Toy train operating and collecting

Interested in O gauge, S gauge, and Standard gauge toy trains? Are you a fan of Lionel, MTH, American Flyer, and other brands of toy trains made today and in the past? If so, the Classic Toy Trains Toy train operating and collecting forum is just for you. If you're new here, please read our forum policies.

Last post 12-22-2009 6:08 AM by dagison1507. 33 replies.
Rate:
Sort Posts:
Page 1 of 3 (34 items) 1 2 3 Next >
09-08-2009 12:43 AM
Offline Boyd
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 08-17-2004
St. Paul, Minnesota
Posts 1,183

?Menards sets 2009?

By chance is there any way of finding out what set or sets Menards will be selling this fall? In my dreams there would be a DM&E diesel set with 5 PS2 central discharge high side green CNW hoppers.

09-08-2009 4:40 AM In reply to
Offline brianel027
Top 200 Contributor
Joined on 11-04-2003
The ROMAN Empire State
Posts 1,996

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Well Boyd, not to swing a hammer and shatter something, but I do think that would be a dream more appropriate for maybe a Service Station Set and not a department store. Lionel's strategy in placing sets in department stores is to reach newcomers, that is families with children. So that means compromises to keep a affordable price point, and compromises in content for play value.

A set of scale sized PS2 hoppers (unless this was new non-scale tooling) would hardly qualify as either newcomer play value or an affordable price point. Part of that "affordable" price point also means Lionel uses items that have already recouped their investment dollars, ie: usually tradtionally sized non-scale cars**. Though I suppose they could also use the MPC developed Standard 0 rolling stock. Bear in mind the last new rolling stock products developed for the traditionally sized, lower price range was almost 15 years ago, with the Waffle Box Car and the Spine TTUX Cars.

So dream on, but I'd say this is a very improbably dream for a department store kind of train set.

** The new 0-8-0 and Dockside steam engines of course are new tooling, but developed specifically to meet a low price point, and thus I think we will continue to see these items in many more starter sets in years to come so that they have a chance to recoup their investment costs.

09-08-2009 5:39 AM In reply to
Offline rtraincollector
Top 75 Contributor
Joined on 04-26-2005
Columbia, S.C. 29203
Posts 4,126

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

I also remember this question being asked last year and it seems that the answer to what they had or were going to have should I say didn't come out till thanksgiving or later it seems they broke them out late I guess they didn't have a lot of sets to sell. Like maybe just the minium order amount

09-08-2009 8:04 AM In reply to
Offline Seayakbill
Not Ranked
Joined on 07-29-2006
Posts 261

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

At our local Menards they had the Mernards set and the Enhardt NASCAR set out about a week before Thanksgiving. The Menards set sold out very quickly, the NASCAR set was still on the shelf after Christmas. The limited edition Menards flat with the Menards NASCAR stock car also sold out quickly, I got the last one. I agree that Menards probably does not get many of the limited editions per store and any employees into trains or NASCAR probably grab em before they get out of the backroom.

09-08-2009 12:09 PM In reply to
Offline Boyd
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 08-17-2004
St. Paul, Minnesota
Posts 1,183

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

 I would settle for a DM&E engine and anything they would put behind it. Make it a banana shaped car for all I care.

09-09-2009 2:26 AM In reply to
Offline Boyd
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 08-17-2004
St. Paul, Minnesota
Posts 1,183

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Maybe Lionel or some other company could do that for April Fools. Post that they are releasing the "Banana Train".

09-09-2009 7:23 AM In reply to
Offline Lionel 773 hudson
Not Ranked
Joined on 04-24-2009
Posts 83

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

  I would like a F3 or 2-6-4 steam set my self.  In years past at least in the last 2 I got a set from there one was a pasnger and one a freight and boath 4-4-2's one had train sounds.  They are boath good runers but one of the transformers blew out.

09-09-2009 7:24 AM In reply to
Offline SchemerBob
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 07-02-2005
Northeast Missouri
Posts 867

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

DM&E has GP38's, so Lionel could do it with their GP38 tooling with traditional freight cars, but maybe some of the more advanced ones, like the auto carrier, hi-cube boxcar and waffle box, etc. I'd go for that!

09-09-2009 9:50 AM In reply to
Offline Deputy
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 10-13-2006
Silver City, NM USA
Posts 1,256

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Boyd:

By chance is there any way of finding out what set or sets Menards will be selling this fall? In my dreams there would be a DM&E diesel set with 5 PS2 central discharge high side green CNW hoppers.



I like how you dream!!!! If you're gonna dream, always DREAM BIG!!! (or to scale...hehe) 
09-10-2009 1:25 AM In reply to
Offline Boyd
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 08-17-2004
St. Paul, Minnesota
Posts 1,183

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

 SD40-2 would be better. I know DM&E have had some of them. Not sure if they had any SD38s.

10-31-2009 2:29 PM In reply to
Offline crip
Not Ranked
Joined on 08-21-2005
Spring Lake,Michigan
Posts 177

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Saw the Lionel train sets at Menards today.

They had the C&NW passenger set from last year at $189.95 and a Lionel Classic freight set at 219.95

 

                                              Mark

10-31-2009 3:47 PM In reply to
Offline Seayakbill
Not Ranked
Joined on 07-29-2006
Posts 261

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Mark, did they have the separate for sale Menards flat car with race car like previous years ?

10-31-2009 4:33 PM In reply to
Offline kehoesj
Not Ranked
Joined on 02-25-2001
MP53 - CNW Pennisula 400
Posts 104

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Our local Menard's had about 5 only of the flatcar with Menard's race car, but my guess is that they may have been left overs from last year.  As of last week, not a lot of Lionel exhibited yet.  I did not check this week - might have more now.

11-01-2009 1:46 AM In reply to
Offline Andrew Falconer
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 07-13-2006
Michigan
Posts 1,520

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Midwest Region appropriate Menard's O Gauge Lionel train sets concept:

Chicago & NorthWestern GP38-2 Diesel in "Safety Yellow" with TrainSounds or RailSounds

Chicago & NorthWestern Single Unit Spine-Flat Car with C&NW Trailer

Chicago & NorthWestern Open-Frame Auto Carrier with Autos

Chicago & NorthWestern Flat Car with Load

C&NW Green O Gauge Hi-Cube Boxcar

C&NW "Safety Yellow" O Gauge Bay-Window Caboose

That set has cars in paint schemes that Lionel has not yet made. I would love to get that set. 

Andrew

11-01-2009 2:07 AM In reply to
Offline Andrew Falconer
Top 500 Contributor
Joined on 07-13-2006
Michigan
Posts 1,520

Re: ?Menards sets 2009?

Another Midwestern region appropriate O Gauge Lionel Train Set for Menards:

Soo Line GP38-2 Diesel in the 1970-1987 Red & White Scheme. TrainSounds or RailSounds

Soo Line Thrall Car Flat Car with Bulkheads & Pulpwood Load. Same flat car as the 1996 release of the SOUTHERN Flat Car with Bulkheads & Pulpwood Load.

Soo Line Standard O ACF Center Flow 3-Bay Covered Hopper in the condensed 1980-1981 Scheme. The older plastic body ACF 3-Bay Covered Hopper.

Soo Line Gondola with Covers - the old Standard O 40' Gondola

Soo Line O Gauge Flat Car with Soo Line Trailer that has the 1970's SOO Slant Logo.

Soo Line Extended-Vision Caboose - the old Standard O Extended-Vision Caboose

That would be a very nice set to have.

 Andrew

Page 1 of 3 (34 items) 1 2 3 Next >
Copyright © 2009 TRAINS.COM
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems
Subscriber and Member Login
E-mail Address:
Password:
Remember me
Free Newsletter
Get our free monthly newsletter delivered to your inbox
My Profile
Screenname: (get your screenname)
Search Community
in