Trackside with Erik and Mike, Vol. 18: October 25, 2004

[ltritt]

This week's a 'toughy', but I voted for #1. The contrast of the sun-brightened engines contrasted with the dark sky is eye-catching. Also, you can see more of the details of the engines. I like close-up shots, but this time I didn't vote for the closer one because you can see only the front-end details of the lead engine. As always, both are good pictures, tho'.

[Anonymous]

Number 1. I like the lighting and drama. Number two's colors are somewhat garish. Number one would be even better if there was a good train behind the engines. The picture looks dramatic but the lack of cars makes it either unrealistic or comical.

[taylorjj123]

I voted for shot 1. I love the contrast with the storm clouds and the angle of the sun.

[hlcw]

Even though the emphasis is on "train pictures," I voted for no. 1 for the location, dramatic lighting and sky.

[Anonymous]

I like the look of the grade in the background, so I voted for #2, I like those kinds of shots.

[wcnut]

I think both shots are good ones, however there is much more drama and narrative in #1... in my humble opinion. This shot really shows that "Uncle Pete" can look good!

[jimitimi]

Both are nice shots. I like #2 with the background grade though.

[Anonymous]

Enjoyed pic # 2 over 1,as a true rail shot.

[Anonymous]

I had to go with picture #1, simply because I'm a U S Marine and seeing that kind of power without a lot of baggage is saying that I'm on my way to get the "Big Job" done, and besides the U P sports the Marine Corps Colors. Pure intimidation!
"Semper Fi"

[Anonymous]

Again, I wi***here'd been an option to vote "TIE". Both were excellent shots, but my choice of #1 ("big power, no train") was influenced by the unusual aspects of the photo. The shadows and dark sky, not to mention lots of horsepower with no consist, did the trick. #2, while a fine shot, was simply quite ordinary. While thousands of fine "ordinary" shots abound...it's the EXTRAordinary that deserve special commendation.

[gemperfilm]

I voted for number one. I just love the contrast of light and shadow and the way the shadow from the embankment frames the light on the side of the engine. The yellow of the UP really looks good in this shot. This shot would not work with any other locomotive color, except maybe the old CNW.

[Anonymous]

I think #1 is the better picture. (Lighting, framing...) #2 is a great shot but too many working details (smoke/haze, grime...) take away from it's overall appearance. If you guys are really interested in comparing your abilities you should attempt specific assignments.

[Anonymous]

I voted for number 1. As those before me have said repeatedly the exposure with the dark skys and bold and heavy UP ACW4400s lumbering along is a striking picture.

[Anonymous]

I picked #1 because of the interesting sky and sun shining on the engines. Gives a nice effect. just bought a rebel and can't wait to take some prototype shots

[walthuston]

Even though the subject matter is Usually Parked (UP) power, I had to vote for the photo with the best color saturation. It appears to be slightly sharper all around too.

Walt