Lionel 2500 series cars vs Williams

[northernpike]

Need some opinions out there...

Looking for 2500 series Lionel aluminum passenger cars-Postwar.

Williams repro cars seem more reasonable in price.  Anyone have any experience

with the mid 80s Williams  repros of the Postwar Lionel?  I prefer Lionel, but if the Williams quality same...

Thanks

Northern

[Captaincog]

Williams makes a good product and it is hard for the casual onlooker to be able to see any difference between the two.

[RAVL]

Williams aluminum cars are difficult to distinguish from Lionel cars.   I would note that the Williams vista dome cars lack the interior detail that the Lionel cars have.  If this bothers you, that is one difference.  The parts for the Lionel vista dome can, however, be retrofitted to the Williams car but the price gap between the two may diminish considerably.  I added an interior to my Williams Pennsy vista dome solely because I wanted to do the project -- I had bought the cars years earlier and it was a fun project.  The painting and decoration on the Williams cars is top notch.

If you are comparing new to new, I would prefer the Williams. My recent experience it that while Lionel is doing a great job on high end locomotives, Williams offers better quality and pricing on the postwar reproduction items.  This is particularly evident on the plastic 2400 series plastic passenger cars.

[wmwalker]

I would agree with everyone here that Williams cars are the better choice and the price point is outstanding. I have a lot of their passengers cars and they are very good in my opinion.