Electronics and DCC
The place to discuss wiring for DC and DCC controlled model train layouts. If you're new here, please read our forum policies.
Last post 11-29-2008 9:17 AM by Vernon/IN. 13 replies.
|
Rate:
Sort Posts:
|
Railfan Andy
Joined on
09-26-2008
Lewisburg Pa.
|
Which system is right for me?
Hi everyone. I currently have the Digitrax Zephyr as my DCC system. I don't really like it and I would like to get a new system. I would like to have more mobility with a DCC system. I was looking at an NCE system, because you have wireless throttles. The wireless throttle idea seems nice, even though I have a small switching layout, the wireless option is nice because I have to move around alot to get to my different industries. Also, with the digitrax system, when I running a locomotive, sometimes the engine will stop and then start up again. Especially with a sound loco, it will continue to run, but will stop and then start up again. I would like a simple DCC system with a wireless or tethered throttle. Also, it only has to have one throttle, at a reasonably low cost.
|
davidmbedard
Joined on
03-26-2004
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Well, you already have a fine system. Just add a UT4 and a couple of UP5s and you are set. UT4s can be used wirelessly out of the box if you buy a UR90. If you want Radio, then you will need a UT4R and UR91. In terms of your sound locos starting and stopping, that is a pickup problem, not a DCC system problem. David B
|
Railfan Andy
Joined on
09-26-2008
Lewisburg Pa.
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Thanks David, I'll consider it. What are the throttles that are obong with more capabilituies that is put out by digitrax?
|
mfm37
Joined on
07-04-2008
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Big one is a DT400
Smaller one is the UT4.
I agree with David, the stalling is caused by poor pickup between the track and the loco not the DCC system. Solve that before upgrading any thing because the trouble will continue. Martin Myers
|
Railfan Andy
Joined on
09-26-2008
Lewisburg Pa.
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Hey Thanks Martin and David. I guess I'll clean the wheels of my loco, and now that I think of it, that's really the only one that does that? Thanks, Cheers, Andy
|
davidmbedard
Joined on
03-26-2004
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Not all sound-equipped locomotives are made equal. If you gave us some more information, we might be able to help. What locomotive? Which decoders? What scale...etc.... David B
|
jrbernier
Joined on
01-08-2001
Rochester, MN
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Andy,
Full function throttles like the DT400 or DT400R will work. To go radio 'wireless', you will need to get:
The UT4/UT4R series throttles are limited in function(like building consists, and programming). I would buy at least one DT400/DT400R throttle. A friend of mine has a single DT400R throttle he uses to 'program' with and build locomotive consists for his operating sessions. He then 'steals' the consist with one of his four UT4R throttles and hands the UT4R to the engineer of the train. He does not want the operating crews to to have a powerful DT400R in their hands. This reduces the chance of accidently breaking up a consist or other 'pranks'.
The UR90 'infared' base station and the DT400/UT4 throttles use infared beams to comunicate. Though they are not limited to 'line of sight', you better have lots of white paint in the ceilings/walls of your train room so the signal can 'bounce'. Also, make sure no one is standing in front of the UR90 base station!
The DCS050 'Zephyr' is a great command station. The 'built in' throttle is limited, but is included in the base price. The system has a lot of features:
Jim Bernier
|
Railfan Andy
Joined on
09-26-2008
Lewisburg Pa.
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
David, I have been using the new Atlas North Shore GP38 wit sound installed. It's in HO scale. I'm not sure what decoder it has in it, probably Atlas.
|
davidmbedard
Joined on
03-26-2004
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Is this factory installed sound or aftermarket? It is a good lesson. It is best to keep a chart somewhere, where you list which locomotive has which decoder. And it is important to give the specifc model of the decoder (ie: Digitrax DH123).
David B
|
Railfan Andy
Joined on
09-26-2008
Lewisburg Pa.
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Good tip David, I'll try it. Oh, and by the way, it was a factory installed decoder.
|
jrbernier
Joined on
01-08-2001
Rochester, MN
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Andy,
Your Atlas engine should have a QSI sound decoder.
Jim
|
davidmbedard
Joined on
03-26-2004
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Yup, a QSI decoder. It should run like a dream..... Here are a few things to check. 1. Place the loco on the track and aquire it. Pickup the front truck, then the rear truck. There is a possibility that one of the wires from one of the trucks has come dislodged from the decoder. 2. Are your wheels in gauge? 3. Are your wheels clean? David B
|
Railfan Andy
Joined on
09-26-2008
Lewisburg Pa.
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
Yea Jim, I remember getting the QSI manual with the loco.
|
Vernon/IN
Joined on
09-21-2007
Central Indiana
|
Re: Which system is right for me?
davidmbedard: Is this factory installed sound or aftermarket? It is a good lesson. It is best to keep a chart somewhere, where you list which locomotive has which decoder. And it is important to give the specifc model of the decoder (ie: Digitrax DH123).
David B
David makes a good point. It is a good idea to keep track of the decoder and the associated CV settings. If you get the Digitrax PR3 and download DecoderPro, you will be able to program your decoders and maintain a database of the CV settings. You will also be able to work with the sound projects of certain Digitrax sound decoders. I hope this helps.
|
|
Get our free weekly newsletter delivered to your inbox
|