Edit topic

Updated your discussion topic below.

Subject
Enter a subject for your topic. Maximum 150 characters.
Post Body
Enter your post below.
First I know some of you will recognize the following post. I first wrote it in the layout design sig just after I had joined the list - so some years back. But it is the best expression of what I look for in a layout; and as you can see - scenery is right up there. On an incredible looking layout I'm willing to sacrifice some operating potential. Parts of my response may be dated, but I think the intent still comes through. I am writing this in response to the question: Does a layout really need scenery? The author of this question thought possibly naught, but my response is on the opposite end of the spectrum: the yin of yang. Before I say anything further, I would like to be up front and say that my modelling skills are not up to the standards I am about to apply. I hope they will be someday, and I strive to achieve it, but there are many, many, many, superior modeller's than I. When I visit a new layout, on the drive over to this person's home, I always have this same thought: "I hope this layout will make me say 'Wow!'" I'm cheering for the author and builder of said layout. I hope they can bring the child in me out so that I itch to own it, play on it, or just be generally envious of it. When I do see one that makes me go "Wow," it is the artistry of it that I am responding to first; not its operational capacity, whether it is free lance or prototypical, whether it is true to one era, or that it has all the "right stuff." This makes me a real sucker for narrow gauge layouts. The next thought after I have or have not gone "Wow" is, does this layout accomplish what the author hoped to accomplish? By this I mean, does the theme extend into the modelled railroad and does it work. I don't like to compare layouts, but I would rather see a good "eclectic - perhaps a little bit too much eclectic" layout well modelled rather than an inferiorly modelled prototypical railroad. In other words, quality rather than "following the rules" which many have told me I'm not to good at...lol. I have seen an 11 year's old model railroad make me say "Wow" - well done. Oh, he didn't have proper staging, the tracks were a little bit spaghetti like, there was too much happening in the space he had, but "Wow!!!" His layout worked for me. I kept thinking, if this kid is this good now, I wonder what he'll be like in 30 years. And I have seen layouts where the modelling was up and down, excellent in some areas, not so hot in others and yet the layout as a whole made me go "Wow!" In the particular one I'm thinking of, I was immediately itching to bring one of my engines over and run it on this chaps railroad. Since it was a Superintendent's tour, I had the good sense to keep my mouth shut...lol. I find I am able to forgive the sins of layout transgressions when a layout "works." Before I visited another layout, I had heard from many that I would be impressed. The first second I saw it, I thought...this is a small layout. But after that first second had passed, I thought "Wow, wow!!" His layout was moving from the "Wow" category to the "oh my god!!" category. I have never seen an "oh my god" layout except in MR and MRP and other mags. The obvious artists come to mind, John Allen et al. Unfortunately, a Japanese chap who's name escapes me, modelling the Pacific Northwest (while residing in Japan) always takes my breath away when I see pictures of his work. For me, if you can pull me into your world and have me enjoy it, then you've got a great layout.
Tags (Optional)
Tags are keywords that get attached to your post. They are used to categorize your submission and make it easier to search for. To add tags to your post type a tag into the box below and click the "Add Tag" button.
Add Tag
E-mail Subscribe
Check the box below if you want to receive e-mail notifications when replies are made to this thread.

Receive notifications

Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Model Railroader Newsletter See all

Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!

Subscriber & Member Login

Edit topic

Subject

Post Body

Tags (Optional)

E-mail Subscribe

Subscriber & Member Login

Users Online

Search the Community