4-4-0 Old Timer

[ort007]

I'm interested in getting an 1800's 4-4-0 American. Does anyone know if the Bachmann 4-4-0 or the IHC 4-4-0 is the better model? The IHC appears to be similar to the old AHM/Rivarossi model (which makes sense!). Any opinions would be appreciated!
Thanks,
Ort007

[ort007]

I'm interested in getting an 1800's 4-4-0 American. Does anyone know if the Bachmann 4-4-0 or the IHC 4-4-0 is the better model? The IHC appears to be similar to the old AHM/Rivarossi model (which makes sense!). Any opinions would be appreciated!
Thanks,
Ort007

[vsmith]

I would try the IHC simply because if used bachmann HO in the past and was not impressed by its performance. If you look around on ebay you could probaly find the old AHM and Rivarossi locos.

[vsmith]

I would try the IHC simply because if used bachmann HO in the past and was not impressed by its performance. If you look around on ebay you could probaly find the old AHM and Rivarossi locos.

[CP5415]

I have a 4-4-0 AHM locomotive I got from my Dad. It's close to 40 years old. It still runs great. The IHC models I've seen are extremely similar. I'd go with IHC.

Just my 2 cents

Gordon

[CP5415]

I have a 4-4-0 AHM locomotive I got from my Dad. It's close to 40 years old. It still runs great. The IHC models I've seen are extremely similar. I'd go with IHC.

Just my 2 cents

Gordon

[Anonymous]

IHC is better than the Bachmann, I had both of them. But if want another very good one it is a new model that is coming out from MDC (Round House Products). They are introducing the 4-4-0 in their old timer line.

[Anonymous]

IHC is better than the Bachmann, I had both of them. But if want another very good one it is a new model that is coming out from MDC (Round House Products). They are introducing the 4-4-0 in their old timer line.

[AltonFan]

Didn't Mantua/Tyco have a 4-4-0 kit in their line?

[AltonFan]

Didn't Mantua/Tyco have a 4-4-0 kit in their line?

[Anonymous]

I have old locomotives and I like the Tyco. I recommend you use the NMRS gauge before purchase. Many of the old model wheels have flanges that are very deep. If you are using better quality throwouts, the flange will engage the points and guards. This can cause grief and derailments. On our club layout, they destroy the handlaid throwouts because they hammer the solder.
Lindsay

[Anonymous]

I have old locomotives and I like the Tyco. I recommend you use the NMRS gauge before purchase. Many of the old model wheels have flanges that are very deep. If you are using better quality throwouts, the flange will engage the points and guards. This can cause grief and derailments. On our club layout, they destroy the handlaid throwouts because they hammer the solder.
Lindsay

[ort007]

Thanks for all the input. Looks like IHC is the winner (for now, at least)!

[ort007]

Thanks for all the input. Looks like IHC is the winner (for now, at least)!

[Anonymous]

For what its worth, we have a Bachmann N scale one that runs great. And we have great dreams of gradually kitbashing a bunch of these to build up a fleet of various old-timers in different wheel configurations.
--Mo

[Anonymous]

For what its worth, we have a Bachmann N scale one that runs great. And we have great dreams of gradually kitbashing a bunch of these to build up a fleet of various old-timers in different wheel configurations.
--Mo

[Anonymous]

I bought the IHC 4-4-0 but find the performance "jerky". Any tips on how to improve performance?

[Anonymous]

I bought the IHC 4-4-0 but find the performance "jerky". Any tips on how to improve performance?

[vsmith]

FYI, MDC Roundhouse will be issueing a new 4-4-0 loco in HO sometime this year, it looks more like a late 19th c loco and we wont know how well it runs till it arrives, but just a heads up if your into that wild west RR thing.

[vsmith]

FYI, MDC Roundhouse will be issueing a new 4-4-0 loco in HO sometime this year, it looks more like a late 19th c loco and we wont know how well it runs till it arrives, but just a heads up if your into that wild west RR thing.

[cacole]

I use both IHC and Bachmann locos of every type and have been pleased with both. IHC models used to be made by Rivarossi, but are now made in China like everyone else's models. Bachmann locos have more detail than IHC; both use can motors; but if you intend to run DCC, Bachmann are easier to convert. Running qualities are practically indistinguishable between the two. The jerky motion mentioned is probably caused by dirty wheels -- you must keep your track and wheels clean, no matter what you are running, in order to get smooth operation out of a steam loco due to their relatively light weight.

[cacole]

I use both IHC and Bachmann locos of every type and have been pleased with both. IHC models used to be made by Rivarossi, but are now made in China like everyone else's models. Bachmann locos have more detail than IHC; both use can motors; but if you intend to run DCC, Bachmann are easier to convert. Running qualities are practically indistinguishable between the two. The jerky motion mentioned is probably caused by dirty wheels -- you must keep your track and wheels clean, no matter what you are running, in order to get smooth operation out of a steam loco due to their relatively light weight.

[Anonymous]

I have HO IHC 4-4-0 and have just hardwired DCC in it. Not hard to do. What I'm having trouble with is the DSX decoder I put in. Can't get sound coordinated with engine. Also have Bachmann locos.

[Anonymous]

I have HO IHC 4-4-0 and have just hardwired DCC in it. Not hard to do. What I'm having trouble with is the DSX decoder I put in. Can't get sound coordinated with engine. Also have Bachmann locos.