Athearn transformer

[dale8chevyss]

I'm still running DC (HO) and I'm in need of a transformer.  The one I have doesn't work well.  My LHS has an Athearn power pack, but I've never seen one of those.  Any thoughts on performance?

 

I'm also considering a Tech 4 from MRC.  I'm almost certain that the Tech 4 is better than the Athearn, but would the Athearn work well enough?  I have one from Bachmann that works well.

 

 

Thanks

[mokenarr]

Its just my opinion , but they do not make a better Power Pack than MRC.   I have been using Tech 2 Railmaster 2400 for maybe 30 years and it runs stuff as sweet as it did when I bought it.

[cacole]

The Athearn transformer is made to run ONE locomotive that comes in their train sets, and will most likely be overloaded and overheated trying to use it for a layout.

The MRC power pack is a much better choice if you ever intend to run more than one locomotive at a time.

[richhotrain]

For what it is worth, I have used the MRC Railpower 1370 with great success.

It is less expensive than the Tech 4, but is does have less features.

Ultimately, the Tech 4 may be preferable to the Railpower 1370 if you plan to run a lot of trains at the same time.

Rich

[tstage]

I agree with Rich.  Even though I no longer operate my layout in DC, I still have a Railpower 1370 for operating my lighting.  Terrific power pack.  You can pick one up on eBay for as little as $20.

The Tech 4 would be just fine for you, too, for the reasons Rich outlined above.

Tom

[mobilman44]

Hi,

MRC has been making quality powerpacks since I can remember (1960s?).   I've had a number of them, with my last DC layout using two Controlmaster 20s - the BIG BOY of powerpacks.

You can't go wrong with an MRC pack, and I would not take a chance on any other brand.   BTW, it would behoove you to get the best one you can.  You will have that pack for a lot longer than most locos.

[Texas Zepher]

dale8chevyss

  I'm almost certain that the Tech 4 is better than the Athearn, but would the Athearn work well enough? 

It depends on your definition of "well enough".  Will it make the train move, and control the speed, and change directions - yes probably.  Will you have good low end speed control, will the speed change greatly going up and down hills and/or around corners,  will the power be ragged and spikey or smooth and properly pulsed ... I cannot even guess.  Unfortunately I've not heard of Athearn power packs.  I am assuming they are 3rd party rebranded to the Athearn name. 

I have to agree with everyone else.   I got an MRC for Christmas in 1967.   I am still using it.  I have purchased several more through the years.  Still have them all.  Still love them all.  I have never met anyone who was disappointed when they purchased an MRC power pack.

[dale8chevyss]

Update:  I found someone selling a tech II from probably 15-20 years ago and got it for a decent price and I'm very happy with it.  What I originally thought was a poor locomotive and poor track was actually a poor transformer.

 

Thanks all for you replies.