Transit

Commuter railroads and light rail. Talk about the latest developments in urban transit systems from coast to coast. If you're new here, please read our forum policies.

Last post 11-07-2009 3:17 PM by BNSFwatcher. 8 replies.
Rate:
Sort Posts:
Page 1 of 1 (9 items)
11-03-2009 5:42 PM
Offline PolishPower2
Not Ranked
Joined on 10-29-2009
Posts 12

Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

What is SEPTA doing wrong? Anyway I guess I can use NJ Riverline to get to Trenton and PATCO...But with the strike how will I get into the SEPTA Stations to get to those lines?

11-03-2009 8:11 PM In reply to
Offline Sam1
Not Ranked
Joined on 09-17-2007
Georgetown, Texas
Posts 670

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

PolishPower2:

What is SEPTA doing wrong? Anyway I guess I can use NJ Riverline to get to Trenton and PATCO...But with the strike how will I get into the SEPTA Stations to get to those lines?

We had a strike in Austin a year or so ago.  I only lasted a few days.  Not many people were affected because public transit is not a major factor in the transportation picture in Austin, although hopefully it will change.

11-04-2009 7:36 AM In reply to
Offline oltmannd
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on 01-17-2001
Atlanta
Posts 4,384

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

Public Transit is a huge deal in Phila. Center City has not been constructed to have a parking space for every person working or shopping there - by design. The economy depends on transit. The good news is that SEPTA has been content to keep the status quo w.r.t. the historical pre-SEPTA operations, so they have separate labor deals for each historic division. Whether this is by design or ineptness, I have not clue. I remember the SEPTA strike of 1980 or thereabout. It lasted about four months. The Regional Rail and PATCO were unaffected. The Regional Rail line trains were packed with people using the "close in" stations. I was using PATCO with a transfer to the Market Street Subway at 8th and Market at the time to get to work at 30th St. Station. During the strike I just hoofed it from 16th and Locust. Tough part was cold windy winter days going over Schuylkill River on Market St. This was before the days of the tunnel and the Market St East station. It's the same situation now. The City Transit (former PTC) DIvision is out. Everything else (former PRR, RDG and Red Arrow) is running. Now, if I were making the same commute, I'd hop off PATCO at 8th and Market, walk a couple blocks in the concourse, and jump on a SEPTA regional rail train to 30th St.
11-04-2009 8:53 AM In reply to
Offline aegrotatio
Not Ranked
Joined on 09-09-2008
Posts 324

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

 Huh?  Transit strikes are routine in the Northeast including NYC.

11-04-2009 10:06 AM In reply to
Offline henry6
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on 12-21-2001
Posts 1,958

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

Routine! You'd think so.  But when was the last really crippling strike?  They've actually been few and far between over the past several decades.  Midwest and West cities have had more than the Northeast.  Let me ask you, why would you say that?  .I mean give me strikes, dates, and lengths over the past 30 years in the Northeast and compare them to the South, Midwest and West and not just some political line or bias or misconception against the Northeast.  The only thing I will grant is that Boston, NYC, Philadelphia, Chicago and San Francisco have had larager rail mass transit longer than other cities anywhere else...L.A. is just come back into it over the past 15 years.

11-05-2009 8:16 AM In reply to
Offline BNSFwatcher
Not Ranked
Joined on 05-27-2009
Posts 290

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

Doesn't anyone remember "Boss" Mike Quill, (Dirtballus Supremus), head of the New York City TWU, back in the '50s?  He would call a strike at the drop-of-a-hat!  Of course, that was before Rudy Giuliani was mayor...

11-05-2009 8:32 AM In reply to
Offline henry6
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on 12-21-2001
Posts 1,958

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

In effect, that was my point...Quill, et al., goes back over 50 years.  No such labor actions have happened in such frequency in the East in the last 25 or 30 years as insinuated above.

11-05-2009 9:58 AM In reply to
Offline oltmannd
Top 50 Contributor
Joined on 01-17-2001
Atlanta
Posts 4,384

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

Center City Phila is a much bigger employment center than it was even in 1980 when the last prolonged strike was. All you have to do is look a the skyline to see it. Those new office towers are all built dependent on transit - there is little or no parking as part of the development. If the Regional Rail went out, too, there is no way everyone could get to work.
11-07-2009 3:17 PM In reply to
Offline BNSFwatcher
Not Ranked
Joined on 05-27-2009
Posts 290

Re: Why is Philly the only city that has had a transit strike?

My family (father, brother, and I) worked for Uris Brothers/Uris Buildings Corp. out of NYC.  We built two office towers in Philadelphia, years ago:  1 and 2 Penn Center.  Uris was an "Investment (read:  owner) Builder", the world's largest, and there was no draw to return to that city to build buildings.  Methinks politics of that city had something to do with the reluctance.  We did build, as half-owners, the Washington (DC) Hilton, but returned to our roots in NYC.  Washington (local) politics was a bear!

As far as strikes by public employees go, they should be totally outlawed.  Fire the bums!  Ronald Reagan did that with the Air Traffic Controllers, with admirable results!  If cops, firemen, transit workers, teachers, nurses, etc., don't like it, they can walk.  We can all cheer and say "Bye-bye"!   

Page 1 of 1 (9 items)
Copyright © 2009 TRAINS.COM
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems
Subscriber and Member Login
E-mail Address:
Password:
Remember me
My Profile
Screenname: (get your screenname)
Search Community
in