Confused On Proper Track

[Swipesy]

I have a pure Lionel O-27 layout (16 x 12) that has Lionel 042 switches on. My Lionel trains run just fine on it. Recently I purchased a MTH Premier Diesel Passenger set and the MTH absolutely hates the Lionel switches. They stall the train everytime the train passes over. I have cleaned the switches but after 3 passes back to stalling. So I have decided to build an additional outside track around the layout just for the MTH train.

I was going to build the new track with MTH RealTrax and 054 switches. After reading many topics on this I am now confused if using RealTrax and MTH switches is a good idea. Anyone with a solid opinion if I am heading in the right direction?

[Anonymous]

RealTrax is OK for floor layouts. It's kind of pricy for a permanent layout. I'd go with Atlas track and possibly Ross Custom Switches.

[spankybird]

What is the model number of the MTH engine that you are using[?]

[jimhaleyscomet]

I have MTH realtrax on my permanent layout. It seems a little quiter than Lionel fastrak. Lionel is more robust, the MTH sometimes does not make contact between two pieces of track and then I have to run a jumper between the two pieces.

I have tubular K-line snaptrack running around the outside of my 027 layout. It does not have a built in roadbed but does have a lot of ties. It can be cut in half to make a transition to O track (or 027 with shims). The best part is it can get very affordable when purchased on sale at Hobby Lobby and comes with any K-line sets I buy (for the cars).

Jim H

[EIS2]

I would definitely go with Lionel's FasTrack. I have used MTH RealTrax in the past. The two major complaints I have with RealTrax are:

1) The track can be very difficult to assemble.

2) After assembling and disassembling the track a few times, the electrical connection between the sections deteriorate causing electrical problems.

EIS

[Swipesy]

QUOTE: Originally posted by spankybird

What is the model number of the MTH engine that you are using[?]

Specifically it is 20-2598-1 from the MTH 2005 Vol II catalogue Pennsylvania RR ABA EMD 8 pulling the Madison 5 car passenger car set.