else to chat with in order to get away from a rather over-eager railfan.  No matter.  I’d met and chatted with E. M. Frimbo himself.

 

   We railfans enjoy rightly claiming Frimbo as one of our own.  But that was only one part of Rogers Whitaker’s persona.  He was as well known to Broadway actors and show people, among whom he was called Popsie; he is said to have promoted the young Debbie Reynolds and also Bobby Short.  He was equally knowledgeable about the jazz and dance bands of the 1920’s.  From what I can tell he was a flaneur, a raconteur, and a bon vivant.  His day job with the New Yorker gave him an expense account to attend college football games all over the East, and to do this he rode trains of every railroad, type, and description.  At all hours.  It was thanks to him that I learned to take taxis in the middle of the night in order to ride trains.

 

   I don’t know if he had any close friends, but he sure had a large and appreciative readership, many, many acquaintances, a good deal of influence, and he left behind a good name.

 

  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Saturday, November 27, 2021 3:21 PM

NKP guy
 
Shock Control
Dave, did you ever meet Frimbo? 

(raises hand)  

I did.

 

   It was easy to recognize E. M. Frimbo.  The first clue was that he looked like a stereotypical Episcopalian Senior Warden.  At 75, he was a tall, commanding presence with wavy white hair and wearing a pinstriped blue wool three-piece suit whose vest had the lapels favored by bankers and moguls.  I’d read once that he was said to look as if he were an executive in the New York Central’s Passenger Department, a simile which delighted him.

 

   The second clue was that he was stepping down from the Amtrak  business car on the rear of the publicity train that pulled into Cleveland on October 30, 1975 to herald the first run of the Lake Shore Limited the following night.

 

   Recognizing him, I walked right up and introduced myself as a faithful reader of The New Yorker, as a railfan, and as a teacher who’d brought his class along to see an historic event. I also reminded him of the letter I had written him a year or so earlier invoking his aid in the fight to keep Amtrak in the Cleveland Union Terminal and not build a new station on the cold and windy lakefront.  His wonderful responding letter explained in patient detail the economics working against just such a restoration. 

 

   We talked for a few minutes until he could spot someone else to chat with in order to get away from a rather over-eager railfan.  No matter.  I’d met and chatted with E. M. Frimbo himself.

 

   We railfans enjoy rightly claiming Frimbo as one of our own.  But that was only one part of Rogers Whitaker’s persona.  He was as well known to Broadway actors and show people, among whom he was called Popsie; he is said to have promoted the young Debbie Reynolds and also Bobby Short.  He was equally knowledgeable about the jazz and dance bands of the 1920’s.  From what I can tell he was a flaneur, a raconteur, and a bon vivant.  His day job with the New Yorker gave him an expense account to attend college football games all over the East, and to do this he rode trains of every railroad, type, and description.  At all hours.  It was thanks to him that I learned to take taxis in the middle of the night in order to ride trains.

 

   I don’t know if he had any close friends, but he sure had a large and appreciative readership, many, many acquaintances, a good deal of influence, and he left behind a good name.

 

 

 

 

Very cool!  I too share Frimbo's twin interestes in trains and jazz!

 

A lot of musicians I've known over the years are obsessed with trains.  I wonder what the connection is. 

 

[/quote]

  • Member since
    September 2011
  • 5,485 posts
Posted by MidlandMike on Saturday, November 27, 2021 7:04 PM

I remember reading an article in the New Yorker about Frimbo's brother, who was an artisanal blacksmith.  He made a plaque in his brothers honor and set it on a tie in Cumbres Pass, along with his ashes.

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • 1,286 posts
Posted by NKP guy on Sunday, November 28, 2021 8:25 AM

[quote user="MidlandMike"]

I remember reading an article in the New Yorker about Frimbo's brother, who was an artisanal blacksmith.  He made a plaque in his brothers honor and set it on a tie in Cumbres Pass, along with his ashes.

From:  Narrow Gauge Discussion Forum:

"Rogers' younger brother, Francis Whitaker, was a blacksmith; he made the plaque and chose Cumbres Pass for the memorial site."  


"Under the pen name E.M. Frimbo, Rogers Whitaker, along with Tony Hiss, regularly published chronicles of his adventures in the New Yorker magazine. Those articles were compiled in a book that was originally published in 1974 when Frimbo had documented a mere 2.3 million miles. The later edition from 1997 includes stories from all 2.7 million miles of travel and the final chapter, entitled "Frimbo's Peak," documents Rogers' family placing the plaque on the tie at Cumbres Pass. They rode the train up the hill from Chama in 1981 and scattered Rogers' ashes at Cumbres. On the return trip from Osier, the plaque was installed just ahead of the locomotive. Kyle Railways employees later came back and bolted the plaque down."

"Cumbres Pass was chosen because Rogers Whitaker loved riding the San Juan and was particularly fond of the $1.15 steak dinners. Legend among Docent circles has it that some have ridden the Cumbres and Toltec with Francis Whitaker though I was never so fortunate. I did have the pleasure of once riding with a gentleman who was in a railroad club with Rogers Whitaker."

 

 

 

 

 

  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Sunday, November 28, 2021 9:40 AM

So is the movement to rebuild the old Penn Station officially dead?

https://www.rebuildpennstation.org

 

  • Member since
    December 2007
  • From: Georgia USA SW of Atlanta
  • 10,520 posts
Posted by blue streak 1 on Sunday, November 28, 2021 7:20 PM

Shock Control

So is the movement to rebuild the old Penn Station officially dead?

https://www.rebuildpennstation.org

This whole rebuilding of Penn station has really been a long novel.   To quote the opera saying.  " Its not over until the fat lady sings " That could be 20 years hence ? 

  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Sunday, November 28, 2021 9:34 PM

blue streak 1
Shock Control

So is the movement to rebuild the old Penn Station officially dead?

https://www.rebuildpennstation.org

 

 

This whole rebuilding of Penn station has really been a long novel.   To quote the opera saying.  " Its not over until the fat lady sings " That could be 20 years hence?

So there is still hope!

  • Member since
    July 2006
  • 1,286 posts
Posted by NKP guy on Monday, November 29, 2021 8:35 AM

Shock Control
So there is still hope!

The patient (the project to rebuild the old Penn Station) is brain dead.

The ventilator (state funding) has been turned off.

The coroner (Gov. Hochul) has signed the death certificate (see daveklepper's Nov. 12 posting).

So the only hope is life after death.  But not in this world.

Not only has the fat lady sung, she's left the building with Elvis.

It's over.

 

 

  • Member since
    December 2017
  • 2,375 posts
Posted by Lithonia Operator on Monday, November 29, 2021 9:16 AM

NKP guy

 

 
Shock Control
So there is still hope!

 

The patient (the project to rebuild the old Penn Station) is brain dead.

The ventilator (state funding) has been turned off.

The coroner (Gov. Hochul) has signed the death certificate (see daveklepper's Nov. 12 posting).

So the only hope is life after death.  But not in this world.

Not only has the fat lady sung, she's left the building with Elvis.

It's over.

 

 

 

I agree. The Moynihan Train Hall serves Amtrak in good style. And the current Penn Station (for LIRR and NJT) is going to get a major revamp featuring more space and light. Nothing beyond that will happen. But when all is done, it should be pretty nice.

There is less chance of a new Penn Station being built, even, than there is of that replica of a Pennsy T1 getting completed.

Still in training.


  • Member since
    December 2016
  • 476 posts
Posted by Shock Control on Monday, November 29, 2021 10:38 AM

NKP guy

 

 
Shock Control
So there is still hope!

 

The patient (the project to rebuild the old Penn Station) is brain dead.

The ventilator (state funding) has been turned off.

The coroner (Gov. Hochul) has signed the death certificate (see daveklepper's Nov. 12 posting).

So the only hope is life after death.  But not in this world.

Not only has the fat lady sung, she's left the building with Elvis.

It's over.

 

 

 

Thanks for confirming.  That was a stupid, stooooopid choice by the powers that be.

Join our Community!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

Search the Community

Newsletter Sign-Up

By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Trains magazine.Please view our privacy policy