Your worst disaster?

[woodman]

Thanks for that reply?????????

[mobilman44]

Hi,

I read some of the postings that talked about parents giving their trains away............  Well, "my worst disaster" is kind of the opposite - and all my fault.

I had a sizeable Lionel set up in the late '50s and traded it in for HO in 1960.  In 1961, my Dad said that his good friend at work had a "whole lot of Lionel trains" that he wanted to give me.  Well, I said "no, I'm into HO now, which is more realistic" (or something like that).  Dad kept after me for a couple weeks, which made this 16 year old even more stubborn.  Soooo, I didn't get those trains - which I understood were in the boxes and quite a few in number. 

Well, about 20 years later I began to think about that, and it festered and festered in me and still does - especially since I built up a large postwar collection in the '80s and '90s.  Today, I consider that a personal disaster - one of my own making.

 

[sfcgadget]

After working part time to support my HO railroad in high school, I had a decent layout and a couple of brass locos. After going off to Basic Training for the Army in early 1972, I came home for leave to find out my mother had sold the entire layout. Adding insult to injury, she also sold my comic book collection which include pristine copies of Sgt Fury and His Howling Commandos, G.I. Combat, Jeb Stuart and the Haunted Tank and my favorite, SGT Rock. They were complete issues for 5 years each from the 1960's. I eventually forgave her, but never totally got over it. I started collecting N Scale in 1978 and then G Scale in 1990. Now, at 58 years old, I can't complain about the trains I have now, but the comic book collection could never be replaced.

[Medina1128]

yougottawanta

Called an Ex Wife. Not only did she make my HO collection of trains disappear (20 years worth ) she forged my name on the title to mt 68 charger and sold it for a grand. Then took me for half of everthing I owned. Yep that was a train wreck I did not see coming.

The trains was bad enough, but a 68 Charger!?!?! SHE should disappear!!

[dgwinup]

OK, it wasn't a disaster as such, but it was a "d'oh" moment.

I grew up in New Jersey and my Dad worked in New York City.  I went to college out-of-state and ended up in the Midwest after school.  When my Dad retired, my parents decided to move to the Midwest, too.  Mom called me and asked my what I wanted her to do with the boxes of Lionel trains and comic books that were stored in the basement.

Yup, that's right.  I told her to sell them or GIVE them to someone who could use them! 

Most of the comic books were from the 1950's and early 1960's.  Don't remember any first editions.  The Lionel trains were from the 1940's and early 1950's, mostly steam.  Quite a few operating accessories like log dumps, cattle cars and milk cars.

Who knew that prices for these things would eventually skyrocket?   I looked online at some comic books that I remember paying 10 cents for as a kid.  Most were in the $5 range but a few were much higher.  I've never looked again!

[wyldmanr8cer]

Thats why I designed my layout to have a gap of scenery between the Main line tracks and the edge of the layout. If you give yourself a buffer it reduces the chance of a train that derails going track speed from falling over the edge onto your floor and potentially ruining a multi-hundred dollar loco!!!!

[CB&Q Modeler]

After airbrushing & weathering a brass Great Northern 2-10-2 in 1988  I sat it on a spur track of my layout,me refusing to put it away cuz it looked sooo' purty. YEP' bumped it wth a elbow and over she went....... 4ft to the floor. thank goodness for rubber backed carpet and Tenshodo toughness.

minor damage and she's still hauling manifest freight to this day

 

[ns3010]

Compared to everyone else's stories, mine is nothing. Cost me nothing, minus some shipping charges.

I didn't know that you weren't supposed to run Atlas's new Gensets in DC mode on a DCC system. I did. Fried the circut board.
Still haven't sent it in for replacement...

Luckily, our basement is carpeted, so the one and only case where I had a locomotive take a dive (stupid neighbor kid) was not a huge problem. No damage to the locomotive, but the fuel tank flew off. Still never found it though...

I'm just hoping that when I go to college, I won't come back to find my layout and everything gone...

[leighant]

The Worst disaster was ME when I was 5 years old.

We had Lionel back in 1949 but the best stuff was what my dad built.  He built a three-foot-long truss bridge out of scrap pieces of tin bent into L's and soldered together.  That Christmas, we went to see a movie about the brave pilots bombing the bridges.  And we had these bricks.  The bricks did not make realistic bombs but I had a really realistic bridge to destroy.

The remains are mounted in a place of honor high on my train room wall 60 years later, for (hopefully) safe preservation.

 

[rambo1]

I told my kids to never touch the trains and I turned around and knocked three loco 2protos 1 athearn to the ground . Two were repairable but the proto gp18 wrecked and it was brandnew! rambo1...remember drinking and model trains don't mix!

[apache fan]

My grandsons were visiting and wanted to run grandad's trains so I took them to the basement and showed them how to run the throttle. The oldest did as I asked and ran the train slowly, I could leave him alone and not worry about anything, his younger brother was a holly terror, tried to see how fast he could run the train, so I explained that he wasn't allowed to run it like that, he ignored me, so I took the throttle away from him and sent him upstairs. He complained to his dad, who brought the little hellion back down and insisted I let him run the train, his dad said he'd control him, so explained again in front of his dad how he was to run the train, he promptly ran the train off the track and it fell five feet onto a concrete floor where it explodes, cost me over a hundret bucks to replace it, the kid has never been back in the basement since, nor will he ever again. His dad never offered to help pay for the replacement

[Texas Zepher]

Rabid

(Sorry if this has been done before. I did a search for "disaster" which did not return anything.)

Yeah the funny thing about searchs and on-line help is one has to be thinking the same as the original author.  Here are three:

http://cs.trains.com/TRCCS/forums/t/115137.aspx

http://cs.trains.com/TRCCS/forums/t/37163.aspx

http://cs.trains.com/TRCCS/forums/t/69661.aspx

#1.  From one of those threads: ...  I don't know if this is the worst disaster, but one of the more memorable.

Back in 1985 or so (when I had very little money for trains), I found an Atlas E7 in N-scale cheap at a local swap meet. This was when this was a fairly new technology. The previous owner had over lubricated and it looked like they ran it on the floor through dirt. I took it home, totally disassembled, cleaned, shimmed, reassembled, and properly lubricated. All told I probably spent 10 hours on it. I put it on the layout and began break in.

It ran back and forth and around at varying speeds for about two hours. It ran better than ANY N-scale engine I had at the time. Finishing, I cranked it up to full speed for a final loop or two, when something distracted me. I went across the basement and dealt with whatever it was. I turned around just in time to see the locomotive take diverge off  the main, and head up the mining spur.  I ran and lunged for the layout control power but it was too far away. I watched it seemed in slow motion as the loco went up around the spur, through zig through three tunnels, shoot through the stub ended mine, and go flying off the 52" ledge. It landed and broke up into all those pieces I had just reassembled. Cracked the body, broke one of the trucks, bent a couple wheels.

All I can figure is the turnout (an original Atlas) slowly worked over and over as I was test running. I was devistated and didn't have the heart to work on it any more. Its parts are still sitting around here in a box some where. That is how it survived the great N-scale purge a few years later when I switched back to HO scale.

#2.  From a post on 12/18/2005:

The club had an open house  for viewing by the general public. Unfortunately our layout is designed for operation not viewing, so we always end up with a shortage of trains in the publicly viewable area. To compensate I always stage a few trains where they can be brought through when a there is a break in the normal action.

This week one of the trains I staged was my brand new Broadway Limited California Zephyr. While I was setting it up everyone had to come and look and we were talking about its inaugural run. Later, I had run the train around once and when there was a break in the crowds, I restaged it. During the next influx of people I was on a local (see weekend photo fun thread http://cs.trains.com/TRCCS/forums/t/52272.aspx). One of the other members snagged the CZ and paraded it out. After a pass for the public, the inevitable happened. It either went into the upgrade helix off-track or swung funny because the tailing 5 cars became uncoupled.  They came shooting out of the tunnel backwards down the track. The engineer immediately stopped, and reached in to fix the problem. Then the loud crunch as two of the cars leap onto the floor. One of the dome coaches took it square on a corner and with the couplers and body popping off. At first it looked like the only real damage was the stirrup got smashed and the grab irons buckled. A bit closer examination showed that one of the trucks must have really taken a blow, as the electrical pick up had been crammed way up bending the brass pickup ribbon. This force is probably what caused the body to separate from the frame.

I could tell he was really upset about wrecking the train, and I told him it wasn’t his fault and the damage was fairly easily fixed and/or not that noticeable. I said it was no problem and had I been that concerned about it I would not have brought the train down. He would have none of it. We continued running trains, but he immediately got his wireless phone, called the LHS, and ordered a replacement for me.

[HaroldA]

Except for one locomotive meeting an untimely end on the basement floor years ago and a couple of Intermountain cars taking a header, I haven't really had much rolling stock end up on the floor.  I do remember one time years ago I was assembling a hydrocal engine house.  I don't remember how much I paid, but it was my first attempt at assembling anything like it and, of course, I bit off more than I could chew.  One day I probably got a little too frustrated and applied a little too much pressure to the walls and it literally exploded in my hands.  After the initial barrage of expletives, I just got out the vacuum and it went to that giant dust bag in the sky.

[yougottawanta]

Called an Ex Wife. Not only did she make my HO collection of trains disappear (20 years worth ) she forged my name on the title to mt 68 charger and sold it for a grand. Then took me for half of everthing I owned. Yep that was a train wreck I did not see coming.

[Anonymous]

Aside from toasting a couple of decoders I installed in a kit-built 0-6-0, which had binding rods, I was lucky so far not being struck by disaster.

However, friends of mine experienced real bad luck, when a Bemo narrow gauge steamer was lifted during a train show - a loss of $ 1,000, just because a dim-whitted bloke could not keep his fingers off the equipment. He eventually dropped it to the floor and all the king´s horses and all the king´s men could not put it back together again. Fortunately. an insurance covered some of the loss.

[cats think well of me]

Recently, I pulled out a custom built Pacific Mountain Scale Shops B&O I5 and decided to do some work on it that I'd been putting off for several years for various reasons. It'd thankfully been one of the models that I chose not to eBay and for good reason the man who painted and built it did a nice job. I added Kadee air-hoses to the model and #58s. So far so good and then I had the grand notion to drill out the solid resin casting smoke stack. I start drilling, with a drill bit that is just to big go figure, and it goes fine at first, nice and hollowed out until I go just to far and crack it and it's ruined! So, I "fix" it with a match stick turned and sanded to an approximate diameter. Cannot drilled into the wood piece to well! So, all that effort, wasted. In the future, I'll cut a piece of brass tubing to length. While working on said model, I trim off some old, dried CA residue  to secure the roof properly and slice through the resin ladder! I manage to find the piece, reattach successfully and continue on, but still. 

Another incident, disaster maybe? Is when the front for a brass B&O got lost around the time I last ran it at a local club's layout. I never thought that thing could be properly restored so I didn't bother trying. Suffice to say, when I resold it after owning it for almost 7-years, I had to deal with a loss of over $200!

And the worst for last! As a teen, I got into N-scale for a while and had built a foam lined box. It worked pretty well but I realized that holding one section with one hand wore it down after a while. Actually, I realized this to late as I got ready to go run my trains at the club's layout I went out the house door, carrying said case by aforementioned spot and everything went flying onto the porch! To say I had been devastated would have been an understatement! I cried, contemplated quitting the hobby and going for something I could better handle like Beanie Baby collecting. An RSD-4 suffered permanent damage, though I could have sent it off to be fixed, I chose not too, but everything else fared "okay" with a broken step here and there. And obviously I did not quit the hobby :)

Alvie

 

 

[hon30critter]

Fortunately I have only had one locomotive hit the floor and it only broke a coupler. Lucky!

My worst experience was with a small loco shed into which I had installed 1.5 volt micro bulbs with reflectors for the exterior lights. My less than optimal electronics brain decided to try to run the bulbs with a 12 volt power supply using resistors to control the voltage. Problem was I messed up on the resistor calculation so when I powered up the lights they looked great - for about 2 seconds. Then, as the saying goes - I let the smoke out of the resistors and the lights went poof! Foolishly I had glued the bulbs and wiring very firmly into the structure. Big mistake! Replacing the bulbs took more than an hour and messed up the structure enough that it required repairs to the walls.

Lesson learned! Keep your roofs removable and cool it on gluing wires into place. Enough said.

Dave

[zgardner18]

You know I thought that I would have a much more dramatic story to tell but mine are jus the same as all of your stories.  I too have two stores to tell.  My second one was when I was getting back into the hobby and took an interest in the expensive engines.  My first big purchase was a Dash-8 Santa Fe from Atlas.  As I was applying the handrails to the nose at the table it slipped and fell to the floor.  I think I cried.

My first disaster didn't come to my trains but to my grandfathers priceless Lionels.  I was 4 years old and it was Christmas time.  Grandpa had a display of most of his Lionels.  All of a sudden smoke filled the house and grandpa took off for the garage to find the flames.  Being a 4 year old I didn't know what to do but follow him. I left the fire door open to the garage and ran back in.  My aunts blame me for the rest of the house burning down, saying if the door wasn't opened the fire would have just stayed in the garage.  I was only 4 stinking years old and both of those haggs can kiss my ___!  Grandpa's hard earned collection had gone up in smoke.

[ChadLRyan]

Wow, I feel for you guys...

For me it was butterfingering a brass Shay.

Yeah still rebuilding it, but in a way, I'm also painting it now so maybe it was 'helped'....

It still was a total breathless shock "OH !!!!" moment...   

[da_kraut]

I have two, my first was when the house from my parents burned down.  It contained my Marklin train set, everything was destroyed.

About a decade and a half later my 4 DC layout was taking shape, decided to take a break from building and run some trains.  One of my Kato AC4400 ran off the end of a siding and hit the floor.  Luckily no major damage, just reassemble the loco and a some glue and good as knew but a huge lesson learned.

Frank

[eaglescout]

I'm 63 years old and just getting back into the hobby from when I was a teenager with a 4 x 8 layout in my parent's basement.  You know the old story:  discover girls, go away to college, get married.  I'm telling my 94 year old mother I am buying model trains again and she asks me whatever happened to the one I had as a teen.  I say, "You have lived in the same house for 50 years and it was there when I left, you tell me what happened to it."  Bottom line, somebody got $500 worth of HO for $20 in one of mom's garage sales.

[Aikidomaster]

My daughter came down to the layout one day (15 years or more ago). She had always been interested in trains. So much so, that she would accompany me to the NMRA division monthly meetings and even went with me to SER Regional meet in Knoxville (that is for another story). So, anyway, I am working on some scenery project and she decides to run some trains. She had had experience doing this under my supervision. Anyway, I have a point to point layout. She decides on the new Atlas Southern FP-7's. Instead of pulling of slowly, she opens the throttle wide open. The worse news is that the direction for the DC was "reverse". Well, soon the 15 or so car train and the new engines are on the concrete floor. As with Murphy's law, the most damaged pieces are the FP7's and my daughter is crying uncontrollably. The good news was it was not my only brass locomotive at the time that she destroyed.

[jeffrey-wimberly]

Back in the early 80's I had an around the walls double decker type layout in a 15' x 17' room that used a train lift to get an entire train from one level to the next. The lift was manually powered. There was no power cut-off for the sidings that went to the lift on either level. Nor was there any kind of automatic system to turn the turnouts to a 'safe' position. Neraly all my motive power at that point was Athearn. Mostly F7's, a few GP's and a pair of PA2's. I had just lifted a train from the lower level to the top level and was running it off onto the line while one of my PA's was pulling a freight on the lower level. Before I even realized what was happening the PA went through the turnout that went to the lift siding and headed straight for the yawning gap where the lift would usually be. Before I could stop it the loco and five cars went off the end and crashed to the floor. Back then the shells of the Athearn PA's were somewhat fragile. This one was no exception. The nose broke into several pieces while part of one side of the cab fairly disintegrated. The motor was knocked out of it's mounts and one of the shafts was broken. Upon closer examination I found that the frame was cracked, so the loco was a total loss except as a parts source for the other one.

[Medina1128]

When my ex-wife and I separated, I left my train stuff there until I could get a storage locker. A couple of months later, I found out she had just left the house and moved in with her boyfriend. When I went to the house ALL of it was gone, including a brass 4-8-4 Northern.

[Mister Mikado]

This duh-head put 12 volts to a 1.5 volt GOW headlight bulb to test it. Got a tad bright before departing to light bulb heaven. Turned out replacing it with an LED was a close color match and a rewarding challenge, since the space alotted for a front headlight in a P2K switcher is close to microscopic.

But that's the nature of the hobby. Take a disaster, no matter how small, learn from it and re-invent the wheel in the process of correcting it. We are all self-made men. (and women and children)

[Eric97123]

About a year ago I was running my brand new Athearn CSX Dash 9 and I forgot about my pair of GP-38 running on the track and they met and my beautiful Dash 9 I had only in my possesion for less than hour went crashing to the cement floor and into a lot of pieces.  I was able to get it all back together and it is now one of my best running locos I have.

[Train Modeler]

After picking up my DD40AX off the floor in pieces which had derailed due to a turnout I forgot about leaving open--that my Dad was right.     I should have put up some transparent fencing there.      About 15 years ago. 

Who was the Mfg and what model was the loco you had to repair

Richard

[ATLANTIC CENTRAL]

It's been so long I don't remember having any disasters.

Sheldon

[HoosierLine]

After painstakingly working on a model it was time to 'wrap it up with sealer coat of Dullcote'.  Only problem was that in my haste instead of grabbing the can of Dullcote I grabbed a can of flat black.....and yes I applied it.