Trackside with Erik and Mike, Vol. 44: December 5, 2005

[Anonymous]

QUOTE: Originally posted by CopCarSS

Exhibit B wins easily for me guys. The Angle is just cool, and the "Snow in the Headlights" look is always a fun way to present the weather. Of course, when it comes to Winter Weatehr, I've always been partial to this shot taken last year up on the Moffat Line:



Care to join me for some Rocky Mountain Railroading sometime?

Chris,
That is one REALLY COOL photo (no pun intended)! [swg]
Nice composition and I salute you for your fortitude in going out in conditions like that to capture what real winter railroading is like. Kudos, and keep up the good work. [^] [:D]
I hope that Mike & Eric take you up on your offer so they can deliver us some of their great pics in your area. [:D]
Now back to "Trackside - Vol. 44:
OK guys it's the battle of the Titans again! Both of your photos are very good and convey the spirit of the theme (Railroads at work under harsh conditions, i.e. winter) making the choosing of a winner a difficult proposition. I finally had to choose Exhibit "A". Photo "A" had much more going for it by having the inclusion of the "human element", namely the trackside workers. I enjoyed the composition (e.g. the symmetry of the shot, the rails in the background also add much to the photo. In summary, nice work! [:D]

[mi-loki]

Definitly like the yard shot better. I spent numerous hours in yards and hardly seen two locomotives with consecutive numbers next to each other.

[Anonymous]

Being a Santa Fe fan, it was hard not voting for A.

I selected B because it captured the head light beams shimmering off the snow flakes in front of the unit. Nice shot

[Anonymous]

I like yard shots, esp B/N, This one is very nice. I work one block from the B/N main line in Springfield Mo, and hear the thunder of the Loco's all day. great job!

[Anonymous]

vote for one fromcol. a or col b

[sporegonfan]

I loved both exhibits, but I like how Exhibit A shows the railroad at work, not just a roster shot.

[kolechovski]

There's just so much more to number 1, and it looks so neat.

[Texas Zepher]

I found it interesting that A looks better in the small view and B looks better in the large mode. I think that is because A is a total scene shot while B is a locomotive shot. I think the cool thing about B is the snow in the headlamps and the angle of the locomotive, but it is finally just a picture of a locomotive. Picture A works on several levels. In addition to the just being picture of trains or a train yard, it has two loco's, two men, and bascially two yards, but they aren't in symetrical sets. The position of the "twins" gives the picture life and keeps the eyes looking all over the entier frame for "other things". The item that sort of ruins A is the small truck in the center top. It needs a twin too, nose to tail would have been ideal.

I voted A.

[Modelcar]

....I simply like the shot B better....Both nice.

[Davidson Ward]

Overall, I loved both shots!

[ValorStorm]

I chose exhibit B. It looks more "Trains Magazine." Exhibit A looks more "Newsweek."

[Anonymous]

It definitely had to be Exhibit B for me. I suppose that I am partial to CP, but even if it was a different roadname, I'm sure I would have voted for it. Exhibit A is an interesting and bsy shot, but B is just so well composed and portrays its subject very flatteringly.

[Anonymous]

B looks like it's moving. I don't know if it is... but it's sweet!! [:D]

[mandelswamp]

Another tough choice. Exhibit 1 had the two railroad men bundled up apparently walking toward their engine while another was at work nearby. Exhibit 2 had an engine with snow on the ground and what looked like some blowing snow or freezing rain. Since I thought Exhibit 2 more closely captured the theme due to the snow cover, I voted for it.

[Anonymous]

I like the shot of the yard tracks best